33 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Early Krentz is breathtakingly romantic - not formulaic!, March 21, 1998
If you're a fan of Jayne Ann Krentz and have been disappointed in her latest novels, pick up a copy of one of her reissues. First published 13 years ago, Witchcraft epitomizes the romantic strength of JAK's characters and the slightly offbeat plot complications in which they find themselves embroiled.
Kimberly Sawyer, a writer of detective novels with a gutsy female lead, reluctantly gives herself into the protective keeping of vineyard owner Darius Cavenaugh when she receives some engimantic threats. A rose with a needle embedded in it, followed up by a dagger-weilding cloaked figure in the dead of night, push Kimerly into Cavenaugh's fierce and and passionate protection.
Cavenaugh arrives on the scene because he is in Kimberly's debt for her part in rescuing his nephew from a band of quirky would-be witches two months previously. He's been biding his time before he comes after her to repay the debt and coax her into his life . But he moves like a steamroller when he finds out Kimberly is being threatened by the witchy kidnappers.
Female readers will silently applaud heroine Kimberly Sawyer because she is an independent lady who is quick with logical comebacks when the hero tries to railroad her emotions. Cavenaugh quickly reveals his vulnerability to the reader when he suddenly finds himself wanting to protect as well as bed Kimberly. But wariness and willpower are on her side as she asserts her independence in Cavenaugh's household where too many demanding family members are reminding her that she prefers a life without familial duties and demands.
This shying away from anything that smacks of family responsibility brings in the second conflict of the novel, and incidentally its strongest element, because it shows the emotional distance Cavenaugh and Kimberly must travel before they can understand as well as accept the compromises a union between the two of them will bring. The conflict has its roots in Kimberly's past. After arrogantly snooping through her mail, Cavenaugh learns that Kimberly is refusing to end the estrangement with the grandparents that cast of her mother and refused to acknowledge their only grandchild 28 years ago. Experience has taught Kimberly that duty to the family can be stronger than love so she's determined to find a lover as solitary and independent as she is. Cavenaugh does not fit the mold because he is committed to a heritage of vineyards and the extended family that depends on it. We like him the better as we watch him frustrated and floundering trying to impose his real-life passion on a woman who seems to find more statisfaction with a character she's created in her own novels.
Desire runs strong through the novel beginning with outrageously provocative statements by Cavenaugh about what he wants to do with Kimberly and coming to a quick culmination with a love scene in a deserted storage shed three days later. This offbeat setting for the first love scene foreshadows Krentz' delight in getting her lovers into the unlikeliest positions, both setting-wise and conjugal-wise. Later love scenes portray the escalation in Cavenaugh's determination to smother Kimberly's fears. Again the reader will applaud Kimberly's honesty and strength because she is the first to say I love you despite Cavenaugh's overbearing ways.
But Cavenaugh believes his elusive lady is still not ready to fully commit to him and arrogantly forces a confrontation with the grandparents Kimberly has steadfastly refused to meet. He believes he's only doing what's best for her by making her face the past.
Here is where Krentz is at her emotional best, showing with just a few words Kimberly's belief that Cavenaugh has betrayed her trust and her love, and his fear that he may have pushed her too far.
His fear turns to panicked desperation when Kimberly runs from him, unknowingly running into danger from the weird kidnappers that began the story.
Witchcraft may be limited in plumbing the depth of secondary characters and in the quickly resolved plot compared to Krentz' later and longer novels. But just like Cavenaugh wines, this is vintage Krentz to be savored over and over again, a fact which is proved by the tattered condition of my original copy. Now that Witchcraft has been reissued I'll definitely be replacing it before I lose the pages that have already fallen out.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Psychic romance mind candy, March 23, 1998
Questions: Why the needle in the red rose? What happened two month ago? Who is Darius "Dare" Cavanaugh? Are there really witches? How did Kimberly Sawyer get involved?
Kim lives alone and she likes it that way. Somehow, living on the Northern California coast, she meets the owner of a Napa Valley winery, that is 150 miles away. We learn of Kim's wounds while growing up and Dare's international past in the import-export business. This story started out well, but the writing became cliche-ridden. It could have been exciting, with its intrigue and unconventional psychic elements, but somewhere along the line, it became derivative, routine romance-genre material.
Written in 1985, it is nice to know that since then, Krentz has grown from mechanical language and characterization into a more powerful and skillful author.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing. This is definitely an early work., October 15, 1999
I was disappointed in this book. The characters start out on an interesting note (Is there some kind of metaphysical element here?) but fizzle down into a flat-line. Although Kim shows strength in her character, she wavers back and forth between accepting and rejecting Darius without really exploring either side (She accepts things too easily and when she does get mad at him, she forgives him so quickly--I don't think she really knows what's on her mind). Darius seems to have only one real character trait: bossy.
All in all, I found this book disappointing. The witches' characters are also underdeveloped. Their plans for Kim are a bit far-fetched. Question: What was the reasoning behind the red rose?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
