46 of 54 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Important, yet defeating, July 3, 2002
This review is from: Who Cooked the Last Supper: The Women's History of the World (Paperback)
In this powerful and disturbing book, Miles interweaves enlightening, empowering facts about women in history that children never get to read in their history books. I'm well over school-aged, and yet every piece of information in this book is absolutely brand new to me. God was once Goddess? Men performed rituals on their bodies in order to recreate the "glorious" act of menstration? I sometimes had to refer to the Notes section to make sure that Miles wasn't making it all up!
I, as well as Miles, grew up wondering where in the world women fit into history---as far as I could see, "his" story was a conglomeration of white men making all the decisions, while women (if they existed at all) hid in the shadows of these powerful (and often very stupid) men. As I read the book, anger overwhemlmed me as I realized that women's history is indeed that of an oppressed majority---an enriching, exciting history that is erased and/or obscured by men looking to dominate the scene. I began to appreciate the gravity of Miles' task of retelling it more and more, and understood the urgency of her success and the very thin ice she tred upon.
This, unfortunately, is where Miles fell in my opinion. She is a powerful author and can paint a picture like few male or female historians before her, however the picture she paints is with terribly bitter and dangerous colors. Her anger (and mine, and every other female's in the world) is understandable and necessary and is a birthright, but Miles takes it too far. She claims that man is a deviation, that his Y chromosome is a "broken and misformed X". Yes, that is one way to describe the appearance of the Y chromosome, but for her to imply that man is a mutant species because of it is equally as bad as patriarchy's claim that women are an incomplete version of men.
Ironically enough, Miles and her writing are more of a testament to the devastating effects of patriarchy than the facts themselves. To read some of her more scathing sentences should send a chill down the spine of men and women alike--and while she has a right to be furious for our kind, her anger is misdirected.
This is where my dilemma comes in. Much like a person accused of being an alcoholic, I'm either a feminist or in denial of my oppression. But I believe there is a middle ground and men and women CAN live in equal harmony. It won't happen in my lifetime, but it is possible. We must start by not attacking each other. Miles would say I'm being the obedient product of my oppression, but she is blinded by the rage of her own.
Bottom line: Don't fight fire with fire; attack patriarchy and the perpetrators of it, not men as a species. They've done it to us for a millenia and look what becomes of it...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
dated but excellent, January 24, 2003
This review is from: Who Cooked the Last Supper: The Women's History of the World (Paperback)
Rosalind Miles has done a piece of very good work with this book. She does not pretend to be unbiased ( she is very emphatically biased)in her description of women's places in society during history, but with so many primary sources she doesn't really have to be, as these women speak for themslves. I found many of the stories horrifying. At times I had to put the book down because the hatred for women illustrated in the quotes was just too poisonous. That said, I found the book illuminating, if not comfortable. I gave it four stars because the early goddess history that Miles describes is of necessity extrapolated from very limited sources, and also because I think that when the book was reissued in 2000 it would have been appropriate to address the events and changes that have occurred since the book first came out in 1988.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Absolutely essential reading, August 17, 2001
This review is from: Who Cooked the Last Supper: The Women's History of the World (Paperback)
I first read this book many years ago - under a different title - and I was delighted to come upon it again as it had fascinated, angered and inspired me the first time around. Its impact is still intense several years later - it's amazing how different history - or herstory - looks when the half of the population that's been denigrated and ignored is taken into account.
This book explores women's role in life and work from the beginning of recorded time all the way up to the present. Who knew that for 25,000 years - up until about 2,000 years ago - that every known society worshiped an all powerful goddess? I certainly didn't. Miles explodes the myths of 'man's' evolution and carefully examines the ways in which woman's position altered throughout different eras. While she uses 'famous' women as references, she's careful to point out that these stories only represent a fraction of what women were actually doing, and what they were doing is generally very different from how it's typically portrayed.
One criticism I've heard about the book - but do not share - is its simplistic view, that it comes from a particular position with particular assumptions and goes on from there. To me, this book is merely one perspective on history that uses a completely different model of interpretation. Basically, while it's a terrific book, it's still just one book tackling a subject - the history of the world - about which thousands upon thousands have been written.
I've found this to be a thoroughly delightful and rewarding read, as it taught me that to say that women and their experiences are typically not included in the standard version of history is not an overstatement - I learned so much that I feel I should've known already. However frustrated I became at how horribly women were treated and the intense, deeply held prejudices against them, I was thrilled to be seeing history in a new way. I think that everyone should read this book, and now that I've found it again, I'm going to start with the people I know... I simply could not give it a better review.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No