[Summary: Too imaginative and quirky for FOX, but "Wonderfalls" is wonderful when you can view all 13 episodes. Higly recommended.]
"Wonderfalls" is an episodic comedy, set in Niagara Falls, New York. It's an "hour" (3/4 when subtracting commercial time) show, without a laugh track. Highly innovative, it uses its setting to great effect, including using View-Master slides for act changes and tourist tchotchkies to inspire unexpected acts of compassion in a previously lackluster protagonist.
OK, so you're a typical member of Generation Why Me, overeducated and undermotivated. You've found the ideal job working in a Niagara Falls gift shop, where you figure if you show up for work you've accomplished enough for the day. You just got passed over for Assistant Manager, losing out to a mouth breather who's still in high school. And now the knick-knacks you're supposed to be selling are talking to you, telling you to do things. You're not sure whether the voices are coming from God, Satan, or a tumor in your brain, but your biggest question is: "Why me?".
That's Jaye Tyler, youngest and weirdest of a family living in Niagara Falls, New York. Parents Darrin and Karen, sister Sharon and brother Aaron don't really understand Jaye. And neither did the FOX Network, which jerked "Wonderfalls" around mercilessly in their schedule and then dropped it, airing only four episodes after paying for thirteen. The people who buy new shows at FOX are a lot smarter than those (ir-)responsible for their schedules. "Wonderfalls" fell victim to the FOX Friday Night Curse, joining "M.A.N.T.I.S.", "Firefly", "Space: Above and Beyond", "Strange Luck", "John Doe", "VR.5", "The Lone Gunmen", "Harsh Realm", "Sliders", "Brimstone", "Tru Calling", "The Adventures of Brisco County, Jr.", "Alien Nation", "Roar", "Futurama", "Kindred: The Embraced", "Night Visions", "The Tick", "Werewolf", and "Wolf Lake". If you've got an idea for a strange new show, you might be able to sell it to FOX. But expect to be pre-empted, moved to a different night, and have the episode order shuffled. Bleah!
Thank you for reading my rant about FOX, and now I promise to get back to reviewing the "Wonderfalls" DVD collection. This includes three discs, with four episodes on Discs 1 and 2, and five on Disc 3. If you managed to catch all four broadcast episodes you've still got nine more that will be new to you. They include answers to questions like "Will Jaye find true love?", and yes, the all-important "Why me?".
In addition to the full 13 episodes you'll get commentary on half of them from the same foursome: series star Caroline Dhavernas ("Jaye Tyler"), Katie Finneran ("Sharon Tyler"), and co-creators Todd Holland and Bryan Fuller. Scotch Ellis Loring ("Dr. Ron Campbell", plus the voice of various muses -- the talking animals) joins them on one commentary. And there's even a music video, with Caroline and other cast members lip-synching their way through a rendition of the title song!
I'm not going to spoil the actual 13 episodes for you, but I will note that in the commentaries you'll find out the plans for important elements of Season 2 (the lesbian pregnancy) & Season 3 (Jaye in the loony bin), plus character traits of the Tyler clan that never got to show up in Season 1. Republican Party folk ballads, anyone?
The video and audio are excellent. While the broadcast episodes were cropped to fill the screen, they're presented in widescreen on DVD.
The "Wonderfalls" cast is eclectic. Caroline Dhavernas is a big star in her native Canada, but her repertoire pre-Wonderfalls is entirely dramatic. Happily, she shows a real flair for comedy here. Tyron Leitso ("Eric Gotts") was the de facto hero (i.e. he survived) in "House of the Dead". Katie Finneran mostly does stage work. Lee Pace ("Aaron Tyler") and Tracie Thoms ("Mahandra McGinty") were Juilliard classmates. William Sadler ("Darin Tyler") was the bad guy in "Die Hard 2", the sheriff in "Roswell", and the mummy in "Bordello of Blood". Diana Scarwid ("Karen Tyler") has been acting professionally since 1977, but "Wonderfalls" is her only regular TV series.
The locations are *almost* right. Niagara Falls, Ontario substitutes for Niagara Falls, New York. The interiors were shot in Toronto. With environments this close to authentic the lighting and other aspects of exterior shots are wholly believable.
If this spoiler-free review leaves you unsure whether to buy the "Wonderfalls" DVD collection, I apologize. I recommend the show highly, and like it so much that I didn't want to detract from your enjoyment in the slightest. It's hard to describe, but worthwhile to those who take a leap of faith.