10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A must have for Simpsons fans and Non-Simpsons Fans alike., August 19, 2006
This review is from: The World According to The Simpsons: What Our Favorite TV Family Says about Life, Love, and the Pursuit of the Perfect Donut (Paperback)
I have always been a fan of the simpsons, but I have a lot of friends who aren't. I have always tried to tell them that the simpsons is probably the smartest show on TV, and that there are so many great lessons to be learned from the episodes. They always say, it is just a stupid show because Homer acts dumb, the kids are disrespectful, and Bart is a terrible role model. This book is a book that I have always wanted to write myself for quite sometime that actually shows the genius writing behind the show and the lessons that can be learned from the shows' plots and quotes. I am very happy that I bought this book. It is a really fun read, and very interesting. I showed it to one of my friends that hates the simpsons, and he read some of it and asked if he could borrow my simpsons dvds to watch a couple of the episodes that he read about. It is a great book!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
fun and entertaining, but too short, January 15, 2008
This review is from: The World According to The Simpsons: What Our Favorite TV Family Says about Life, Love, and the Pursuit of the Perfect Donut (Paperback)
This book covers a lot of topics that The Simpsons mentions in their show. He starts when an analysis of the main characters and then an analysis of the presentation of various cultural and politicial issues that are shown in the show. Surprisingly, the book was written by a college student. Most nonfiction books are written by high level professionals, journalists, or professors. There were some good insights, but the analysis of the issues were mostly short and not well researched.
For instance, in the chapter about Bart, he talks about deviancy and nonconformity. He does not talk about Nelson and his friends and the difference between them and Bart. Nelson revels in whatever pain he causes and does not care who he affects. Bart generally likes to cause pain to authority figures but shows caring when his family is upset. The book does not acknowledge this important difference.
Later on, he talks about Lisa and intellectuals. He does not acknowledge the double standard in American culture that intellectuals are portrayed negatively as "nerds" or "geeks," yet people are very reliant on "expert" advice and opinions. This is an important thing to consider in the discussion about Lisa's character.
The chapter about the supporting cast is also lacking, with the writer giving a brief description of the important characters and very little analysis. Later on, toward the end, there is a chapter about the issue of guns. The author talks about the issue, but there is a lack of real research. He does not talk about the status of guns in other countries. Other countries have much stricter gun control laws. In England, not even cops have guns. This information is often talked about in the gun control debate.
The chapter about celebrity culture shows little good research. He does mention the history behind celebrity obsession and talks about the obvious. He fails to mention the fact that celebrities are simply America's royalty. We don't have an actual royal family, so the public gossips about the rich and famous. Focusing on the lives of the rich and famous is a form of escapism.
The chapter about education was also a bit short. He talked about some issues that are obvious. It surprised me that he did not mention the seminal scene in "The PTA Disbands" when krabapple and skinner are talking to the issue. The support more money for education, but not more money for taxes and the audience keeps switching their support for the issue. This scene shows the hypocriscy of the public, that they readily support increased education funding, but not increased taxes.
All in all, there are some insights and this book is an entertaining read, but not much more. Definitely not a serious works and could be a lot better with more indepth research.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
