Most Helpful Customer Reviews
55 of 60 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Beautiful pictures, but short on insights, October 24, 1998
This review is from: The World's Best Sailboats: A Survey (Hardcover)
This is book of beautiful pictures and great interviews with designers of some of the most respected sailboat builders in the world. I enjoyed the read and I very much liked the emphasis on overall quality that comes through loud and clear. Mate's book, however, is like a tour guide to the world of the "rich and famous", not a practical guide to functional sailboats. If you have $800K to buy an Alden or a Hinkley, then be my guest, but understand that while these boats are built to the highest quality standards, some of the design compromises they incorporate do not produce the safest, most appropriate, or the most durable boats in the world. Mate' is clearly a knowledgeable sailor and no lightweight when it comes to boat design issues, but he seems to have missed the point with this book. I had almost bought into his philosophy that a beautiful boat with lovely teak decks and interiors is the same a "great" sailboat when I saw a write-up on Steve Dashew's new "Beowulf" series of boats and how they were designed and developed(covered in "The Encyclopedia of Cruising"). Dashew's thoughts are worlds apart from the design philosophies of the manufacturers of high-end production boats like the ones covered in Mate's book. If the purpose of this book is to provide a useful guide to the market for new production sailboats, to my mind, the author has missed the mark. A potential sailboat buyer will benefit far more by taking a look at some of Dashew's design comments than he or she might by reviewing any of the boats mentioned in this book. What bothered me most about this book was the boat builders that Mate' excluded as well as some that made his "A" list. No production boat mentioned in this book is built out of aluminum which is far superior to GRP in almost every respect. On the other side of the coin, some of the boats included had me scratching my head. Hallberg-Rassy and Beneteau were both reviewed even though both have serious weaknesses as far as blue water sailing in rough weather is concerned. Hallberg-Rassy still uses the chopped glass lay-up method for its hulls which is far weaker and less stiff way of building hulls than woven GRP. Beneteaus, which are marvelous boats for the price, lack stiffness because of the use of a plastic shell liners rather than integral beams and other stiffeners used in most better boats. You would not want to spend much time in the Southern Ocean in either of these production boats. All in all, I loved the photographs, enjoyed the comments of the designers, but ultimately found the book lacking in useful insights. As a tour of what's available at the high-end of the production market, the book may have some merits, but viewed as an aid to selecting a safe and suitable boat it falls short.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Delicious eye candy, December 28, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: The World's Best Sailboats: A Survey (Hardcover)
The photography is stunning, the interviews thought-provoking. If you want to see beautiful boats in all their glory, this is the book for you. Selection is a bit arbitrary; the high technology side of the industry is pretty much ignored. But that's not what this book is about. It's about beauty. It's about style. It's about craftsmanship. Those are great things, in any era, for any reason. But I do join with the previous reviewer: This is an appreciation, not a buyers' guide. By all means buy the Dashews' Offshore Cruising Encyclopedia and educate yourself technically before spending $ 500,000 plus on a boat. Buy this book and let your imagination soar, into a world where you have the funds and the energy to maintain a sixty-five foot teak-laden palace. True beauty is yours.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This book would be cheap at twice the price!, June 3, 2000
This review is from: The World's Best Sailboats: A Survey (Hardcover)
This is an absolutely gorgeous book. The photography is awesome! It is a "dreambook." You would not look through it in order to choose a boat. Most of them would only be available as used boats in any case. You buy this book for your coffee table, because you love fine, beautiful yachts! Ferenc Mate has done a remarkable job, bringing together some of the finest sailing yachts, designed by the world's best naval architects and built by some of the best yards. The boats are described in the text, and the building techniques and history discussed, and line drawings presented of the plans, buttock lines, sailplans and accommodations. But, the most striking feature of the book is the exquisite photographs, many of which were made by Mate himself (photographic credits are listed on page 281.) One does not need to be a yacht owner to love such vessels, or to love this book. However, I have been a yacht owner. I built my own, in my back yard: a ketch-rigged (two-masted) trimaran, the Wild Goose, document number 516550 Net 11. She was a 36' beauty, with a 20' beam that took me four years to build and all the money in the world. We sailed her and lived on her for a couple of years in the Pacific. Anyone who has ever longed for their own boat will want this fine book to dream over. Such dreams can and do come true. Take my word for it, they do! Joseph Pierre, Author of THE ROAD TO DAMASCUS: Our Journey Through Eternity
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|