15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Good, Short Guide to World War One, June 23, 2009
It is difficult to do justice to as great an event as the First World War in only 180 pages, but Stone does as well as we could hope. He does particularly well in describing the causes of the war and in showing at the end of his narrative how this war was really the prelude for the even greater, even more costly Second World War. Though it is relatively easy to read, it can be a little bit difficult to follow simply because so much had to be left out so this could be, as it claims, a short history. Still, anyone who is eager to read a brief overview of the War, or anyone who seeks to understand some of the background to the Second War, would do well to read this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
An Excellent Summary of "The War to End Wars"., March 11, 2010
When you put this book down - and it doesn't take all that long to read the 190 pages of it - one is left with two opinions - or at least I was. First, that you have read a very readable, authoritative and concise history of this horrible and unnecessary conflict; and, Second, that you need some time to consider what it all meant in the long run - the rise of two dictatorial and militant states (Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia) a second even more terrible war, the end of France as a controlling European power, the end of war "as we knew it" - the war of with cavalry charges, bugles and "gallantry" etc.
This was war of a new kind. No longer is war left to the warriors. The entire population is involved. Cities (London) were bombed from the air for the first time. There are new weapons - tanks, airplanes, poison gas - entire countries laid waste physically and economically. And I could go on. But you get the drift. The thinking and analyses part takes longer than the reading part.
With respect to the reading part I learned a lot I had not known about the fighting on the Eastern front and in the Carpathians. Professor Stone is trenchant and opinionated; but for anyone wanting a concise history of World War I this is the book for that person. However, if you want more facts - and I did - John Keegan's "The First World War" (Vintage Books 2000) gives a fuller account of the tragedy and is beautifully written - well worth reading.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A highly readable short history of World War One, July 18, 2009
In 190 pages plus maps, Prof. Norman Stone summarizes World War One, variously and erroneously know as "The Great War" and the "War To End All Wars". It was, in fact, a grandiose display of human stupidity. All the "great powers" were involved with perhaps 70 million men putting on uniforms and taking up arms. In the end, 15 million were dead and the stage was set for an even bloodier world conflict in less than a generation.
WWI is boring to most people. The Western Front was largely static, with no grand advances or retreats by either side after the first few months. The Eastern Front, while it laid the groundwork for the cataclysmic collapse of Tsarist Russia was more dynamic, but also more remote to most readers. The peripheral fronts along the Italian border and in the Middle East are scarcely known, though the events in the latter laid the foundation for the world situation today.
Thus, this very concise history by Prof. Stone should be greeted with delight by the casual student of history attempting to grasp how the 20th Century became the most deadly time in history.
Stone's command of the subject is complete. His vast knowledge is demonstrated by his judicious omission of details that would be vital in a more specialized history. Stone provides the outline of how the war came to be after one of the most peaceful and inventive eras of European history. He is unsparing in his treatment of the politicians of the major players and their grasping for greater power, wealth and territory.
The scale of the war, which could have been prevented by any of several "leaders", was made possible by the increased production capability and wealth of each of the belligerents. Stone does an excellent job of explaining how national cultures shaped the military strategy and tactics of each nation. For the British and French, the Napoleonic wars of the 19th Century provided the model, a state of mind that literally murdered millions of young men. The Germans, ironically, had greater faith in their individual citizens and produced a stronger army with more innovative tactics.
The Russians were simply hopeless, with only a few rare exceptions.
Stone explains how the Western Front ossified into trench warfare, with one bloodletting after another because military leaders in general failed to recognize the reality of industrial age warfare. (Stone touches upon, but does not go into detail about, the sophistication of the trench systems, which is a worthy subject in its own right.)
Each of the major battles is analyzed, which is quite a feat in so few pages.
Overall, Professor Stone has produced a highly readable short history which will fill in the blanks for many about World War I.
Jerry
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No