10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Evocative and moving, but a bit slight compared to Berger's earlier work, August 28, 2008
This review is from: From A to X: A Story in Letters (Hardcover)
This is a "novel" in the form of a discontinuous, out-of-order series of letters from A'ida, an activist, to her imprisoned lover Xavier. The letters are arranged, as the book's conceit is explained in a brief introduction by Berger (who has "found" or "been given" them), as they have been found in Xavier's cell after he departed, in a few bundles. They are interspersed with little fragments of writing by Xavier -- the only words of his we read, as his replies to A'ida are not printed -- which are mostly political reflections, sometimes quoted from figures like Eduardo Galeano and Subcomandante Marcos, and which in the main sound suspiciously like interjections from Berger himself, though this is not at all obtrusive or disruptive to the reader's experience. The letters from A'ida retell little incidents of life and political resistance, from a neighbor's jelly-making to her work at a pharmacy to a night of protest, ringed by occupiers' tanks. While the setting is deliberately fictionalized and the place names are drawn from ancient Assyria, there are still some details that make it seem likely the characters are Palestinians; but their experience is meant to be an allegory of activist life anywhere rather than a depiction of a specific place or a single historical moment. (Xavier's situation clearly evokes that of Nazim Hikmet or Antonio Gramsci, for instance.)
Though there are a few incidents, for the most part there is little plot, little development in the situation of either character over the course of the book, and the letters are out of chronological order in any case; what is important is the tone created in A'ida's lamenting her lover's absence and summoning his memory, the particular, carefully structured feeling of long but hopefully not interminable absence evoked by the book. As a result of this, the book can feel a bit monotonous -- literally, in that it has only one tone and little variation (we might wish for a joke to break the pathos, or a real narrative line); but this is not a fault so much as a choice, and the choice to stay in one emotional register undeniably has a great cumulative power over the course of this relatively short book, written in common language and about common experience.
"To tell the truth? Words tortured until they give themselves up to their polar opposites [...] Solution: the evening language of the poor. With this some truths can be told and held."
This is one of Xavier's interjections, but it is also an apt statement of the goal of Berger's writing. His late fiction has often been concerned with recuperating the love stories of common people, poor people, and gently transposing these love stories into a political register;
To the Wedding was a particular and concrete version of this, Lilac and Flag (the last volume of his great trilogy Into Their Labours) was a more general and allegorized one. This book seems a sequel of sorts to
Lilac and Flag, an attempt to build something more hopeful on those characters' desperation and to help build a mood which is not tragic out of their sad existence. Though this is not Berger's greatest work, in this regard it is a great and worthy success.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
As always..., October 24, 2008
This review is from: From A to X: A Story in Letters (Hardcover)
Berger is a marvel. He is a fearless artist armed with penetrating vision and magificent command of his craft. I have been reading his work since the mid-sixties and wonder always how it is that he never, ever gets stale.
There are many things to love about From A to X, such as its economy. Telling the story through letters and notes delivered a feel of intimacy I found quite gripping, especially so because it was delivered in the voice of the woman. It is a novel of political passion delivered in a quiet voice. I hope you read it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Arts and letters, October 3, 2009
John Berger's epistolary novel (one of his most celebrated in years, and longlisted for the Man-Booker Prize) shows us the letters of a pharmacist, A'ida, to her lover Xavier imprisoned in a nameless country for alleged terrorism. Berger's leftist politics are fully on display here--A'ida and Xavier are romantic lovers of freedom in the old Marxist sense, and the stack of letters we are given from A'ida to her love have notes scribbled on them by Xavier often quoting from or mentioning nostalgically great historical figures from the Left and attacking corporate multinationals for oppressing the masses and raping the planet. A'ida's work is to present to Xavier the quotidian life he is missing penned up in his prison, although the novel also seems to partake of a possible code language (often suggested by the gesturing hands A'ida draws for him in her letters) that may explain the novel's hopeful final image.
Berger's work is undeniably innovative and clever, and his playing with letters (both of the postal system and of the alphabet) is genuinely imaginative. The novel largely eschews much of a plot which lends it a kind of lyric immediacy but also makes it seem a bit of a chore to get through; things are not helped by his tendency to sentimentalize A'ida's and Xavier's relationship or their politics. (We are led to believe they are wholly and unproblematically on the side of the angels.) It's difficult even to have a political novel divorced from any kind of context whatsoever. Since we don't know where A'ida's town is, we can't know what government she and Xavier are really protesting, or what they realistically propose in its stead. This seems more like a noble failed novelistic experiment than anything else.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
