Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Ancient Faith, Present Reality, March 5, 2010
This review is from: Worshiping with the Church Fathers (Paperback)
As 21st century Christians, we tend to think that our ways of "doing church" are either 1) the same as those of believers through the ages, or 2) somehow better than early Church practices. Most of us try very carefully to match our practices to Scripture, but 2,000 years of cultural baggage affects our understanding of what it means to worship the Lord in Spirit and in Truth.
In Worship with the Church Fathers (part of a four-part series on patristic teachings), Eastern University chancellor Christopher Hall digs into the writings of early Christian leaders (Ambrose, Athanasius, Augustine, Clement, Cyril, Irenaeus, John Chrysostom, John of Damascus, Justin Martyr, Tertullian, and others) to lay out something of an "early Church theology of worship," drawing important themes and principles that modern believers would do well to understand and apply.
Hall grounds his discussion on worship in the early Church's understanding of sacramentalism--that is, the use of physical elements to represent spiritual realities. He points out that the Church fathers used the Latin word "sacramentum" to translate the Greek word mysterion, which the New Testament writers used to describe the deep truths of the faith that transcend comprehension. The fathers, Hall states, passionately pursued the sacraments, seeing them as the opposite of dualism and Gnostic heresy. They saw them as reminders that God's creation was important to Him, and viewed the symbolism of worship as a crucial continuation of the principle of the incarnation.
Hall devotes particular attention to the practice and significance of baptism (in which the water represents the cleansing and life-giving of the Spirit), the eucharist, prayer, and spiritual discipline (i.e. fasting, silence, etc.). His chapters on prayer are a powerful reminder of the centrality of prayer to the Christian life (and show an interesting perspective on the character of God), but his discussion of the eucharist, while helpful in articulating a Christocentric view of communion, goes too far toward the Catholic/Eastern Orthodox position of transubstantiation to be wholeheartedly recommended.
On balance, Worship with the Church Fathers provides evangelicalism with a needed viewpoint--that worship is neither wholly intellectual nor wholly emotional but grounded in the spiritual and physical reality of God's presence. While Hall's biases lie with the more liturgical traditions, his faithful study of the first generations after Christ is informative and instructive.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Colossal Pop Review, January 6, 2010
This review is from: Worshiping with the Church Fathers (Paperback)
"Worshiping With The Church Fathers" is probably not a book the average everyday Christian is going to read but there is no reason they shouldn't. It will, however, appeal to the curious thinker and Ancient Church history buff like myself. Author Christopher Hall is the Chancellor of Eastern University near Philadelphia, PA and has written a very well documented and informed book that looks at the ancient practices of worship among the early church fathers. To the average reader this may sound like a dry and boring read but Hall doesn't just spew out facts and information, he challenges the reader to look at early worship practices and see how they can be applied in modern day living of the Christian today.
This book is divided into three topical sections which include the Sacraments, Prayer and Discipline. Within these topics there are sub categories which include baptism, the Lord's supper, The Lord's Prayer, roadblocks to prayer and many others. What has been insightful to me in the section on baptism is his section on infant baptism and the early churches view of this practice. This has been one area in which I struggle and it was interesting to see how the early father's viewed it. The second part of the book which is on prayer is probably the most applicable part to the book. It looks at various aspects to prayer like praying the Psalms, distractions in prayer, unanswered prayer, fixed times for prayer and the four key elements of prayer (supplication, intercession, thanksgiving and confession). The closing section on discipline gives the reader a glimpse of Athanasius's biography of Anthony and some of the ideas and practices that came out of the monastic communities. The idea behind this section is to show the reader the importance of slowing down and seeing how the "desert life"can be applicable to busy pastors, preists and Christians in general.
Is this an easy read? By no means. As I mentioned earlier it is a great read for individuals who are interested in the spiritual practices and beliefs of the early Church Fathers. As a pastor myself I found this book to be insightful and practical. "Worshiping With the Church Fathers" would not make for a good daily devotional but it would be a great resource for individuals to have to better understand why and how the early church functioned and worshiped. Don't let the title scare you away, check this book out... You may find your faith encouraged and challenged as you do.
([...])
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Church Fathers are Alive, Well and Relevant, June 7, 2010
This review is from: Worshiping with the Church Fathers (Paperback)
Christopher Hall follows his two previous books with a powerful third, topping his other two with deeply powerful insights into forgotten Christian writers - forgotten to the Evangelical world - bridging a gap that is desperately needed between modern Christianity and those greats of the past.
There are no long-winded sermons, dusty facts, or theological interpretations. Instead, Hall connects the Fathers with their own words, sometimes with his insights by experience, producing a text that gives the Christian steady reading while he or she explores what the Fathers believed. Starting with the Eucharist and Baptism, he doesn't argue for sacramentalism, but shows how the Fathers lived the communication of Grace, a tradition handed down time and time again, by various writers, producing a strong focus in the Christian life. Moving into prayer, he shares with the reader his challenges in presenting a better understanding of prayer, something that he struggles with himself. Finally, he ends with individual discipline. This book is thoroughly engaging to the theologian, Church Historian, but most and best of all, every Christian.
In a time when we `fit' God into our lives, Hall reminds us of the Fathers and their life led in Christ. He brings home not theological arguments, nor denominational, but draws the reader into Christian historical theology. He seeks to answer the tough questions on prayer with how the Father's did so. He brings in Augustine, Chrysostom, Clement of Alexandria, Origen and numerous others, but he ties these great writers to himself, and thus to us, by sharing his personal experience, such as the sacramentalism he received from his Uncle Bob. He doesn't expect to change anyone's opinions, only to show that, perhaps, what Evangelicalism is missing by ignoring the Fathers and the early theology.
Read it as a Church History text book, or a theological work, or even as a devotional but this book should be read, and will be enjoyed, but those who are seeking something more in there worship of God, and the understanding of the focus placed on such sacraments by Catholics, Orthodox and others as they worship God.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|