Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Brilliant Origin Story of a Great Marvel Character, June 29, 2009
This review is from: X-Men: Magneto Testament (Hardcover)
A subperb example of expanding a super hero character's origin story. Greg Pak and Carmine Di Giandomenico have done an epic job. They manage to tell Magneto's story, remain true to most of the existing continuity, and maintain historical accuracy. This is a moving and important account of a Jewish boy's coming of age during the Nazi era in Germany, and the story of survival in Auschwitz. But more, this story shows us how the young Magneto (Max Eisenhardt) survived in Auschwitz, working in the Sonderkommando, which reveals much about the character's later history as Magneto. The writing and art are first rate. The coloring is excellent as well. The book contains a true Holocaust story -- that of Dina Babbitt, called "The Last Outrage" and a teacher's guide for Holocaust studies in the classroom. Magneto is one of Marvel's most important and sophisticated characters. Despite repeated depictions in the comics (in recent years) that are flat, one-dimensional, and uninspired, (usually due to the writer not wanting to address the full complexity of Magneto's psychology and history), Magneto remains one of the best adversaries in comic book history precisely because of his Holocaust and World War II backstory. This character was a good man who became a costumed "villain" to protect his mutant people. Magneto spent most of his life trying to play by the rules, trying to forget his past. He started out as a heroic and well-intentioned boy, growing up in a loving family -- but a family increasingly beset and attacked by Nazi-inspired hatred and violence. MAGNETO TESTAMENT depicts a part of this journey of the character, from the years 1935 to 1944, with a coda from 1948 at the end. I highly recommend this book, for fans of the comic book character, fans of the movie version of Magneto, and for anyone interested in a graphic novel about the Holocaust, for either reading or teaching others.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
well-done, November 23, 2009
This review is from: X-Men: Magneto Testament (Hardcover)
Magneto's Testament finally gives readers the background story of Magneto in one book. Certain things are different then what had been assumed in the past, and a few things are tweaked- for example the only time when magneto's powers come into play is when he is shot at and it is severely downplayed. It's not obvious that it was his powers and instead looks as if his father acted as a shield. This is different from the scene in the X-Men movie where his will to stay with his parents bends the metal gates at the labor camp. Also, there was no saved by wolverine or captain america which was shown as happening in the series X-Men Evolution. All in all this is a good read, and a great addition to anyones shelf.The artwork is both well done and respectable to those who actually survived the holocaust. It, however, is not filled with epic action sequences between mutants and Charles Xavier makes no appearance in it whatsoever. However, you do meet Magda, the gypsy who is destined to be the mother of Pietro and Wanda Maximoff. A definite necessity for an X-Men fan, and a good read even for those who aren't. :)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb read. Chilling and sad., April 29, 2010
This review is from: X-Men: Magneto Testament (Hardcover)
This is one of the best origins I have ever read for a comic book character. I have been collecting comics for over 20 years and always was fascinated about Magneto's origin. We all know Magneto was a Jewish kid growing up during WW2 but this book gives us more detail into his childhood life and his family. If you took off the X-men name on the cover, and you took off the Magneto in the title, this would still be a fantastic comic. Spoilers: There are no mutant abilities or any super powers happening in this book. It's a tale of Max Eisenhardt (Magneto's birth name) growing up during the Nazi rise to power and his struggles for survival. I was moved by the book simply because it is retelling real life. The stuff that happens in the comic happened in real life during those times and it is saddening to think people can treat others this way. The art while not the best, fit the book and the mood perfectly. The book moves at a fast pace and can be read in about 30 minutes. This is also a great book to us as supplemental material to teach young children about the Holocaust and why we can never sit back and ever let anything like this happen again. 5 stars! Get this hidden gem today.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|