17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
ABBA Reviewed Again, June 30, 2006
This review is from: The World's Greatest Albums: ABBA - The Gold Singles (DVD)
This is the second ABBA music review disc to be offered on Amazon. The first "Music In Review- ABBA 1973-1982" contained a review on each of ABBA's 8 albums. This disc "Worlds Greatest Albums: The Gold Singles is just a review of the individual songs on ABBA Gold.
The presenter on this program is Graham Mctavish and the reviewers are: Collin Irwin, Chris Roberts, Pip Williams and Les Davidson. This disc is similar to the "Music in Review" disc however the quality of the clips that they use are much better. However when they do present a clip, it is in a small box in the center of the screen with logos all around it. You don't get to enjoy the clips much. They pull footage from 'ABBA Special Japan 1978, Midnight Special, Starparade 1978 Germany, Don Kirshners Rock Concert 1975 ect.
The critics on this disc are much harsher than the previous release, for example one of them hates 'Mamma Mia' and 'I Have A Dream' and all of them despise 'Does Your Mother Know', so unlike the first disc this isn't all pro-ABBA but a much more balanced review. Some fans when buying discs like these are not interested in 'balanced' reviews, they of course want to hear nothing but praise for their heroes, so if you are one of these stay away from this disc or you'll find yourself yelling at the TV set! My 2 star rating comes from the fact that nothing new is revealed here that most ABBA fans don't already know, and the presentation would be better if you saw the whole clip on full screen, not in a small box. Also the songs are not complete, you will only hear a portion of them and the reviewers will come on and tell you what they think of them. This disc also contains only an image gallery, with pictures that we have all seen before, nothing new or special. Other than that no special features, no book. (The other disc "Music in Review" contains a book.)
Final thought, the clips-shrunk down and incomplete- the reviews- debatable. Nothing new, nothing we haven't seen before.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Skip it....a rental only., August 12, 2006
This review is from: The World's Greatest Albums: ABBA - The Gold Singles (DVD)
I would like to second everything in the first review on this page. There is nothing here you haven't seen before, if you're an ABBA fan, and I'd like to add that the main presenter has the annoying habit of mispronouncing Agnetha's name every single time, (hint: it's NOT pronounced "Agg-nee-tha"...do some research, for pete's sake). For some unknown reason, the program completely leaves out any mention or critique of the "Gold" album's tracks, "One of Us" and "The Name of the Game". (Even though, like the same company's "Music in Review" 2-DVD set that preceeded this release, you still hear a very questionable cover band singing "One of Us", this time over the program's end credits. Who wants to hear that after an hour and a half of the real thing?) Overall, the commentary and criticism is not worth very much on this DVD, and is almost laughable at times. Skip this, or if you must, just rent it instead, because it's definitely not worth the purchase price. You won't want to watch it more than once.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
