Most helpful critical review
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful
Good info, but based upon carnegie lie
on August 24, 2014
The information in the book is inspirational, but i have a bit hard time that it is napoleon hills own words, not carnegies words. At first i was a little sceptical of why he published the interview first 1953, when the interview is said to have taken place 1908. Also why was all principles there then, even before he did any research. I checked it up now and unfortunately all seems to be based upon a lie. Hill doesnt seem to have met carnegie at all. http://www.budgeburgess.com/LiesaboutAC.html. So the carnegie story that he gave the mission to hill, interview for 3,5 days, introductory letters etc seems to be just a marketing trick (smart). Also the research of 20 years, is a lie.