From Publishers Weekly
In spite of his best intentions, fifth-grader Willie never seems to measure up to the expectations of either his humorless teacher or his exacting father, who merely wants Willie to "concentrate." Even Marla, the new girl, is reluctant to respond to Willie's friendly overtures because, as she explains, "You don't fit, and people won't like me if they see me with you." Only his indulgent mother seems to appreciate Willie's ample good qualities, but she also comes across as immature and weak. Ultimately Willie does win Marla over and in the process makes a dent in his relationship with his father, but these small triumphs are hard-earned--and Marla almost immediately moves away. The lack of sympathetic, strong adults and Willie's naive vulnerability are not an entirely credible combination, much less a comfortable one. Ages 9-12.
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 4-6-Willie is a likable fifth grader who has trouble concentrating, especially in school. He's somewhat naive, a bit of a joker, but consistently honest and loyal. His father is temporarily home full time after a dispute with his boss and has apparently just become aware of his son's shortcomings. The boy's poor academic performance and his dog's lack of training become primary targets of his father's criticism. Then, a new girl moves to the area. Marla is shy, quiet, and leery of Willie's overeager attention. His persistence and kindness win out, and eventually Marla learns to trust him. Their friendship is short-lived but the boy succeeds in helping her through a hard time in her life and in accepting yet another move. Willie's interactions with his parents, particularly his father, are important throughout the short novel, and in the end he does earn the man's praise. However, this story is primarily about his relationship with Marla. Although the plot is rather thin and some of the characters are not fully developed, Willie shines through as a believable child who is wise beyond his years.
Marilyn Long Graham, Lee County Library System, Fort Myers, FLCopyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.