Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A mesmerizing, disturbing story, January 29, 2009
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Samantha Harvey does a magnificent job of taking us inside the mind of a man, Jacob, who is slowly losing his touch with reality due to Alzheimer's Disease. The story and the circumstances, are from his point of view, and we come to realize after a while that they are sometimes confused. Things that are seemingly facts don't always match and the reader has to try and sort out the real from the imagined. But in Jacob's mind the events which cover parts of his childhood, his marriage, his children, and one or more possible affairs are all perfectly real for much of the book. Certain thoughts are strong and common throughout the book and others are only touched on and one wonders how they fit in. As the disease progresses, he too becomes more confused, but we are left with only his thoughts, not knowing which are of actual events and which are imagined or tangled with other thoughts and not entirely accurate.
When I first selected this book, I was drawn to the subject matter, a disease that is so hard to understand, but then turned away because I thought it would be depressing. I came back out of curiosity and the thought that this could be a unique story, wondering how the author would handle it. The subject matter is, of course, depressing. But Harvey is a very insightful and talented writer and the end result is a book that is both interesting and somewhat of a mystery at the same time as the reader tries to distinguish facts from increasing confusion in the character's mind. The book that made me empathize with the character as I tried to sort through his memories and come to my own conclusions about what was real and what was not. It's a story that won't leave me for a long time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Quite simply spectacular, February 17, 2009
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
But oh no, not an easy read. I'm used to racing through books, but who can race through the tangled wilderness of a deteriorating mind. And who would even want to skim quickly through the rich landscape of imagery created by this most-talented author...
Ms. Harvey deftly flips back and forth through time and memories as Jake's mind and world erodes. If we are lost, consider poor Jake-- or perhaps your mother, or your father-in-law, or your great-aunt Charlotte --as they wander through the tangled wilderness of their failing brains. Per Jake: "Time speeds up, rushing headlong into conclusions, then it stops. There is something teenagery about it. Something uncomfortable and maladroit as if it has not learnt how to pace itself with space."
And what is the nature of memory after all, when, in fact, the act of remembering irretrievably alters the memory. What's real in Jake's meanderings, what's manufactured? And what's with all this wandering around on the moors through blinding snow or fading yellow light to the jarring noise of random gunshots?
With prose worthy of Ian McEwan and the creepy imagery of Tim O'Brien's "In the Lake of the Woods", and finally and most completely, with her own talent and style, Samantha Harvey has created a masterpiece.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Literate but it loses me, February 10, 2009
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
This story is, I think, an exploration of the meaning of memory and and self. If memory erodes, self erodes or warps. It is a worthy topic, but I never could quite get into it.
Perhaps it is just too much work for me. Instead of crystalline language and tight architecture, it is as though the elements of book were dropped on the floor, swept back up and packaged so the reader is challenged to put it back together again. To quote the author, "The idea of the eternal story delighted Helen and perturbed him. If a thing went on forever, how could one ever know its centre point, where its weight settled? It seemed to him to not be a story at all...far too resonant of the way he is beginning to think, the motifs that repeat in his mind like subliminal messages..." [p.210] This suggests the author's intent and reader's challenge.
Samantha Harvey wants the reader to feel the disorientation of Alzheimer's. As a reader, I was willing to try and work with the author, giving the story and book time to mature as I read but I lost patience. So many of the sentences are weighted with implied significance that felt as though I needed to remember for later, and then disappeared to be replaced by a new sentence with new significance. Perhaps that is what Alzheimer's is like and Harvey has accomplished something astonishing. At the same time, the characters discuss their their duty to each other: who and how to love, whether the duty of being a Jew is greater than the duty of being a father and husband, of the limits of friendship and responsibility for one's actions. This is a literate, intelligent book with a high minded sense of non-structure that challenges the reader to bring his own order, picking up brief conclusions or assessments then reassessing a few pages later. I am willing to do that work if the language, the word choices, the structure, the atmosphere or the depth of the characters seduce me along the pages--if the craft of the writing is irresistible. I did not find that here, although I am sure that some readers will.
I felt the book was much like modern art: clear talent, tremendous intelligence but intended for an intelligentsia of which I am not a member and whose signposts I do not recognize.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|