From School Library Journal
Grade 3-5-This funny, exciting Halloween romp will entertain readers long after the holiday has passed. On her way to the All Hallows' Eve Ghastly Gala A-go-go, a scatterbrained old witch avoids a collision with the Channel 12 air traffic report helicopter. Trick-or-treater Sarah, six, sees her fall from the sky and gives her a Band-Aid. The witch repays the kindness by turning the child's fairy-princess-costume wand into a magical one that grants wishes. At first, these wishes are harmless enough, but then her desires begin to wreak havoc, as when she wishes that everyone had a dog. To remedy the problem, the witch tries a reversal spell that brings even more disasters. Silhouette illustrations decorate the opening pages of chapters. This beginning chapter book is for a much younger set than Vande Velde's usual audience, but the author maintains the wry wit and entertaining fantasy for which she is known. Readers will be kept on the edge of their broomsticks wondering how Sarah's life will ever be put back to normal.
Heather Dieffenbach, Lexington Public Library, KYCopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 2-5. Vande Velde, known for her many humorous mystery and fantasy titles (most recently,
Wizard at Work, 2003), offers a not-too-scary tale suitable for younger middle-grade readers. While trick-or-treating, six-year-old Sarah and her obnoxious older brother encounter a befuddled old witch struggling to get out of a grocery store dumpster. The kind girl lends a hand, prompting the witch to grant Sarah's costume wand magical powers for the night. Of course, things turn out badly, and before the evening is over everyone in the world has a puppy. The witch tries to undo all the damage, but it takes her several hilarious reruns of the night (think Bill Murray in the movie
Groundhog Day) before she gets things right. Short chapters, large print, and scattered sketches make for a pleasing, nonthreatening format. Vande Velde's strength is her keen ear for snappy, middle-grade dialogue, and the witty repartee between the witch and her household appliances will please children even slightly older than the target audience.
Kay WeismanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved