Customer Reviews

X-Men, Vol. 1 (Marvel Masterworks)

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This book, like all the books in the Marvel Masterworks line, is an excellent addition to any comic fan's bookshelf. The softcover versions are affordable and contain full-color reprints of classic comics in chronological order. These books are a great resource for nostalgic baby boomers, comic book collectors/historians, or curious new readers. They provide a convenient way to follow the evolution of long-running comics franchises like the "X-Men", the "Fantastic Four", and "Spider-Man" from their humble beginnings.

With any story, it is helpful to go back to the very beginning, to see who everyone is and where they came from. That's what you get with X-Men, Vol. 1. This book collects the very first adventures of Stan Lee and Jack Kirby's superhero squad the X-Men. In these stories we meet the original X-Men lineup (Cyclops, Beast, Angel, Ice Man, Marvel Girl and, of course, Professor Xavier) as well as notable villains Magneto, the Blob, Toad, Quicksilver, and Scarlet Witch. Any fan of the X-Men from cartoon shows, movies, or newer comics will get a kick out of these early stories, where our favorite superheroes are still clean-cut teenagers. It's also neat to see co-creator Stan Lee start developing the characters into the personalities with which we are now familiar.

Marvel Masterworks volumes are excellent, and this stands as one of the most important ones. (The very start of the X-Men!)

However, I must warn new readers and younger X-fans that the stories collected in this volume are from 1963 and 1964, and the comic book style will seem very dated to modern readers. For such a graphic medium, these comic books are very "talky". Lots of speech bubbles crowding up the frames and explaining every move in almost unnecessary detail. And don't expect to see popular characters like Wolverine, Storm, Rogue, Colossus, Shadowcat, or Gambit. They wouldn't appear until the 1970s or 1980s. Heck, Beast isn't even blue in these early stories. (The adventures of the all-new X-Men, featuring Wolverine & Co., are being released as "Marvel Masterworks: The Uncanny X-Men", starting with Vol. 1.)

And while these early stories are interesting from an academic perspective, I wouldn't say they are all great entertainment. Particularly for readers more accustomed to modern comic storytelling. This is a chronological presentation of all of the old comics, not a "best of" collection or a "greatest hits" package. So keep that in mind. The creators were still testing the waters with their characters and storylines.

Still, this is a great place to start if you are interested in the history of one of America's top superhero teams. There's no place to start like the beginning. But know that the X-Men have a long history and that a purely chronological approach to "discovering" the comics might be tedious work. 1960s "X-Men" is definitely worth checking out, but 1970s and 1980s "X-Men" are essential, too, and might be more satisfying to some readers.

So, keeping in mind the age of these early "X-Men" tales, this is an excellent volume of vintage Marvel comics. One of the most essential Masterworks books out there. The birth of one of Marvel's major superhero franchises. This is a far cry from today's "X-Men". It's interesting to see how it all began and I encourage any curious reader out there to check this book out, if they are so inclined. If you think you might be interested in the early days of Professor X's team, pick this up. You've got nothing to lose.

I highly recommend this to anyone who's become a fan of the X-Men. Like much of the Marvel Masterworks books, this one takes the reader back to the early 1960s, when the original X-Men were a bunch of kids exploring their powers under the guidance of Mr. X. The artwork, styles and text all reflect the time in which the stories are told. In fact, as with Ironman Masterworks Vol. 1, reference is made to the "upcoming" World's Fair in Flushing, Queens. It's not nearly as complex and edgy as the X-Men comics would become, but it's worthwhile as an artifact of the characters, the time in which they lived and American culture as a whole during that time period.

If you're a fan of the new X-Men (1975 to the present), you might not like this at all. If you are a fan of early Marvel comics, & especially the Jack Kirby/Stan Lee creative magic, then this is the cheap way to read how it all began. The early X-Men are not very powerful (besides Cyclops) & like Spider-Man & Daredevil, they fight common thugs in a few issues. There is also a lot of soap-opera involving Scott's feelings for Jean, (and even Professor X's feelings for Jean!!!!). Like the first few Avengers issues, the art starts out crude, brutally inked by Paul Reinman. (If only the issues of FF, Avengers & X-Men he worked on could be re-inked!) By issue #4 & 5, even Reinman can't ruin Kirby, who is developing at the speed-of-light. Then, the best Marvel inker of 1964, Chic Stone shows up, and you get 5 glorious issues of great art & story, where the X-Men take on Unus, Sub-Mariner, The Avengers, Ka-Zar, & of course--Magneto! I bought my collection used for $5, so I have no complaints!! Long live Jack Kirby!

Well if you're looking at this you must know that this is where it all begins. There isn't much to say about it but it's great to see it from the start. To see how much things have changed over the years. I wouldn't recommend this for the younger generation unless they have a great interest into the specific x-men team.

Don't get me wrong, The X-Men are a classic must-have in the Marvel Masterworks industry, but it doesn't mean that it is an excellent comic. For those of you who think that, then you need to read all of these issues thoroughly before making up you mind. X-Men were enjoyable at parts, but most of the time I was kind of dragging myself through the pages. Sure, they're interesting and they try to propel you forward but sometimes it fails. Nevertheless, I rated it a 4-Star because of a few things.

The artwork for one (and in every single Marvel comic) is fantastic. I can't stress it enough over the dazzling panels drawn by Jack Kirby. The stories were not-bad also, and that kept me reading. I sugges reading these all in order, by the way, or else you'll definitley be confused. The Beast, Angel, Cyclops, Marvel Girl, Ice Man, and Professor X are all formed into a team of "mutants" who live to protect humanity against other mutants who feel that we should be destroyed. Good setup. Personally, my favorite issues in this one are the very first one which features the infamous Magento for the first time. Then I really like the one which guest stars the Avengers in issue #9. An epic battle goes down between the X-Men and the Avengers (my favorite team of heros besides F.F.) and it was really intruiging. Also, the last issue in this volume will blow you away. This one was different because it's set in a different time and place and future with different characters that you'll only meet once. For instance Kazar and his Sabertooth Zabu.

This Marvel Masterwork was not a mistake to buy, but it wasn't the best I read. I suggest looking at Fantastic Four, Spider-Man, Hulk, or the Avengers before looking at this.

This was a good purchase, but if you are going to buy these I recommend buying the x-men omnibus.