Customer Reviews

Winner Take All

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

The Navy has a long standing initiation rite for those who have never crossed the Equator (referred to as Polywogs). Once you have crossed the Equator and endured the initiation, you become a Shellback and earn a much sought-after certificate to atest to this fact. NSA analyst Bill Lane has a far more insidious initiation to endure as he hops back and forth across the Equator in Flannery's first installment of the Bill Lane franchise, "Winner Takes All". In this novel, Flannery's newest protagonist, Lane, must unravel the mystery surrounding the sinking of a U.S. spy ship off Russia's coast before the incident taints a planned War Game between the U.S. and Russia, called Operation Pit Bull, set to commence off the coast of Brazil.

Lane and company must contend with power-crazed Ukrainian Generals, renegade submarines, treacherous politicos, and . . . yes, assassins before he is able to defuse the powderkeg that Operation Pit Bull has become. Throughout it all Lane gets to spend time on half of the U.S. Navy's Atlantic fleet. He's hard to keep up with.

Sigh - how does this stack up to previous Flannery fare? Its AWESOME. Flannery is a master of back alley Coldwar shenannigans and he successfully brings that talent to bear on a totally believable post-Coldwar plot. He has oodles of sub-plots, most of which are attended to before he closes the novel. In previous outings he had flexed his considerable gift for military action sequences, however, he has honed that skill to crackling perfection in this novel. Not many people can make a combat simulation suspenseful. Flannery does.

The pace of Winner Takes All is very fast - much faster than previous works by Flannery. In earlier works he could be accused of redundancy as he digs in to the depths of his characters' motivations. And that redundancy tended to slow his previous works down a bit. That is not the case with this novel. There is very little redundancy - that's the good news. Unfortunately, there is very little character development, too. Perhaps in future outings with Bill Lane, we'll get to know him as well as we got to know Flannery's legend of previous works, Wallace Mahoney.

Characterization lapse aside, however, Winner Takes All is clearly one of Flannery's finest.

Sean Flannery again is off to the races with an exciting book about the terrors of international relationships in a world whose relationships are based on mistrust, greed, hate, religion and compounded by too many weapons of mass distruction and twisted powerful men willing to use them to further their ambition. Sean weaves another great action tale, complete with marvelous descriptions of the weapons of war in actual use. It is non stop action. The story is slightly less than top rate only because for me, the motivation of the principal players is a bit forced, but never the less, a very good read

Flannery was supposedly a military analyst and speaker at CIA functions. How someone so uninformed regarding the USN rank structure got to that level explains why we have had such problems in recent years with military intelligence and the CIA. In his wild tail Winner Take All, he has a Navy LT as CO of a fighter squadron (should be CDR) a LCDR as XO of an aircraft carrier (senior CDR or junior CAPT) and a LCDR as the commander of an air group...CAG...(senior CDR)...and his civilian hero catching a ride on a SR-71 was just to much....I gave up on this far fetched drivel half way thru and won't read any more by this imposter.