22 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Berlin hell under the Red 'liberators', October 16, 2005
This review is from: Woman in Berlin Hb (Hardcover)
The anonymous author of this fine wartime diary is amost certainly Marta Hillers, a former journalist, who died in June 2001 at the age of 90.
Although published in the US and UK mid 1950s it was largely ignored by a world not ready to see Germans as victims too. Since being republished, after the author's death, this book has become a belated bestseller -and deservedly so.
It shows the Red Army for the rabble they were-watches, booze and women were considered the booty of war and with a thug like Stalin as a political leader no restraints were placed on the animals from the steppes. Estimates of rape vary from 90,000 -130,000 in the climatic struggle for Berlin, according to medical records, with over 10,000 German females perishing as a result of the animalistic attacks on them, or by suicide or injury as a consequence of such assaults. All told the Red Army raped over two million women as they rampaged across eastern Europe-a figure that included Jewish women who had escaped death in the Nazi camps only to suffer again at the hands of these Red 'liberators.'
The author, an articulate professional, who had toured the Soviet Union before the war, and knew some of the language, describes the orgy of rape, and after having thrice experienced pack rape at the hands of such scum she sought out a Red Army officer -prostituting herself to be protected from the pack.
The author brilliantly describes the breakdown in Berlin society in this diary, starting on the 20 April 1945 (Hitler's birthday) before the Reds arrive in her suburb, and ending on the 16 June - just over a month after peace was restored in Europe.
There may be some people who think the German civilians deserved what they got -but this reviewer is not amongst them. Depravity is depravity, regardless of who is on the receiving end and the rationale for fighting the war was to stand against such heinous war crimes, not to add to the list of the atrocities.
The Red Army's record in World War II is a disgrace and outraged comments from Russian spokesman convince no-one. It is appopriate that the fine British historian, Antony Beevor, has a preface in this republished version. His more recent work on the Battle for Berlin, was attacked as a 'slander' against the Red Army by the then Russian ambassador to Britain. No doubt that Russian apologist would also consider this diary a fabrication (a charge levelled earlier). Still, for years the murder of the Polish officer class in the Katyn Forest, by the communists, was also labelled a 'fabrication' while the continued imprisonment of the Hero of the Holocaust, Sweden's Raoul Wallenberg, was similarly regarded as 'false' western propaganda.
The courage of this woman, and many others, in war shattered Berlin contrasts greatly with the rank record of the Red Army and is a must read by anyone interested in the impact of total war on a great city and its people.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Woman in Berlin, September 7, 2005
This review is from: Woman in Berlin Hb (Hardcover)
This book tells the forgotten story of the average German citizen's experience during WWII. On par with Anne Frank's diary in terms of historical significance, poignant life experiences, and the sheer deconstruction of society during war. Of course, since it is an adult's perspective, the themes are on a more mature level. The writing is excellent, the images searing and moving. I can't believe this book is no longer in print or that it is not better known.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Chilling account, February 24, 2010
This review is from: Woman in Berlin Hb (Hardcover)
A chilling, disturbing account of the first weeks of the Russian occupation of Berlin. The book left a deep impression, and a bitter aftertaste, even a feeling of guilt. The Russian internet is full of denial and angry denunciations: the Germans brought it upon themselves, how dare they offend the memory of war veterans, etc, etc. - this is truly sad. Two wrongs do not make right; the Germans committed atrocities in Russia, no one says otherwise, but is this enough to justify rape and plunder of the civilian population? Russia is not willing to face this dilemma; the Russians prefer to forget, or pretend not to know, or refuse to believe, and so the present generation, too, shares the blame. This book is stark reminder of the darker side of the Soviet occupation. Does it tarnish the treasured Russian self-image of a "liberator of Europe"? Absolutely. And this is how it should be, for history is often unpleasant and does not square with political contigencies. I only wish it was read more in Russia. It will not be read, not amid all the nationalist stink. Yet a woman in Berlin must not be forgotten, nor should all the other women in Kiev, or Minsk, or Warsaw - victims of war and tyranny. I think this is the broader message of this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No