Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Love Story Based On True Faith, June 14, 2004
This review is from: Winter is Past (Regency Series #1) (Steeple Hill Women's Fiction #3) (Paperback)
Althea Breton comes from wealth but lives with the poor, lower class. Simon Aguilar is a Jew who publicly renounced his faith to become a Christian for the sake of his political career, yet while he no longer embraces his Jewish heritage, neither has he embraced the Christian faith. He is a man of two worlds, but also of none. And while Althea has fully embraced her faith, inasmuch as her father is a wealthy Lord, yet she lives as a nurse and a servant, neither is she of either the world of privilege or peasant, so she, too, is of two worlds, but also of none. Both Simon and Althea are at loose ends, though neither is fully aware of exactly what they lack in their lives. But when Simon hires Althea as a nurse and companion for his seriously ill daughter, Rebecca, Simon and Althea begin to see a glimpse of what each needs to find happiness and fulfillment. Love, tenderness, understanding, and acceptance begin to grow in the Aguilar household, but is that enough? Doesn?t the Bible caution against becoming ?unequally yoked? and isn?t a relationship with Simon a classic example, Althea worries? How can she fall in love with a man who doesn?t truly believe and have the passion for Christ that she does? Morren weaves an intriguing tale of love into a fabric of faith and creates a garment that will bless readers with its timeless message. Reviewed by: Tina L. Miller, author of "When A Woman Prays" (also available at Amazon.com)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Inspiring Novel, October 22, 2005
This review is from: Winter is Past (Regency Series #1) (Steeple Hill Women's Fiction #3) (Paperback)
Winter is Past
Ruth Axtel Morren has created her first compelling master piece. Winter is past an inspirational- historical novel that will captivates every reader's heart. After being raped Althea Breton renounced to her life of wealth and social position to serve the Lord. She lived her life working t at children orphanages and nursing the sick.
Simon Aguilar needed a trustworthy woman to care for his seriously ill daughter: Rebecca. Althea accepted to work for him as a favor to her brother even though she didn't want to do anything with a converso (as men like Aguilar were known) were more common in nineteenth-century England. Simon Aguilar, a Sephardic Jew who has made a nominal conversion to Christianity in order to realize his goal of a political office. The author herself descended from Shaphardim which makes the novel credible.
When Althea Breton arrives to act as Rebecca's governess she certainly has no idea what Simon is like. Althea hopes that when she is no longer needed in the Aguilar household, she can return to her life in service to the poor, never knowing of what would happen between them. The love between them grows and they acknowledge it, but they are wary because of their individual backgrounds and secrets.
Winter is Past is a very touching novel which captures the essence of time. This well crafted story gives great description of the living conditions in London and Sephardic culture in England at the time. Morren brings a lot of historical background, making the novel a success. I took great pleasure reading her novel; it is a great piece of writing which I personally can connect with. I recommended it to all Christian fiction readers, it will make you rejoice.
Maria A. Cervantes
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent novel, but with an exception...., March 11, 2008
This review is from: Winter is Past (Regency Series #1) (Steeple Hill Women's Fiction #3) (Paperback)
Ruth Axtell Morren is a wonderful writer and one of my favorite authors, and I agree with the other reviewers that this is an excellent book.
However, I do take exception to one of the underlying ideas in the novel---that is, the repeated assertion (by the Methodist heroine to the Jewish hero) that Judaism and the Church of England are "dead religions" full of "meaningless ritual." I think such claims are offensive to readers who might be part of liturgical/sacramental Christian churches (Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Episcopalian, Lutheran, etc.). The implication is that one cannot truly encounter Christ in those churches and that people in those churches are just practicing a "works-based" sort of useless faith, which is an unfair generalization.
I had the opportunity to dialogue with Ruth Axtell Morren herself about this novel, and she explained to me that at the time she wrote the book, she was an "on-fire pentecostal" and that the Methodist church of the early 1800s was the closest thing she could find to the sort of church she felt most at home in. She also said that she has since grown a lot, as a Christian and as a writer, and that she now has a more generous view of Christian churches as a whole.
Originally, though I liked the story very much, I was rather disappointed in the novel because of the prejudice I felt was being demonstrated towards liturgical types of churches. But now that I've heard the author's side of the story, I can understand better and forgive the mistake.
Readers should enjoy this novel, but take care not to absorb the notion that one must be a Methodist (or belong to some other non-liturgical Christian church) in order to truly worship the Lord. There are a great many vibrant, Christ-centered liturgical/sacramental churches; the rituals are only meaningless if you refuse to see the meaning in them or to let the Holy Spirit work on your heart.
For my part, I am looking forward to reading more novels by this fabulous author!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
