2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Engrossing in a morbid way, August 1, 2008
This review is from: Women's Prison (DVD)
This film starts with a whimper and ends with a whine, yet, although one realizes it from the minute one buys it, it is indeed strangely engrossing. The chaos and filth of this Iranian women's prison, starting in 1984, with the Mullahs in charge already four years, extending all the way until 2001: we in the West can see how many women were suddenly considered "unIslamic" and therefore condemned to prison, if not death. What struck me is the horrific resemblance to old-style Catholic nuns, who did instruct us in a grammar school in San Francisco: their completely black outfits, their sternness and their lack of smiling or other expressions. A new warden arrives, aims for cleanliness and discipline, and she gets it, using the solitary cell and male-delivered lashings. There is a strong sense of sadistic pleasure emanating...
Meanwhile, the inmates seem to be mostly in for adultery or prostitution, because they are poor; our one main character arrives young and tough, having killed her stepfather when she saw him beat her mother. Her spirit is not completely broken, but we see her sadly becomes more morose and aged as the film proceeds, with a bemused look at the new young ones coming in, still high-spirited. They call her "Auntie Mitra" at the end, when her hair is turning white under the mandatory hejab.
The prison itself is 1800's-grim, with old brick walls, a large yard for exercise, hand laundry and dish-washing. The prisoners appear to make their own clothes, cook and clean, and wash clothes in small buckets. They do not wear uniforms, but normal street clothes, and only with a new warden do they really begin to use the hejab. They even have one proper long coat, all in the same print material, with which they attend their trials.
If you think that this is a dreary tale so far, well, yes, it is. But the sheer spirit and comraderie of these women impressed me. They sing, they dance, they stage mock weddings, they withstand blackouts, they do sports in the yards, have friends and cliques, and talk incessantly. They're usually in the long, wide corridor together, freely walking between the cells, unless the warden wants to punish them by locking them in for a day to their respective group cells, about 10 beds per cell. One might even say that they're having a pretty good time, except for being locked up. They even have their children with them, which all seem to keep an eye on. One baby, born in the prison in 1984, re-appears as a 17-year-old ringleader and cocksure thief, whose mother had been executed; our heroine Mitra had been trained as a midwife and delivered her in that cell, with a blackout going on. Mitra remembered her mother and told the eager girl about her; they became close in the prison.
One word of caution: I am laid up with an Achilles Tendon rupture, have to kill the time somehow with books and films, and so I watch almost anything. But I liked this film. The filmmaker was herself involved in Iran's women's prisons and tried to show exactly how things were in there.
Libraries probably carry this as "educational" and "banned in Iran!"
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting, March 21, 2007
This review is from: Women's Prison (DVD)
The story begins in the early 1980's and ends a little after the turn of the century. Although there are two main characters; the warden, and a murderess named Mitra, I think the story is really about the "whys" of these women being in prison. Some are in prison for "unislamic conduct", others for their political or religious views, and yet another woman is in prison because her husband has accused her of adultery. Besides the "whys" issue, I think this film also wishes to show the conditions of women's prisons in Iran. The prison is a broken-down building, the inside is dirty and the women are covered with lice. Some of the women have been imprisoned with their young children. Yes, these children actually grow up in the prison. One child is left behind as his mother is dragged to the gallows. Disorderly prisoners are subject to solitary confinement, and lashings. In one scene prisoners are forced to stand outside for hours in the snow. Rape by male prison guards is also suggested. No wonder the film is banned in Iran. I thought this was an interesting film - the story, acting, costumes, and setting were all very good.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
fairly awful, April 27, 2007
This review is from: Women's Prison (DVD)
The basic story with this film is that it was underwritten and countenanced by the Iranian government, but when it came time to take a look at what the director had wrought, the officials blanched, and to this day the film has only been shown in Tehran in a extensively butchered edition. But it has been shown there; hence the "Banned in Iran" brag on the cover is only partially true.
Well, on the one hand, it does offer a look at something few Westerners could even imagine: what day-to-day life is like in an Iranian women's prison. Come on: how many of you could imagine what the inside of one looked like?
Yet the film is stiff and boring. The direction is heavy-handed and inept, the story uninteresting, and the characters, only sketchily developed. On the whole, when you finish the movie, you'll probably wish you had stopped it 10 minutes in. Everything after that doesn't add much.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
