50 of 51 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Out of this world, March 8, 2007
In the Yiddish folk tales that are woven through this magnificent book, the World to Come is a heaven occupied both by those that have passed on and those that have yet to be born. So Dara Horn writes about families and generations: elders who have passed on (or in some cases been eliminated), adults facing tragedy, finding new love, or conceiving new life, and children trying to figure out what it all means. One folk tale tells of a town where nobody ever dies, because nobody has really truly lived; throughout the book, Horn is concerned with the quality of living, with risk-taking, faith, and trust, and with authenticity in life or in art. This may sound abstract, but Horn's writing is far from it; her greatest gift is to plunge the reader into the souls of her characters, sharing their experience through their eyes, ears, and skin.
In some ways, this novel reminded me of
THE HISTORY OF LOVE by Nicole Krauss, another recent novel spanning several generations of Jewish families in Europe and America. Just as that was tied together by the fate of a manuscript whose history spans much of the twentieth century, so this also revolves around an artwork, or rather two of them: a small Chagall painting that is stolen from a New York museum at the start of the book, and some stories by the Yiddish writer Der Nister (the Hidden One), who ultimately met the same fate as numerous other Jewish intellectuals in Soviet Russia. Both art forms -- painting and folk tales -- offer ways of looking at the world that are instinctive rather than logical, childlike in their immediacy, and closer to religion than to fact. Both deal with other worlds. Many of the characters in the book are involved with the visual arts, but since this is a novel it is the stories that provide the connective tissue, offering a different way of seeing to stand against the many tragedies of the past century. As Horn acknowledges in the appendix, most of the stories are adapted from earlier writers, but her skill is to weave them into a narrative that links divers times and places in a web of feelings and perceptions rather than as points on the railroad of chronological logic. This wondrous novel seems to be at once totally original and to have existed for ever.
I have to admit that my attitudes to the book went through some changes. I was put off reading it for several months because of the excessive cuteness of the original cover [I see it has now changed]. It was not until I got into it that I realized that this was an adult story, childlike at its best moments, certainly, but never childish. Once I had come to trust Dara Horn as a storyteller, I felt she could take me anywhere: to modern life in New York, the privations of an orphanage in Soviet Russia, the horrors of Vietnam, or the imagined world of folk tales going back centuries. I found myself telling everybody I met that this was something on the level of Paul Auster's
ORACLE NIGHT, Myla Goldberg's
BEE SEASON, the Krauss HISTORY OF LOVE, or (in a non-Jewish context) Ann Patchett's
BEL CANTO -- writers that one can trust completely, knowing that danger would be answered by joy, intrigue by the bright clarity of truth. But all these adventurous writers face the problem of bringing their many strands of feeling and event together into a satisfying conclusion. Horn's solution is to end with a folk tale of her own creation. I have to say that this is less effective than most of the adapted tales she had included earlier, taking the reader on an extended excursion to the other world when he is aching to know what happens in this one. But the emotional conclusion that lies behind this little parable is absolutely right, and brings this treasure-house of a book back to something simple and true.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
47 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Storytelling at its best, February 27, 2006
In the World to Come, Dara Horn manages to weave family history with myths of birth and paradise to create a beautiful tale. She begins with Ben Ziskind, who steals a Chagall painting from a museum when no one is looking. Ben is going through a bit of a personal crisis at the time, so it's unclear whether he is correct that this painting once belonged to his family or he is simply becoming delusional. We soon come to understand Ben, his motives, and his fears.
Horn's real talent is the ability to switch between scenes, timelines and perspectives all while keeping the interest of the reader. In many novels I find myself slogging through certain parts, biding my time to return to the characters I truly care about. All of Horn's characters are interesting, and I relished all of them equally.
Death is a common theme in the World to Come, and it is to Horn's great credit that her novel is nevertheless optimistic. The denouement may leave some readers craving for more details about exactly what happened next. That is Horn's plan, and she executes it with brilliance.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
26 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dara Horn has outdone herself!, February 22, 2006
After reading "In the Image", Dara Horn's impressive debut novel, I could not wait to read her next creation. "The World to Come" exceeded my expectations!
This beautifully written, multidimensional novel will have broad appeal to lovers of historical fiction, symbolic literature, mystery, romance and much, much more. The novel is deep and philosophical, but also is just plain fun to read with colorful characters and a suspenseful plot that smoothly carries the reader between different time periods and places. A lot of research obviously went into this work, and readers learn interesting, little-known facts about Marc Chagall's art, Yiddish literature, and Russian and American history by osmosis.
What makes art famous and what does it mean to own it? How does our family shape our destiny? When do we encounter "the world to come"? The book touches upon these questions and leaves you with even more. I guarantee you will be thinking it over after you have turned the last page. That is the sign of a great novel, and this book definitely deserves your consideration.
The most pressing question for me is ... when does Dara Horn's third novel come out?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No