I gave it 1 star on account of the picture on line. If you don't look too close, it looks like a pretty good costume. My wife picked this costume for our pet to go along with her brothers Scarecrow costume for Halloween, (different maker and type of costume). She was totally disappointed with it when she put it on the dog. With the fake arms and dress shoulders, it looked very tacky. She ended up adding material to the dress to wrap around the dog, to fully enclose the dog's body like a skirt and removing the arms. She put leg holes in it for the front legs of our dog to make them, the arms. While, after all the work, it did look a little better, it still wasn't as good as the other costume we bought for her brother. Any costume that hangs on just the front of the dog isn't very good, unless you're able to carry the dog in a back-reclined position, the entire time. Avoid this costume at all costs.