Customer Reviews

Wilton Jelly Roll and Cookie Pan, 12 x 18 x 1 Inches Deep

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

I thought a cookie sheet was a cookie sheet. Not so. These bent during unpacking and when nestled (I have 6) are impossible to separate. I put 12 ramekins filled with chocolate cake on one to freeze and it couldn't hold the weight! They feel cheap and I am back to using my 20-year old ones.

Excellent item and service. Although jelly pan arrived with a slight bend in middle of product. Like it was picked up by a strong, heavy hand.

I bought 2 of these sheets for holiday cookie baking because they are oversized and I thought I could get my baking done quicker than usual. That scenario didn't happen because I made the (apparently horrible) mistake of storing 1 sheet on top of the other. Once you stack, game over... there is no prying the sheets apart. A total waste of money!

I just received these pans. I took them out of the packaging and put them together, one inside the other. A few minutes later I tried to pick just one pan up. Surprisingly they had stuck together, and I could not pull them apart. I had to get a pair of pliers out of the garage to separate the pans. I put them in the trash, and will not even try to use them. waste of money.

Ordered 2 for my mother. Aluminum is the only way to go (no rust). Not much more you can say about them other than they do what they are designed to do.

This is such a beautiful, well-made product. I've had mine for about a year and love them!

I search far and wide to find these Aluminum cookie sheet pans of this size for my wife. She is well pleased with them and likes them better than the teflon coated sheets that are every where. They appear heavier than her old sheet pans.