Most Helpful Customer Reviews
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Sometimes an author must know what to cut, July 10, 2009
This review is from: The Wild Marsh: Four Seasons at Home in Montana (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
In this book, Rick Bass chronicles the seasons in his beloved Yaak valley. He's partly motivated by a fear that the nature in which he loves will be destroyed all too soon, so that someone with an observant eye should write it all down for future generations.
While Bass observes nature in the Yaak as the year progresses, this isn't a Montanan version of the Sand County Almanac. He spends much more time on human interactions with the natural world. Some of this, he admits, is navel-gazing; but much of it just tells the story of a human community that lives close to nature - - gathering berries, chopping wood for fuel, relying on autumn hunts for meat. The bulk of the book lies in its longest chapters, which reflect very human concerns: April (rebirth), July and August (wildfires), and November (hunting season).
Bass also muses on many purely human issues that follow the rhythm of the seasons. He is middle-aged and aware of aging and his own eventual death. He has buried his mother, and some friends. He has two daughters representing the next generation. Like many parents, he worries about the world in which his daughters will live.
If you've already read some of Bass's books, much will be familiar. In this book, however, I wish he had edited himself more forcefully. The book seems much too close to its origins as journal, just reporting the thoughts of the day. It doesn't tighten up those thoughts, revisit them - - or, most importantly, decide which thoughts need to be deleted as not fitting the themes he wishes to emphasize.
This could have been an interesting answer to Sand County Almanac, emphasizing the human role in nature, and the way that a human community lives and loves in a wild place. But it sprawls too much in its present form, and has too much navel-gazing. It would have benefitted from some sharp editorial scissors to release the great book that wants to be born here.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Year of Nature Essays, June 26, 2009
This review is from: The Wild Marsh: Four Seasons at Home in Montana (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
With Thoreau as his inspiration, Rick Bass tackles "Walden West" with this loving tribute to his home in the Yaak Valley, THE WILD MARSH. He writes from a cabin perched on the marsh and uses the calendar as a means of structuring the book, starting with January. Here we get detailed accounts of nature's every breath -- flora, fauna, and the fodder for thought that they cause.
Fans of Rick Bass and readers who enjoy nature essays will take to this book straight off. Other readers might enjoy it more as a "dip in" book rather than a "read cover to cover" book. That is, with his descriptions and ruminations so rich, readers could equally enjoy the book by, say, reading the month they are in or headed toward, then moving on to other books, then returning to this the next month. Here's a sample of Bass's style from the chapter "March":
"It's a joy to be out walking in the woods, traversing bare ground. I love winter, and snow, but cannot help but think of the bare earth as the "real" world. Some folks go out in early spring, hunting the winter-shed antlers of the deer to sell to curio shops and so forth, but I go simply out of pleasure, and perhaps worship: to see, and touch, the echo of the secret deer that have been passing through our forest. It's hard to describe, and harder to explain, the feeling of richness one gets, spying an antler just emerged from the snow: treasure, discovered."
You hear echoes of Thoreau when you see the word "worship" and the words "the echo of the secret deer." Nice stuff. Contemplative. This is not fast food. Like a walk in the woods, you need to be in the right mood to enjoy what it has to offer. You need to be inspired by a whole page dedicated to a deer's antler (or a painted turtle's carapace, or an aspen's bud). If this sounds like you, then I highly recommend the book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not one of his best, July 2, 2009
This review is from: The Wild Marsh: Four Seasons at Home in Montana (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
I have been a fan of Rick Bass for a number of years. I especially enjoyed his books titled "Oil Notes," "Platte River," and "Colter" in addition to his earlier works on the Yaak Valley. I also enjoyed this book but feel he has covered this territory in depth in his other books on the Yaak and this is an effort to just publish one more book.
There is no question the Yaak Valley is a special place deserving of a writer of Bass's talent but there is little new in this volume that is not contained in his earlier works on the subject. Perhaps had I not read his earlier efforts I would have enjoyed this book more and to be sure there are some wonderfully written, lyrical passages marking the four seasons of the year that will resonate with many readers. His chapters on each month of the year contain some really insightful, touching descriptions of a landscape and geography most of us will never encounter for any length of time. However, the book to me is a bit sad given Bass's 13 year unsuccessful effort to gain some type of federal protection or wilderness designation for his beloved valley. Given the tenor of his past books this one leaves me with the impression he is leaving a record of what was and could have been but probably will never be again.
Bass is, without question, one of the best environmental writers and thinkers practicing today. This book is more of a journal than a book of advocacy. A good read but contains material found in his earlier works.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|