Most Helpful Customer Reviews
37 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Road Not Taken, November 28, 2004
Carol O'Connell's novels operate on two levels, at least. On the one hand, they are cleverly crafted mysteries that leave us guessing up to almost the final pages. On the other, they are explorations of the exceptional mind and, in the case of the Mallory novels, the spiritual biography of a sociopath.
Looking back over the eight Mallory novels, typically the real murderer, and the real crime, usually turn out to be much less interesting than any number of other elements. So here. The center of *Winter House* is Kathy's confrontation with a doppelganger, Nedda Winter, a woman she could become. Is Nedda insane? Did she kill her entire family in a childhood rampage? Is she killing now? As these questions are answered, questions about Kathy Mallory are answered.
Kathy's had a free ride for seven novels, with Riker, Charles, and the poker club making excuses for her while the reader looks on, titillated and aghast. Things changed in *Dead Famous* when Johanna Apollo said to Charles, "You know what she is?" and he nodded. Here, at last, he closes a door in her face, refuses to allow her to bully a victim, and says "No" when any sane person would. Riker and Charles have begun to demand that Kathy grow up. Whether she will, we'll see in another novel, I think.
The first four novels were a set that appeared to complete Kathy's story. The next three took us from where she came from to who she is. *Winter House* begins to explore who she can become. Of the eight books, one of the best.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Mallory is back on track, December 6, 2004
Winter House is the best Mallory novel in some time and essential reading for fans of the characters, who have been feeling neglected since Stone Angel. The story is setup around the death of an intruder at a New York mansion (the Winter House of the title). The victim is a serial killer, originally captured by Mallory (thus her involvement in the case) and the killer is a intriguing, old women who was supposed to have disappearied 58 years before when most of her family was massacred by an ice pick wielding assassin (who was the subject of a Riker family obsession).
The story goes through many twists and turns as should any good mystery, but ultimately it rests on the strengths of the characterizations. Mallory is presented as a feline force of nature. Despite the fact that the series bears her name it is interesting to note that we almost never receive her point of view, but rather observe her second hand through the perceptions of those who love and fear (for) her. Charles, in particular, is often center stage here, and more than ever his own inner strength and basic decency are on display. His love for Mallory is firmly at odds with her methods, and in this case he is willing to directly oppses her (and even usher her out of his home - which would have been a death sentence for many)based on principle. In Mallory's reaction to this we actually get some insight into her troubled psyche and the importance of Charles in her life. A highlight of this is in a brief point of view moment as Mallory is being thrown out, where we see for the first time that icy, young detective might avoid human contact (touch), but is not adverse to it, and perhaps even craves it (also the image of Mallory being put out like a house cat, instead of her usual tigress is quite amusing).
The first 4 Mallory novels represented a fairly tight character based arc, that dealt with events leading from her adopted father's death through the revelation of her past. Subsequent novels, like Shell Game and Crime School, have been entertaining, but were plot based and completely independent of each other, with no noticeable character growth. With Winter House I see the possibility that O'Connell may be back to work on developing these people and their relationships with each other. In order for me to enjoy a series progress has to occur. The mysteries are entertaining, but ultimately what keeps me coming back is my affection Mallory, Charles, Riker, and poker crew. I want them to live and breathe, not be trapped in the amber of a generic police procedural. My hope is the Winter House is a big step in that direction.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Maybe the best Mallory book?, September 20, 2004
The latest Mallory book begins with the dead body of a burglar, apparently killed in self-defence. Except the corpse had been carrying an ice-pick in a house that long ago witnessed the massacre of a family.....all killed with an ice pick.
This book is brilliant, and though I think the whole series is truly amazing, it still stands out.
"Winter House" sees a strong return to the almost supernatural feel of the earlier books and features Charles Butler heavily (which is always a good thing as far as I'm concerned). Also all of the members of the poker group make a welcome appearance.
The book feels like it is firmly rooted into its place in the series (which one or two of the others haven't) and contains subtle references to events in previous books.
Mallory's own emotions are very much in evidence, again giving lie to the idea of a restrained sociopath. And, as this is Carol O'Connell, the plotting is easily equal to the standard set by her stunning writing style.
I read it straight through and then again two days later. It really is exquisite and I cannot recommend it enough, or give it enough stars.
And though it's been said many times before, Carol O'Connell really does transcend the genre and her books are as hard to pigeon hole as Mallory, herself.
If you have never read Carol O'Connell or a Mallory book then start with the first ("Mallory's Oracle") and work your way through the series of, now eight. They are worth every moment you will spend reading them and more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|