Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Woman of a Thousand Secrets, September 2, 2008
Tonina hails from an island where she doesn't belong. Found in a basket plucked from the sea, she is raised by an elderly couple who recognize her many differences and send her on a concocted mission to find a healing flower. The real purpose for this mission is for Tonina to find her true people and homeland. As she travels across the sea and through the jungles of Central America, she encounters a strange speechless boy, a one-eyed dwarf, and a local hero named Kaan. When circumstances beyond their control force Kaan and Tonina to undertake a long arduous journey together, Tonina begins to learn that the question of her origins may be more complex than she has imagined. As the dangerous mission through the wilds continues, her group attracts a myriad of followers and she and her party encounter ancient tribes, abandoned religious ruins, and deadly enemies bent on destruction. Along with a set of breathtaking discoveries, Tonina discovers that one of her number will be an unlikely ally and friend, and this unexpected partnership may shape the course of her life, forever altering her destiny.
The story of Tonina and her journey was an extremely interesting take on early Mayan and Aztec civilizations. From cultural adversities between tribes, to the religious aspects of the region, the book was an all-encompassing look at a part of world that doesn't get much notice. I found the level of detail of all aspects of the society very engrossing. The book had a directness in tone that made the information particularly entertaining, and although most of the people in the book were fictional, the society and some of the characters portrayed were not. I was amazed to learn of the advancement of the Mayan people in regards to everything from time calculation to cosmetic body enhancements. The religious beliefs of the Mayans and Aztecs were very similar to some of the fundamental truths of Western religion. Most of my enchantment with this book came from depth of the cultural detail and the ability of the author to convey this forgotten culture.
This book was dense with characters, but never became confusing or crowded despite their colorful, in-depth portrayals. I particularly enjoyed the saucy character of One-Eye, the dwarf, and Ha'meen, the aging wizened child who oversaw the palace gardens. Although Tonina's character could be too naive and trusting at times, her intelligence and resourcefulness canceled out her other flaws. Throughout the story she was genuine and kind hearted, even when circumstances were against her. Only the character Brave Eagle (the speechless boy) seemed out of place. He, in my opinion, was underutilized in the story, and it was a bit confusing to finally see the worthiness of his character apart from being used as a plot contrivance.
The first section of this book, which deals with Tonina's exodus from the island where she was raised, was the only shaky part of the story. It seemed rushed, and the circumstances of Tonina's alienation from the other island dwellers was never fully explained, except that she was different from them physically. I didn't really understand the hostility of some of the others on the island when they reacted to an ordinary occurrence and made it a source for anger and revenge. It was clear that Tonina needed to leave the island, but the catalyst for that conclusion seemed forced and unnatural. This, in my opinion, was the low spot in the book, and because of it, I found it harder to immerse myself in the story. The later sections were more engaging and believable and I found my interest in the story picked up after the first few chapters.
Despite some minor setbacks with plot and character, this was ultimately an enjoyable book. I found it had an odd, irresistible pull to it, and I read along with fervor to find out what would happen next. There were many twists and turns to the tale that were both unexpected and fascinating, and this made up for the previous missteps. This book was an interesting departure from those that I normally read, and I would recommend it for those who would enjoy a peek into primitive Mayan and Aztec culture.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Silly, April 15, 2009
Barbara Wood disappoints me for the first time. I was excited about this novel as it takes place among the Tainos and the Mayans in the days before Columbus. Tonina is abandoned on an island as a baby and raised by the natives despite her obvious differences. At 21, they send her off on a "quest" for a special flower, hoping she will find her real tribe. She ends up in Mayapan and meets a ball player and a one eyed midget and this crazy fantasy like adventure starts. It strikes me as the kind of story that you would read to your kids before bed, rather than an adult novel. She even rescues a boy that becomes an eagle. Little too "fantasy land" for my taste. I also noticed a drastic difference in writing style. Normally in Wood's novels, the reader really gets intimate and in depth with her heroines. However, in this one, I failed to get a real feel for Tonina as the story was told in such an offhand, impersonal way.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Okay, but nothing spectacular, December 5, 2009
This review is from: Woman of a Thousand Secrets (Hardcover)
This was an enjoyable enough read, but ultimately I found it slightly disappointing. The best part was the evocative setting: the characters journey through lush jungles and ruined cities in the time of the Maya. Unfortunately, though, the author wasn't content to let us experience this world through the eyes of the characters. We were constantly jerked back to a modern, European-based worldview by phrases like "Guama could not begin to guess that on this important day... the country of the goblet's origin was referring to this seasonal cycle as the Year of Our Lord 1323" or "the mountain town of Cuauhnahuac... which a future race of men would alter to Cuernevaca, deeming it more pronounceable". One of the worst interruptions came when a character saw a vast number of orange and black butterflies and interpreted it as an omen from the gods, "not knowing that she was witnessing the annual migration of a butterfly that would one day be called 'monarch,' and that these millions of butterflies had just ended a flight of three thousand miles, begun in the far north at a place someday to be called the Great Lakes." What bothered me most was how unnecessary this was; the reader is perfectly capable of recognizing a black and orange butterfly as a monarch, and the monarch's migrations are likewise fairly common knowledge. It was like the author had done her research and wanted to make sure everyone knew it, rather than letting her knowledge remain subtly in the background.
The characters suffered from a certain lack of subtlety, too; the good guys are unfailingly honourable and the bad guy is completely delusional. The issues they faced were also fairly standard: people had to accept their true selves so that love could triumph in the face of adversity. The best way to describe my objection to this might be to say that it felt too much like a typical women's book.
Still, despite focusing on the negatives here, I certainly don't regret the time spent on this book, and would consider reading another by the same author. It was worth it for the setting alone, and the storyline did hold my attention. So although it wasn't exceptional, it definitely wasn't a bad book either.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|