69 of 71 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
scared stiff, April 12, 2008
Nevada Barr's NPS Ranger, Anna Pigeon, is a strong and brave woman. She treks through various wildernesses, descends into bottomless caves, fights fires, saves children, both human and lupine. She's the only character I've ever known who actually employs the self-defense strategy most women can't stomach - gouging out an attacker's eyes. She has taken an ax to the head of a man. But Anna isn't a walking instrument of destruction. She loves nature, loves the wild and celebrates it knowledgably. She loves her sister, Molly, her pets, her friends in various parks, her new husband. In all of Barr's books we spend so much time in Anna's head that first-person narration would be redundant, but that's OK. Anna's head is a good place to be. I admire her. Even though she rarely looks beyond the parameters of the task at hand, she is able to go out and do what needs to be done in her world. She sustains many injuries, but she survives and triumphs, a middle-aged argument for mind over matter. She's not a super-hero, nor would I wish her to be. A bit more imaginative than Kinsey Milhone, less careless than V.I. Warshawski, Anna is a solid character who has evolved through a carefully crafted and amazingly consistent series.
In this novel, Barr takes us back to the scene of the second book in her series, Isle Royale in Lake Superior. Rather than the deep-diving of that adventure, we have frozen treks across the island, a terrain less dramatic, if no less deadly, than the amazing spaces of Yosemite, the setting for High Country. That book was the previous holder of the series' Most-Violent-Action Award, but Winter Study surpasses it with a blend of atavistic terror and human malice that's hard to read. The natural threats are so terrifyingly described and the human perversion is so graphically portrayed that, several times, I had to put the book down and walk away. I just finished it and my neck and shoulders are stiffly painful from the tension.
While that's a visceral tribute to Barr's talent as a writer, I'm not planning to re-read the novel. The wildness of the wolves and the beauty of the island are as vividly described as the terror and the dark deeds, but the latter cast shadows that are too heavy for pleasure reading. If you like the dark side, you may disagree, but I'd advise reading this fast - airplane (or airport) style. It's not a book to savor; it's a book to finish quickly, in the daylight.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Tense drama in an isolated setting, April 23, 2008
Nevada Barr's latest national park mystery is set in Isle Royal, a remote island off the coast of Michigan. Her heroine, Anna Pigeon, has been sent from her assignment at Rocky Mountain National Park to Isle Royal to observe a 50-year-old study on wolves in order to prepare her for managing wolves at her home park in Colorado. Barr does a great job of evoking the cold, barren wilderness of an Isle Royal winter with very few amenities for its inhabitants. As a reader, I felt every windchill and heard every wolf call in the book. Her characters, many of them thoroughly unlikeable, are drawn with a careful eye to detail and believability. Each one is motivated by a powerful force, whether it be personal or professional. Anna herself is roughed up more often than is necessary and the repeated scenes of her narrow escapes begin to lose effectiveness after awhile. Despite this flaw and the darkness mentioned by other reviewers, this book should please Nevada Barr's many fans.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I liked her books better without an agenda..., April 18, 2009
Up to now, I have read Nevada Barr's books practically savoring every word. I have travelled to many National Parks and so I have enjoyed her descriptive settings and the associated mysteries she has placed in the numerous parks. I have usually felt like I was right there in the middle of the action - (gee, I couldn't read and get out of the caves in Blind Descent fast enough, they felt so real!)
But this book seemed like it was written for a different purpose altogether. I never felt a true sense of Isle Royale National Park. (Superior Death was much better at that.) I never felt a connection with the action or characters - they seemed to be one-dimensional, where usually Nevada Barr has such depth to her characetrs. I even skimmed the middle 170 pages and still got the whole story that she had there.
This could have been a much shorter novel for the story she was telling here. (It could have been the same length if she had gone into better depth of action and character).
The covert agenda wasn't necessary either. When I got to the first part of it, I almost stopped right there. It would have been the first novel of hers I hadn't finished.
I have always waited for each new novel in high anticipation. She needs to go back to what worked. Very disappointing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No