William Grant Still: Afro-American Symphony, Amy Beach: Gaelic Symphony

Royal Philharmonic Ensemble (Performer) | Format: Audio CD

Product Details

• Performer: Royal Philharmonic Ensemble
• Audio CD (July 20, 1999)
• SPARS Code: DDD
• Number of Discs: 1
• Label: Bridge
• ASIN: B00000JIRD
• In-Print Editions: MP3 Download
• Average Customer Review: 3.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (2 customer reviews)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #83,250 in Music (See Top 100 in Music)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

25 of 25 people found the following review helpful:

3.0 out of 5 stars Still and Beach Together: The Smart Thing and the Dumb Thing, November 6, 2001

By 

Robert W. Allen (Northfield Falls, Vermont United States) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: William Grant Still: Afro-American Symphony, Amy Beach: Gaelic Symphony (Audio CD)

Okay, the people who put together this CD didn't have a bad idea to begin with. Ask any decent musician about who gets slighted as a serious composer and he/she will probably say African Americans are not taken seriously and neither are women. So why not take two important works, one by an African American and one by a woman, on one CD? They couldn't have made a better decision. Both Still and Beach are great lyricists. Their symphonies are top notch and deserve to be better known. So far it seems like a good decision all round.
But now comes a slight problem. Beach's symphony is about 50 minutes long and Still's symphony is also very long. They both won't fit on one CD. So the solution becomes to slice and dice the lesser known of these two works, Beach's Gaelic Symphony, and that was a tragic mistake, especially since this particular recording of the Afro-American Symphony is so well done. The only real solution, as I see it is to get the works on two CD's. Fortunately, there are three other recordings of Still's symphony and one other recording, much more substantial, of Beach's to choose from. So this CD gets three stars from me for the superb performance of the quirky and bluesy Afro-American Symphony and none for the Beach which I will now have to get on the other CD. The guys who thought this whole thing up should have thought of that in the first place. Now that would have been really smart.

25 of 25 people found the following review helpful:

3.0 out of 5 stars Beach Symphony nr. 2 Structurally Gutted, July 22, 2001

By 

Trommelfeuer "Trommelfeuer" (Missouri) - See all my reviews

This review is from: William Grant Still: Afro-American Symphony, Amy Beach: Gaelic Symphony (Audio CD)

If you are looking for a good copy of Beach's Symphony nr. 2 "Gaelic", well this rendition has some fine moments, but it's physically missing a lot. Literally. There are five cuts in this rendition that amount to 65 pages removed out of a 220 page score. This pares a 45 to 50 minute work down to an anorexic 35 minutes. I was angry to have found this to have been the case; these details are normally mentioned nowhere upon the CD case. The cuts made are as follows: 1. The entire recapitulation of the first movement is excised. This amounts to 24 pages out of 77 pages of score. 2. Nine pages of the third movement are excised. The movement seems to be in an unusual rondo form with two structural climaxes; the second climax is omitted and about half the material between the climaxes is omitted. This comprises the entire portion in E major, the bridge-like section after it, and a bass clarinet solo section. 3. Ten pages of the development section (about half of it) of the last movement are excised. 4. Twenty pages of the recapitulation section (most of it) of the last movement are excised. 5. Two pages of the coda of the last movement are excised.

Omitting an optional repeat is one thing. Even cutting out a page or two of material on some argument of extraneousness given the performance costs...while not tolerable it is understandable. But the above cuts amount to gutting the symphony's structure.