Most Helpful Customer Reviews
26 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Leftovers from the 70's, January 25, 2003
This review is from: Witches: True Encounters with Wicca, Wizards, Covens, Cults and Magick (Hardcover)
I remember Hans Holzer from the 70's, as THE "Ghost Hunter" and his association with Sybil Leek. He was into ESP and psychic experiences and he wrote many books which I explored at that time. I do remember his stories about ghosts and approached this book with an open mind.
I am surprised at this book. There is so much information in here that is just wrong and some of his sources are questionable.
While there are a few groups and names that are easily recognizable, he does not interview those but merely mentions them. Those individuals that he does interview are very new to the path. Some of the covens he interviews are not very well known and those that are have very dated interviews.
His information, like Wicca being an "ancient religion" is inaccurate (actually founded by Gerald Gardner in the 1930's/40's), he does not differentiate between Wicca and witchcraft. He calls Ms. MorningGlory Zell "Mountain Glory", and a picture of Yvonne Frost is labeled "Alice Frost". Typos abound showing very poor proofreading. There is no bibliography, no references to where he found his material. This is just his personal experiences, beliefs and pictures.
Photos are misleading. There are photos of him and Sybil Leek but they do not relate to the material being discussed other than to mention a remembrance or two. Many of the photos are out of focus.
A lot of the material is from the 1970's. He tells the stories as he remembers events and interviews from that time period. Very little, if anything, is updated to today's current pagan community. What we read is a vignette of what the craft was like in its early years but not what it has evolved into today.
Some of his memories of people like Tim Zell (Oberon Zell Ravenheart) and Dr. Leo Martello and the Frosts are interesting. His coverage of the "Witch Wars" of the 1970's is an interesting viewpoint from a different perspective. There is some truth to the events that occurred but there is some omitted information or he just didn't get the entire story.
He includes rituals from some groups he practiced with back then, and this becomes so much filler to beef up the book. It is interesting if you are looking for older reference materials. He also goes into "Satanism" and again, while it may be interesting to the curious, it has nothing to do with "witches" and should have been done in a book separate from this book.
All in all, the book lacks authenticity, is not factual or current and has interest only from the standpoint of the author himself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best Since Drawing Down the Moon, October 14, 2002
This review is from: Witches: True Encounters with Wicca, Wizards, Covens, Cults and Magick (Hardcover)
Reviewed by Poke Runyon This book is large (8.5x11"), heavy, thick (670 pages), black and intimidating. The dust jacket screams "Witches" in inch-and-half high type garnished with a flaming red pentagram; just the thing to leave on your coffee table when your Christian maiden aunt pays a call (obviously shock value is part of the publisher's marketing strategy). However, if we can get past the book's appearance and take an unbiased look at the contents we will find a treasure trove of modern Pagan, Wiccan, and Magical history going back forty years (and in some instances brought up to date). Professor Holzer might be called the Herodotus of modern witchcraft. He reports on what he has observed first-hand, and gleaned from interviews, among the several personalities and groups he has visited over a period spanning four decades; and all this graphically documented by nearly a hundred photographs. He writes for the general reader, avoiding academic technicalities. His viewpoint is empathetic, in pleasant contrast to the expose journalism so often associated with this subject matter. He does not attempt to write a comprehensive history of the modern Pagan/Magical revival--but, when such a history is written, Holzer's contributions will figure prominently in its corpus.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not worth the money, January 2, 2003
This review is from: Witches: True Encounters with Wicca, Wizards, Covens, Cults and Magick (Hardcover)
I'm at a toss with this book. It's big, it's black, and it boasts of "true encounters with Wicca" and so on. While this book is written from the perspective that Witchcraft isn't a bad religion, in the first 100 pages, it feel into some might deep stereotyping. A couple examples: * In the history section, the author declares firmly that practitioners of the old religion long ago did not worship the Devil. That they, in fact, worshipped one god (a goddess, really), known only as The Moon Goddess. He's not talking about the modern practices, but those that took place during the Witch Hunts. * He states that the practitioners are all young and beautiful. On another page, he says that most of the practitioners are those born ("Natural Witches") or are young. And the only reason the youth are interested is because the "wild dancing and frolicking" of the Sabbats are like those one would find at a rave where they would take drugs. He plugs his other books a lot and I'm wondering if a lot of his material for this book wasn't left over from his others. (He was a prolific writing in the 60's and 70's.) Most of his examples come from that time. While some of the chants and that are good, over-all, this book is dry and boring and not worth the $30 to buy it. If one finds in cheep, I'd still not suggest it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|