85 of 87 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
MY CAREER AS A PRO BEGAN BY READING THIS BOOK, February 8, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: Writer's Guide to Book Editors, Publishers, and Literary Agents, 2002-2003: Who They Are! What They Want! And How to Win Them Over! (Paperback)
First, folks, let me say I am a professional writer who prefers to remain anonymous, whose third novel will come out in hardcover from a major house this fall, and my agent is getting me six-figure advances, including foreign rights and audio sales. Second, like all you aspiring writers out there, four years ago I was a struggling "wannabee" too, with my own gigantic pile of "Dear Author" rejection letters. I quickly learned that wannabee writers fell into one of two groups, which I labeled the "willoughbies" (the people who WILL break in professionally sooner or later) and the "wontabees" (the people who will never succeed no matter how much you try to help them). If you really, truly want to go pro, you have to be honest with yourself that at any point in your early career you still have a heck of a lot to learn -- and the Herman Guide will make a big difference in getting you there. So, I agree with the other 5-star reviewers below, that the 1-star reviewers of the classic, indispensable Herman Guide sound like sour-grape whiners and complainers. Agents have no time or patience for obvious wontabees. And believe me, they can smell a wontabee within 3 seconds of when they open the submission envelope. Don't blame it on Anthrax.
So why is this Guide valuable to you? It is the most complete and accurate existing guide to agents -- who are the only people you should contact if you have a full-length book you want to get published, not editors. Whoever below said that editors are more approachable might have been talking about short stories for magazines, where it's true that you don't need an agent and no agent will want to even look at your stuff anyway. And the guy or gal who said below that Herman is out of date probably doesn't realize how long it takes from when the raw material of a book is ready, to when the actual book reaches the bookstores. It takes over a year, sometimes closer to two years!!! Editing, production steps, and advance marketing, all force this long lead time. So, OF COURSE you should double-check the info to make sure it's current and accurate. What Herman says about my own literary agent, for instance, is spot on!!!
I strongly recommend that you read every single agent's description of their "dream client" and their "client from hell" -- yes, every darned one of them in this Guide -- and then think hard about what they say, and learn from it before you send out another submission. It WILL make a difference. If you're too lazy to carefully read hundreds of different agent listings, or too self-referential to learn from this solid-gold resource of wisdom, then you're a wontabee for sure.
In summary, without this Guide I would not have learned how much there was to know about things that I didn't even know I needed to know, and I would certainly not have learned the "right answers" to all these unasked questions. Nor would I have happily left my previous career "day job" far behind me long ago, and be making a very nice living as a full-time professional writer. If this sounds opinionated to all you wontabees out there, well, what can you do, I'm opinionated.
PS: Also strongly recommend agent Donald Maass's THE CAREER NOVELIST. Hard hitting, no punches pulled, eye opening, cynical, whatever, you gotta read it. (No, Donald Maass is not my agent, though I did meet him once at a writers conference.)
PPS: I predict this review will get lots of "not useful" votes from bitter wontabees. Too bad.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
64 of 67 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
my advice, January 30, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: Writer's Guide to Book Editors, Publishers, and Literary Agents, 2002-2003: Who They Are! What They Want! And How to Win Them Over! (Paperback)
You can get a copy of the association of authors' representatives (AAR) for free online... Next, take another reviewer's advice and look inside books most like yours. Often writers do thank their editor or agent. They don't have to, so there's a vote of approval right there for you to go by. Then research that agent or editor. Use the internet. Plug their name into a google or other search (google.com). The best success I have had with both agents and editors has been with this technique. By doing it you will also learn a lot (maybe much more than you want) about the publishing world. Write them a query and show them that you know your stuff: tell them why you would like to work with them, in particular. Mention the acknowledgment you saw in so and so's book. Go to your library and use Literary Marketplace (for free) and think about buying a copy of Writer's Market for info on publishers and agents. Also go on sites like Preditors and Editors (which although primarily a sci-fi, fantasy site, has great info on many publishers and has info on who to avoid.)
Sometimes writers trying to get published feel like they have an extremely expensive hobby. It gets tiresome buying the how-to books and still not see any income coming in. Don't fret and don't get down. But don't buy things out of desperation either.
Check out info at your library and then buy the reference books that you would like to be able to access daily at home.
Writer's Market is good for the money.
Also, think about finding online support for your writing endeavors. There are many sites where writers talk about their craft and support each other through the... business side of being a writer.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Out-dated information, November 24, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Writer's Guide to Book Editors, Publishers, and Literary Agents, 2002-2003: Who They Are! What They Want! And How to Win Them Over! (Paperback)
I purchased the latest edition of this which was titled, 2001-2002 edition. A more fitting title would be the "1999 Writer's Guide" I write to people who have been gone for two to three years....and their publishing houses are writing nasty letters back to me complaining about my outdated information.
This book is shoddy work that is not helping my efforts as a writer. Listing people who have been gone for two-three years and titling the book as current is both unprofessional and unconscionable. It is pretty clear to me that the cover of this book was changed while everything inside stayed the same...a real scam and a disservice to writers.
My warning to writers is to check every listing before sending out your query letters or proposals....getting the wrong name on your query letter is a quick way to the trash file.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
