Customer Reviews

Winslow Homer : An American Original [VHS]

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

My 8th graders hated it. As an art teacher I support what the producers are trying to do, however, this video has a weak script, uninspired performances and is simply boring. The basic dramatic conflict of the story is too internalized for middle school and too childish for high school. The performances are so underplayed and amateur-ish that there's nothing to hold students' attention. There are really very few insights into Homer the man, the artist, his techniques or his life beyond the fact that he was an illustrator during the Civil War. Save your money for a documentary video on Homer.

I ordered this DVD for a group of fifth graders to whom I teach Art History. We had already read a short biography of Homer prior to viewing and has observed many of his paintings. I have to say, that after viewing part of the film at home, I wasn't sure if it would hold their interest (I found it a bit bland) but it did! Their background knowledge, helped bring many of the films themes to life: his independent character, work as an illustrator, as well as his involvement as an illustrator during the Civil War. They enjoyed it very much. It was perfect for their age group.

Super family video that is interesting, historically accurate and educational. Subtle story and paintings are woven together well. Makes the viewer believe it's really 1874 in New York. Creativity balances the theme of the horrors of war. Found it engrossing and entertaining. "It was funny and sad, interesting and about war." "The way the artist worked was great, how he saw things and painted them." "I liked the kids messing with the man, and the boy and girl being sweet on each other." Ages 8-12.