This is probably my most-anticipated album of recent memory. Considering Stadium Arcadium, By The Way, and Californication are still in regular rotation (I actually just started going backwards; downloaded from here Blood Sugar Sex Magik, since I've never actually owned it, in seething impatience for this thing to be released) I could simply not wait to wrap my ears around it.
I'm the type of music listener who tears apart an album. I know that while I may be immediately grabbed sonically it might not hold up with repeated listens. If I love an album I'll basically keep it on repeat for 3 months. I know I'm not the only one.
There are those albums (what do we call them anymore? This is my second or third time buying an "album" that's not a physical product) that the opposite happens. On initial listen you're less than impressed. "This is nothing I haven't heard before" or "eh." But then something happens. You find a day later your brain is singing to you, and you can't quite place why the music is so familiar. It's stuck in your head. And just like that, you love it.
This happened to me for Red Hot Chili Peppers' I'M WITH YOU. At first it sounds very similar, almost boringly so, to the sprawling, eclectic, creative masterwork that was Stadium Arcadium, with sprinkles of the band's previous couple albums sprinkled in, minus the tight guitar genius that is John Frusciante. His presence is missed here but Klinghoffer's certainly no slouch, and adds in my estimation a more classic-riff, edgy guitar sound to the mix, where Stadium Arcadium, led admirably and beautifully by Frusciante's guitar (Flea is always, simply, awesome), had the tendency toward more chamber-music-y happy poppy sounds. I LOVE that album, but I agree with the criticisms that it had gone too far away from RHCP's funk-groove-nutjob vibe. Here, I'm With you seems to fully embrace where the band comes from while at the same time building on the musical education and evolution that took place in their music since they broke out and became a super-famous rock band.
I will be listening to this "album" for a long time. It works its way right in there with Red Hot Chili Peppers' body of work, shows they have indeed grown up, in fact grown waaay past their "sock-on-the-flop" days, and they're mature, skilled, very talented musicians. Anthony Keidis is, to me, one of the most able and versatile rock vocalists alive. Even though his lyrics are wacked-out-almost-mostly-nonsense, they're consistently fun to sing along to, and I look forward to knowing every lyric to I'M WITH YOU before long.
Enjoy!