Customer Reviews

Writing Arabic: A Practical Introduction to Ruq'ah Script

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

With the greatest of respect for Alif Baa and Mastering Arabic mentioned in the reviews below, neither teachs you good Arabic handwriting, and both also concern themselves with pronunciation and grammar. Writing Arabic, by contrast, concerns itself wholly with the Ruq'a script, the script most Arabs use for their everyday handwriting. The reviewers are right in saying that some knowledge of the Arabic script would be helpful (no, neccessary) before approaching this book - you need the ability to make out ordinary Arabic print (i.e. the calligraphic Naskh script) - and the reader should use this book in conjunction with another book on the Arabic language. However, for the serious student of Arabic, I can't recommend strongly enough the use of this book as soon as you know the alphabet. You'll also learn to read other people's handwriting - no easy thing.

Oh, don't be put off by the 1950's typewritten English script - unlike the other books on offer, no printed Arabic appears in this book, just good handwriting. The others show a little scrappy Naskh script (an extraordinarily difficult script to write properly) and print the rest. The aim of Writing Arabic is to teach you to write Arabic clearly.

[Note Summer 2005: a new book has come out that may be a more user-friendly way of learning good handwriting: Jane Wightwick and Mahmoud Gaafar's "Mastering Arabic Script" (not to be confused with the authors' "Mastering Arabic"), which also teaches ruq'a. I've not seen it yet, though. JL]

If you want to learn how to write Arabic so that your handwriting would even fool an Arab, there is absolutely no better book available. Most other Arabic language books teach only naskh script, which is the Arabic equivalent of block printing and looks juvenile in handwriting. The few books that actually do deal with ruqah script don't really teach the student how to develop good penmanship. Anbody seriously interested in learning to write Arabic as it is written in the modern world cannot ignore this book.

If you've been developing your Arabic handwriting by imitating the printed script used in textbooks and other printed material, you're pretty much wasting your time. The 'Naskh' script is not used by Arabs in handwriting and attempts to imitate it only end up looking amateurish.

Mitchell's book is the only really good introduction into both the handwritten and calligraphic 'Ruq'ah' scripts that I know of. It has a very systematic approach, and comprehensive and thorough coverage which makes it relatively easy to locate specific details-- but since the individual sections are interdependent the student will have to work iteratively through the material front-to-back a number of times until it is completely mastered.

As alluded to in a number of reviews, this book is definitely 'old school'. It is a reproduction of a typewritten and handwritten manuscript, has a pretty high 'information density' (so the book itself is correspondigly deceptively small), and is unforgiving in its use of technical terminology, demanding focused attention from the reader.

Just to reiterate a point made by another reviewer, this book bears no relationship to Alif Baa at all. Alif Baa is a grammar tutorial that does not go into handwriting at all-- and vice versa, Mitchell's book presupposes quite some basic knowledge of Arabic orthography. In any case I'm surprised that someone would recommend Alif Baa under any circumstances, as that suffers, in my opinion, from a great many defects.

If you are used to modern typeset textbooks with four-color graphics, sidebars, and elaborate formatting, you may be disappointed by 'Writing Arabic'. If, however, you can take this book on its own terms, you should find it a valuable and reliable resource.

If you seriously want to learn to write Arabic properly, this very practical manual is indispensable. It shows you how develop your Arabic handwriting step by step in order to achieve stunning results that ooze instant authenticity, and are more Arabic than an Arab's hand !
T F Mitchell has done a great service here, and it's a little surprising why this manual isn't staple as so many go astray by copying the 'naskh' (print) script, which is too much like trying to fit a square peg in a round hole.

Although the essential practicality of the book is beyond reproach, it does need modernising in terms of pen technology discussions, linguistic asides, and colour/typeface. An accompanying CDROM or some type of multimedia ought to be, to use the author's language, 'de rigeur' !

First published in 1953, this text is showing its age. Its chief attribute is that it focuses on the cursive ruqah script as opposed to the printed naskh that is found in many instructional texts. If you want to achieve competence in understanding handwritten Arabic the material here is great for helping you reach that goal. Most of the examples are given with printed and handwritten forms side-by-side which is quite helpful. The pedagogy, however, is archaic and there are a number of more recently published books that provide better instruction on developing good Arabic penmanship. The book also has annoying transliterations which detracts from the emphasis on writing. Despite being an introductory text purchase this book only if you can already read some Arabic. Otherwise try Alif-Baa (Brustad, al-Batal, & al-Tonsi) as suggested by a previous reviewer or Mastering Arabic (Wightwick & Gaafar). Both show how to form cursive strokes in a user-friendly way and have accompanying audio material. If you intend to use this book as a stand-alone introduction to Arabic writing you will likely be disappointed.

The best introduction to writing in an everyday Arabic script well that I know of. What more can I say? A must for students of Arabic. It uses the ruq'a script which nine-tenths of Arabs use to write with. First published in the '50's, it's unsurpassed.

I bought this book hoping to improve my Arabic handwriting. I guess it has helped a little, but before you plunk down thirty dollars for it, there are a few things you should know:

(1) although it has a nice cover, the inside is a photo-reproduced typescript from 1951 that is ugly and quite difficult to read;

(2) although the information provided in the book is somewhat useful, it is quite difficult to follow.

In the introduction to the book, the author laments the lack of awareness that students and scholars have of how to write Arabic properly. This may have been true back then, but now with less "orientalist" introductions to Arabic such as Brustad, al-Batal, and al-Tonsi's "al-Kitaab," which has an excellent introduction to the written and spoken alphabet, I'm not sure how useful this book still is.

If you are obsessed with Arabic handwriting and want to get into the technicalities of writing with a reed stylus, then this book might prove a useful -- if somewhat idiosyncratic -- reference. The table in the appendix, which exhaustively demonstrates the different word forms, is a nice resource. But if you, like me, just want to be able to reproduce a decent script, I recommend looking at Brustad, al-Batal, & al-Tonsi's "Alif Baa" first.