Customer Reviews


121 Reviews
5 star:
 (91)
4 star:
 (24)
3 star:
 (2)
2 star:
 (3)
1 star:
 (1)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favorable review
The most helpful critical review


76 of 78 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars First Stewart/Mann Teaming a CLASSIC!
Winchester '73 is one of the most enduring and popular films of James Stewart's career, for several reasons; it was the first of five teamings with brilliant, underrated director Anthony Mann, who retooled Stewart's drawling, 'aw-shucks' persona into a laconic, edgier, more flawed hero; it featured a brilliant cast, including Shelley Winters, Dan Duryea, Stephen McNally,...
Published on June 15, 2003 by Benjamin J Burgraff

versus
21 of 29 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars Great Western, Incredibly Poor DVD Transfer
It's a real shame how badly this film was transferred to DVD. Much of the DVD is fine; some sections of it look better than I've ever seen in any other format, displaying the excellence of the black-and-white photography. But other sections are grainy and marred by distracting visual noise, and that isn't the worst of it: In several places during the film, the DVD...
Published on May 8, 2003 by Scott Clifton


‹ Previous | 1 213 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

76 of 78 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars First Stewart/Mann Teaming a CLASSIC!, June 15, 2003
This review is from: Winchester '73 (DVD)
Winchester '73 is one of the most enduring and popular films of James Stewart's career, for several reasons; it was the first of five teamings with brilliant, underrated director Anthony Mann, who retooled Stewart's drawling, 'aw-shucks' persona into a laconic, edgier, more flawed hero; it featured a brilliant cast, including Shelley Winters, Dan Duryea, Stephen McNally, John McIntyre, and, in VERY early appearances, Rock Hudson and Tony Curtis; visually, it is spectacular, one of the most beautiful Black and White films ever made, with deep-focus photography highlighting rugged Arizona settings that literally leap from the screen; and, most of all, it is a terrific variation of 'Cain and Abel', told through the premise of the search for a 'one-of-a-kind' rifle Stewart wins in a competition, then loses through treachery. It's the kind of film that offers new insights each time you view it, as the actions and motivations of 'good' brother Stewart and 'bad' brother McNally become better understood.
What truly makes this DVD an 'essential', though, is the bonus track...Described as an 'interview' with Stewart, it is actually an audio commentary that runs through the film, offering not only his reflections about the making of Winchester '73, but insights about his career, working with John Ford, Alfred Hitchcock, and his great friends Henry Fonda and John Wayne, even a nice story about his long-time mount, Pie. Recorded several years ago for the laserdisc edition of Winchester '73, it provides a rare opportunity to hear a screen legend reminisce (and makes you wish Wayne and Fonda had lived long enough to have offered personal observations about THEIR classic films!)
This is a DVD NOT to be missed!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


38 of 39 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Anthony Mann creates a classic, July 19, 2004
Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Winchester '73 (DVD)
The story goes that in 1950 Jimmy Stewart was looking around for something a little different for himself, something where he could play a character less folksy and warm. He sure did find it in this film, as well as all the other magnificent westerns he did with gritty, noir director, Anthony Mann (T-Men, Raw Deal, Railroaded, etc). This is the first of their collaborations.

When the film was first shown to test audiences, there were titters in the crowd when Jimmy Stewart's name appeared in the credits. "Mr. Smith" in a western? Shooting people? Please. By the end of the film, the tittering was all done and Stewart had established himself as a viable western hero (although in truth the magic of these Mann/Stewart westerns is that the characters Stewart plays are hardly "heroic." They are usually driven, neurotic men, nearly shifty-eyed, with a mean streak a mile wide - bitter men, and always very, very angry and eager to kill.

The basic set-up of this film is beautifully simple: Jimmy Stewart has a prize rifle stolen from him, a Winchester Model 1873 (which at the time the film takes place was state-of-the-art in the world of firearms), and he spends the rest of the movie hunting the man that stole it.

The story unfolds, however, as the movie rolls quickly along to something much more complex, culminating in one of the finest shootouts in movie history. The two principal actors of the film, James Stewart and Stewart McNally, spent a great deal of time practicing with their rifles (in Stewart's case Mann often found him walking around the set with bleeding knuckles, the results of his hours of self-training working the classic lever-action Winchester). Their hard work paid of in a tremendous realism.

Anthony Mann brought in cinematographer, William Daniels, for Winchester '73, a veteran who most notably had worked a great deal with Garbo in the 30's. Daniels brought his tremendous sense of lighting to the table to create one of the most beautiful looking Westerns of all time. Daniels' light, combined with Mann's unmatched visual sense, made things look nearly 3-demensional in their reality. When viewing this film, watch for the staggering long shots, or the scenes near dusk or at night. Pure texture and light - at once glamorous yet real.

This film also has my favorite depiction of aging Western legend, Wyatt Earp, the Law in Dodge, played with easy authority by Will Greer. Greer always offers his suggestions to town folks with a warm smile, as when he asks Stewart to give up his gun in an early scene. There is always a bit of steel in the old gunfighter's eyes, though, and folks always do just as he suggests. Quickly.

All in all a great treat and a must-have for any fan of the Western (or for that matter, any lover of movies). A true classic all the way. --Mykal Banta
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars `My mistake. I shot THROUGH it...', May 8, 2003
By 
Edward M. Erdelac (Valley Village, CA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
This review is from: Winchester '73 (DVD)
This movie can do no wrong in my book.
Two greats, Anthony Mann and Jimmy Stewart, team up to deliver this two-fister about an obsessed man tracking a killer from his own past while his friend Millard Mitchell does his best to keep him from going over the edge. Shelly Winters does a nice turn as the poor gal. Stephen McNally is oily as the main bad guy, and Dan Duryea comes off like Johnny Udo (from the original Kiss Of Death) in chaps.
The story really heats up when Stewart wins a shooting contest in which Wyatt Earp officiates (watch for the postage stamp across the nickel - some heroic marskmanship here) and gets his prized Winchester rifle stolen for his trouble. The Winchester does a hot potato act between badmen and Indians (Rock Hudson shows up as a war chief, in a scene where Tony Curtis dons the blue wool as a cavalry buck), and finally winds up in a climactic, hair raising shootout in a jumble of rocks above the desert. You can FEEL the bullets whizzing by.
Especially love the scene where Lin encounters Waco Johnnie Dean (read: Johnny Udo)in a bar and displays a decided lack of patience for the young bad man's showboating... There aren't many places to find good old Jimmy Stewart coming off harder (but do try `Flight Of The Phoenix'...wow!).
PS - This DVD is a good buy - the print they used tends to be a little less than pristine here and there, but it has got a commentary track with Jimmy Stewart on it! How did they do this? It seems Jimmy might have been watching the Laserdisc. His anecdotes about the old studio system and incites into acting are great. Especially like the stories about his hat (used in various westerns for twenty years) and horse, Pie (same as above).
"Huh...this laser thing is very interesting..." Jimmy Stewart.
Great suprise. Great DVD.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


12 of 13 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Cain and Abel, June 9, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Winchester '73 (DVD)
Along with a handful of other titles, this film is right at the summit of the great American Westerns ever made. It came entirely out of the blue as well. It was James Stewart's first serious Western (omitting "Destry Rides Again") and displayed a side of his character his Air Force buddies may have known about but precious few other people did. When Stewart threatens to break Dan Duryea's neck in a bar fight movie audiences must have been seriously taken aback. Doubly shocking is the fact that Stewart is out to gun down his outlaw brother for the murder of their father. Nor was Anthony Mann, the director, known for his Westerns, but this masterpiece simply could not be improved. The show is littered with great performances, especially John McIntire as the gun dealer, and Stewart sidekick Millard Mitchell, who made a huge impact in Hollywood during a very short career. Mitchell also appeared in "Twelve O'Clock High", "The Gunfighter", and "Singin' in the Rain" before dying of lung cancer in 1953.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


9 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A classic in the purest sense!!, September 24, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Winchester 73 [VHS] (VHS Tape)
This is a "don't miss" classic that is fit for family viewing (my 10 year old is hooked on old westerns now). Being a Western junkie I was surprised I had never heard of this one - I was missing one of the greats! James Stewart is unforgettable as a man determined to set the record straight. Cameos by Rock Hudson and Tony Curtis were surprising to say the least. This film has my highest recommendation to anyone who has enjoyed other westerns such as; Stagecoach, Tombstone, or Unforgiven. Do not be disswayed by the fact that it is in black and white. In fact, the B&W attitude adds to the overall drama of the film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


11 of 12 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars THE LIFE STORY OF A CLASSIC RIFLE, September 14, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Winchester '73 (DVD)
The rifle is a coveted prize at a western shooting contest hosted by the western legend, Wyatt Earp (Will Geer). It is a perfect Winchester that won't be sold, only won. Two brothers compete for the prize; both trained by the same man, one good, and one evil. Right prevails is the shootout.
But Evil will not accept the results and steals the rifle. What follows then is a series of changes of hand for the "One of a Thousand" Winchester. From wily gun traders to Indian raiders to quick-draw outlaws, the gun's odyssey is followed in this classic western with the good brother (James Stewart) seeking not only to regain his treasure but to put an end to a lifelong obsession.
Shelly Winters comes along for the wild ride and look for Tony Curtis and Rock Hudson in very unpredictable cameo appearances.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars "That's where you're wrong. I don't like it. Some things a man has to do, so he does 'em.", April 16, 2006
This review is from: Winchester '73 (DVD)
Between 1950 and 1955 James Stewart and director Anthony Mann made 5 Westerns together. Each of them are excellent and deserving of multiple viewings.

This first pairing finds Lin McAdam (Stewart) and his partner High-Spade Frankie Wilson (played by one of my absolute favorite underrated actors: Millard Mitchell) on the trail of Dutch Henry Brown a two-bit, low life, four flushing scumbag that really [...] off Stewart but we don't know why. They catch up with him in the opening scene in Dodge City but since there's no guns allowed in the city limits and Sheriff Wyatt Earp is watching them both like a hawk they can't kill each other. Instead they compete in a shooting contest. Grand prize: a high-coveted "one-in-a-thousand" Winchester Model 1873 rifle. Stewart wins the gun, but Brown and his men jump him, steal the rifle and skedaddle it out of town with Lin and Wilson on their trail.

From here on the story splits into two: one the story of the rifle and it's quickly changing owners and the other of Lin and Wilson tracking down Brown and why exactly does Lin hate him so much that he would dedicate his life to killing Brown.

Like I said earlier this is an excellent film and I'm sure a real surprise for audiences back in 1950 who had never seen a rough and haunted Stewart. Most people probably didn't even think he was capable of it! I'm a big fan of Anthony Mann and he does a great job here, I especially like the look of this movie: it's rougher and grittier than the normal Western of the day. Another big plus for this film is the strong supporting cast. In every scene you see a familiar face: Shelley Winters, Rock Hudson, Tony Curtis, John McIntire, Dan Duryea, Stephen McNally, James Millican, Jay C. Flippen, Charles Drake (he was really good), John Alexander (Teddy from ARSENIC AND OLD LACE!!!), Abner Biberman, and Steve Brodie! Now that's a supporting cast!

If you're a fan of Stewart's or Westerns or just good movies then you can't go wrong with this one. Oh yea, if that's not enough for you there's also an audio commentary by Stewart himself!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


9 of 11 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Added Bonus, May 7, 2003
By 
Guy Allen Johnson "brfilms" (San Francisco, CA United States) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Winchester '73 (DVD)
As usual, some of these big studio DVD releases don't adequately advertise what they have. Hey, they could only sell more. I guess they have something against that.
Winchester '73 is one of my favorite westerns, and I rushed out the first day to buy the DVD. Universal has done a great job -- good restoration, very reasonably priced. But there is one gem that isn't apparent until after you buy it. Not mentioned on the front cover, on the back cover an extra is advertised in small print -- "interview with James Stewart". I was thinking it would just be a few minute interview. Instead, it turns out to be a full-fledged audio commentary -- really insightful. I have no idea when it was recorded -- perhaps for a Laserdisc release? -- but this is something that should be advertised prominently.
Although it doesn't appear that the other great Anthony Mann-Jimmy Stewart westerns released concurrently -- "Bend of the River" and "The Far Country" -- have such bonuses, I look forward to buying them as well. At least they are much less priced than the Mann-Stewart "Man from Laramie," a very good film that is very highly priced by -- Columbia, is it?
Now we just need "The Naked Spur," a true masterpiece, to come out in a restored version.
Enjoy "Winchester '73"!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5 of 6 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A classic western with a great story and fine performances, July 22, 2005
This review is from: Winchester '73 (DVD)
This classic Western from 1950 is yet another proof of how much we miss having an actor like Jimmy Stewart around. He can play the good guy while keeping him dangerous, a bit mysterious, and who can be both tender and ferocious an instant apart. In this movie his is Lin McAdam who travels with his friend High-Spade Frankie Wilson in pursuit of a really bad guy named Dutch Henry Brown. Early in the movie they compete in a shooting contest in Wyatt Earp's (Will Geer) town. They are competing for a gleaming new Winchester rifle, which represents the epitome of personal weaponry in 1873.

Much of the plot follows the ownership of that rifle as it passes through many hands until it finally gets back to its rightful owner at the end. This is interwoven with the pursuit of Dutch Brown by Lin McAdam and the adventures they have along the way.

It is a fine classic Western with shootouts, fistfights, a woman of ill repute (Shelly Winters) who has a heart of gold and is ill treated by nearly every man in the movie. The bad guys do their character acting well and impart an edge and memorable quirks to their performances. Most memorable is Dan Duryea's portrayal of the dangerous Waco Johnnie Dean. There is one peculiar scene of law enforcement, though, when the good guys burn down the house of an innocent settler to drive the bad guys out. Isn't that a bit much?

Even though it is in black and white it is so compelling that my twelve year old son was walking by and was instantly captivated by the movie. Westerns still have that magic for every generation when done right. This one is done very right.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars "Winchester '73 (1950) ... Anthony Mann ... Universal Studios (2003)", December 26, 2010
This review is from: Winchester '73 (DVD)
Universal Studios presents "WINCHESTER '73" (1950) (92 min/B&W) (Fully Restored/Dolby Digitally Remastered) -- Lin McAdam (James Stewart) and his friend High-Spade (Millard Mitchell) arrive in Dodge City for a shooting contest, in which the prize is a perfectly manufactured Winchester repeating rifle, referred to as "One of a Thousand" - a gun so fine that Winchester won't sell it --- Lin runs across Dutch Henry Brown (Stephen McNally) in a saloon and the two would kill each other right there but for the fact that town marshal Wyatt Earp has everyone's guns --- Lin wins the rifle in an extraordinary marksmanship match-up with Brown, but the latter steals the prize from him and sets out across the desert --- Thus begins a battle of wits and nerves, and a pursuit to the death --- The roots and raw psychological dimensions of that chase are only exposed gradually, across a story arc that includes references to Custer's Last Stand, run-ins with marauding Indians, a heroic stand with a a shady but well-intentioned grifter and a meeting with murderous sociopath named Waco Johnny Dean, plus a romantic encounter with a young, golden-hearted frontier woman --- All of these story lines eventually get drawn together neatly and gracefully by director Anthony Mann, who balances the violence of the events with a lyrical, almost poetic visual language.

Written for the screen by Borden Chase who also scripted two other Stewart/Mann westerns: "Bend of the River" (1952) & "The Far Country" (1954) --- All three are classic James Stewart Westerns!

Under the production staff of:
Anthony Mann [Director[
Robert L. Richards [Screenwriter]
Borden Chase [Screenwriter]
Stuart N. Lake [Story]
Aaron Rosenberg [Producer]
Joseph Gershenson [Original Film Music]
William H. Daniels [Cinematographer]
Edward Curtiss [Film Editor]

BIOS:
1. Anthony Mann [aka: Emil Anton Bundesmann] - [Director]
Date of Birth: 30 June 1906 - San Diego, California
Date of Death: 29 April 1967 - Berlin, Germany

2. James Stewart
Date of Birth: 20 May 1908 - Indiana, Pennsylvania
Date of Death: 2 July 1997 - Los Angeles, California

the cast includes:
James Stewart - Lin McAdam
Shelley Winters - Lola Manners
Dan Duryea - Waco Johnnie Dean
Stephen McNally - Dutch Henry Brown
Millard Mitchell - High Spade Frankie Wilson
Charles Drake - Steve Miller
John McIntire - Joe Lamont
Will Geer - Wyatt Earp
Jay C. Flippen - Sgt. Wilkes
Rock Hudson - Young Bull
John Alexander - Jack Riker
Steve Brodie - Wesley
James Millican - Wheeler
Abner Biberman - Latigo Means
Tony Curtis - Doan
James Best ... Crater

Mr. Jim's Ratings:
Quality of Picture & Sound: 5 Stars
Performance: 5 Stars
Story & Screenplay: 5 Stars
Overall: 5 Stars [Original Music, Cinematography & Film Editing]

Total Time: 92 min on DVD ~ Universal Studios ~ (05/06/2003)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


‹ Previous | 1 213 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

Details

Winchester '73
Winchester '73 by Anthony Mann (DVD - 2003)
$14.98 $8.49
In Stock
Add to cart Add to wishlist
Search these reviews only
Send us feedback How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you? Let us know here.