Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Jane's Addiction....bread and spread in LA...., May 17, 2005
First of all, I really looked forward to this book. I read it in 3-4 hours in two sittings and it was very entertaining. Brendan Mullen wrote an extended article in SPIN Magazine on Jane's Addiction back when their Strays album came out a couple years ago. He states, at the beginning of this book, that band members more or less stopped giving interviews shortly after the albums release so he couldn't get additional information for the book. This forced him to search high and low for other key characters who surrounded Jane's Addiction, along with the band and management, in telling their complete story. It worked. This is a great book and gives an excellent perspective as to what Jane's achieved and what they were up against (primarily themselves). Anyone familiar with Jane's will notice a few familiar quotes and paragraphs from past interviews dating back more than 15 years. Mullen pulls from all sources and paints a good picture of band's impact on the LA music scene at that time and the argument that they created the alternative scene that Cobain and others were able to blow the doors open on a few years later. The development of Lollapalooza is very interesting as well. This book would receive a five star rating had the band done interviews more recently specifically for the book. Unfortunately, they didn't and you have to stick to their old interviews which in many ways is good for catching the moment but not as good for catching the band's perspective on their impact over time. Had they done interviews it may have turned out more like the Crue's DIRT. But Jane's was a much darker band, and you definitely get the feeling here. Actually it sounds like Porno For Pyros was more drug-addled than Jane's, if that's possible. This is a biography and almost gets 4.5 stars. The 5 Star books will be the complete autobiographies by Avery, Perkins, Navarro and Farrell. They'll come in time. Long live Jane's Addiction, one of the last truly great rock 'n roll bands......
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great bio of a classic band, February 24, 2006
As someone who refused to even listen to the latest Jane's album (i'll only acknoledge the first 3!), didn't know what to expect from this book, a cheap attempt to wring some cash from an ever-diminishing fan-base? But Jane's is one of those bands... true innovators, and this book is a terrifically detailed account of their story. I was really impressed by the vast amount of interviewees the author was able to bring together in a very coherent manner, including Casey Niccoli and Eric Avery. A must for true fans.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
a fun read on a great band, July 12, 2005
I loved the oral biography style that Brendan Mullen used in "We Got the Neutron Bomb: The Untold Story of LA Punk" (which in turn was inspired by the classic in this mini-genre, "Please Kill Me: The Uncensored Oral History of Punk"), so I wasn't disappointed with this book. There's no denying that Janes Addiction were as debauched and hard-living a band as they were an amazing and innovative one. "Whores" seems to focus more on the debauchery, although I think the Janes tale doesn't offer anything as memorable as, say, Led Zeppelin's shark incident or Nikki Sixx's many ODs. Still, the reader gets a good sense of Janes Addiction' musical impact and legacy from the band's friends and admirers, many of whom are incorporated here -- some unsurprisingly (Flea, for example) and some whose connections to the band I never knew about (avant-country diva Carla Bozulich was an early girlfriend of Eric Avery's?!). Perhaps most tantalizing is the sketch Mullen draws of the larger mid- to late-1980s scene in Los Angeles that Janes Addiction came from: early LA goth, hair metal, Fishbone, the Red Hot Chili Peppers, Thelonious Monster, the Nymphs, local rivals Guns N Roses, etc. I only wish this scene had its own document -- a sequel to "We Got the Neutron Bomb," perhaps?
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|