From Publishers Weekly
Jacobson (Moon Sandwich Mom) creates in third-grader Winnie a resourceful heroine who knows her own mind. As the novel opens, Winnie makes peanut butter and banana sandwiches: "It was Winnie's job to make a healthy lunch for herself and her father. She took her job very seriously." Though her mother died soon after Winnie was born, she and her father speak easily and openly about her mother. In addition to a supportive father, she has two best friends, Vanessa and Zoe. But when the two girls want to join ballet classes on Tuesday afternoons, the threesome's usual library-going day, Winnie is crestfallen; she "danced like a goose with something stuck in her throat." The author demonstrates her intimate knowledge of elementary school dynamics. At a sleepover, "the three friends lay on their backs. It was easier to be truthful this way." Jacobson conveys Winnie's hurt feelings as a stronger bond inevitably forms between the two aspiring dancers, leaving Winnie out. But her brief stint on the periphery also presents Winnie with a rare opportunity to see another side of her father. This uplifting tale speaks to the emerging independence of all grade-schoolers. Ages 7-10.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Gr 3-5-Three eight-year-old best friends do everything together, and always wear an identical article of clothing. Excited about taking an after-school ballet class, Vanessa and Zoe convince a reluctant Winnie to participate. After several lessons, the dance teacher points out to the other students how inept Winnie is and the child drops out of the group, which strains her relationship with her two pals. Finally, she misses them so much that she decides to try ballet again. With help from her sensitive, caring father, the girl becomes an expert at grand jets. She also comes to realize that people can have different interests and still be good friends. Geis's uncomplicated pencil drawings capture the girls' energy and personalities. The characterizations, simple vocabulary, large-sized type, and pages with lots of white space make this a good title for those who are just beginning to read chapter books.
Elaine Lesh Morgan, Multnomah County Library, Portland, OR
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.