6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Babe and berserker, not that there's anything wrong w/ that., January 28, 2004
This review is from: Wolverine Vol. 1: The Brotherhood (Paperback)
As a fan of Greg Rucka's novels and comics, I've come to expect a few things: 1) lean, punchy writing; 2) attention to operational detail in depicting assorted spies, assassins, bodyguards, etc.; and 3) Women.
In most of the books I can think of, Rucka prominently features not just females, but larger-than-life Amazons who are often tougher than their male counterparts. Wolverine:The Brotherhood is no exception, giving the reader a rootin'-tootin', suspect-slappin', stereotype-bustin' female ATF agent who could probably eat nails and [...] tacks.
While this obsessive commitment to feminist ideals can be off-putting, it's mostly counterbalanced by the quality stories Rucka consistently spins. He skillfully references aspects of Wolverine's character, such as his black ops background and feral tendencies, weaving them into the story without a lot of clunky exposition. Rucka crafts an oppressively gritty setting, filled with the kind of twisted villains a character like Wolverine was born to fight.
Someone once said that art could be defined as the selective interpretation of reality according to the artist's values. Judging from his characters, it seems that Rucka has a fairly large sexual axe to grind.
Taken individually, his characters are quirky and engaging. However, after the third or fourth story, a pattern becomes apparent, and I begin to feel like what I'm reading is a well-disguised sermon or morality tale.
As good as Wolverine: The Brotherhood is, I find myself looking fondly back on the writing of Chris Claremont. In his classic and definitive X-men run, he introduced me at a very early age to strong female characters, such as Storm and Callisto. Without a whiff of preachiness, he made them both likable and believable. Their actions and attitudes arose naturally from character and situation, and never seemed to be part of some program on Claremont's part.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great for established fans and newcomers alike, March 27, 2005
This review is from: Wolverine Vol. 1: The Brotherhood (Paperback)
Those of us that have been reading Wolverine for a while know very few things for certain about everyone's favorite Canadian X-Man, but two things we know for sure are 1. He hates cults, nazis, and bullies and 2. He has a soft spot for girls in trouble. These two elements clash in this graphic novel.
When Lucy Braddock, the waitress at Logan's favorite café and his neighbor is murdered after asking for Logan's protection, he will not rest until he finds her killers. Tracking down the culprits with little more information than what kind of gun he was shot with, Logan proceeds to prove he is still the best there is at what he does, and what he does often is bloody.
My favorite chapter is the last. After the blood bath of the previous issues, after Logan has to deal with physical pain, he meets Nightcrawler in a bar for a little soul searching. For long time fans, this issue was touching, harkening back to Claremont's run on X-Men, but with Greg Rucka's unique style.
Speaking of style, Rucka's writing and Robertson's art provide a unique, gritty style. Both use a highly stylized approach that is still somehow very pleasant and not overdone.
There's enough references to previous plot points in Wolverine's past to make established fans rejoice, cheer, and flinch, but a newcomer can easily pick this up and understand everything without having to spend extra on more books.
Highest recommendations!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Wolverine and Cults, July 3, 2011
This review is from: Wolverine Vol. 1: The Brotherhood (Paperback)
One of the first few books I fully read solely about Wolverine and I enjoyed it. The story itself might not be for everyone. It's dark, very gritty and some of the renderings of Wolverine makes it seem like he is an animal. The story in itself is almost like a detective story. The majority of the story has Wolverine going around asking questions to find answers on who he should target to kill. I wouldn't necessary recommend this book to most readers out there. Its a must buy for Wolverine fans though but for others who want superhero versus villains type storylines, this isn't the book for y'all.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No