Customer Reviews

Xbox Cordless Precision Controller

5 star:		(11)
4 star:		(10)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(5)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

I owned the first Logitech Cordless Controller for the Xbox and thought I would never replace it, but think again. This controller is amazing. Not only can you walk to the other side of the room or relax while playing without cords it never misses a beat. The size is significantly smaller than the first controller making it easier to hold. Anyone who owns an Xbox must purchase this amazing product.

My experience with this controller has been nearly flawless. Wireless beats wired up and down the field, and there is simply ZERO lag with this controller. None. No complaints at all with button or d-pad sensitivity, but perhaps I am not the connessieur that other reviewers are. The smaller controller makes for a different, but qualitatively equal, experience than the standard XBox controller.

HOWEVER I have this against you, Logitech: You conveniently neglected to include a headset slot on the controller. Since my constant play of Ghost Recon 2 on XBox Live is threatening to cause my early exit from graduate school, this brother NEEDS a headset. But this leaves me with only two options:

1) Get really, really close to the tv screen, which my momma told me never to do.

OR

2) Buy a wireless headset from--wait a minute!--from LOGITECH! Funny how that works out. I wonder if that crossed the minds of any of the execs at Logitech when they were designing this little beauty? Nah, probably not. I'm sure this is an oversight that will be corrected with their next-gen wireless controller.

So now I have to decide whether to buy 2 or 3 used games OR a wireless headset. I think I'll risk the vision impairment and sit close to the screen . . .

Bottom Line: PERFECT wireless controller. SNEAKY design by Logitech.

(I really, really apologize for using the words 'connessieur' and 'qualitatively' in a review of a video game controller. It won't happen again, I promise.)

I bought two of these controllers, and I have been using them heavily, mostly playing Burnout 3. I thought the previous version, the bigger one that took 4 batteries, was a good product, but this new model is definitely an improvement, fitting the hand a bit better. Most importantly I have never experienced any problems with the response or wireless signal. This really is as good as a corded controller!

The batteries seem to last quite a while too. I didn't get the 50 hours listed in the product specs, but I did get almost 40, which is still really good in my book. (I was using alkalines. I don't know if it will work with rechargeables, which typically have a slightly lower voltage even when fully charged.)

The only downside that I can see is the difficulty of using the Xbox Live headset. The memory card slot is on the base unit, not the controller itself, so you have to sit near the Xbox to use the headset. If there was better XBL support (a communicator jack on the controller, as another reviewer suggested) I'd give this 5 stars.

Some other reviewers have disliked the button response and the feel of the analog sticks. All I can say is I didn't feel that way. I did notice that the face buttons weren't as sensitive as my stock Xbox controller; by that I mean I had to tap a little harder to get any response at all. But that was easy to get used to and now I don't even think about it. Every brand of controller is a little different, so you'll always notice something like that when you switch.

Unfortunately, I did get to experience Logitech tech support. One of the controllers I bought was dead on arrival. It was clear to me that the controller itself just wasn't working, but I had to explain everything to Logitech tech support and try their fixes. Once those didn't work, they did immediately send me a replacement unit. Getting a dud once in a while is inevitable... what matters is how the company handles it, and I have to admit that Logitech did a great job.

Based on this experience, I am looking forward to getting the Logitech cordless PS2 controllers too.

This controller was fantastic. It worked great for Halo and all of the Ghost Recon's. Very sensitive and quick response. I absolutely loved it.

Then one day, it decided to start acting on its own. My characters started moving by themselves...planes started flying themselves. Very odd.

Slowly at first, I was able to correct the controller. A quick movement on the thumb stick or D-pad stopped the controller from acting on its own.

Now however, it's too far gone to bring back. For some reason the controller is stuck on the down movement. Nothing I do can fix it.

So now I have a cool looking paper weight. Do not buy this as it will fail. It is only a matter of time. If you don't believe me, look on eBay and see all of them for sale. Oh yeah, look closer. they are all refurbished! What does that tell you?

EDIT:
As an update to my original post, I've FIXED my controller. If you are having problems, try this. It is straight from the Logitech website (allbeit, buried in their knowledgebase)

Question
How do I calibrate the Logitech Cordless Precision Controller for Xbox®?
Answer


Normally there is no reason to re-calibrate the Cordless Precision for Xbox®. In rare cases where the mini-joysticks may need to be re-calibrated, you can use the process below. Please note that this process only works for the Cordless Precision Controller for Xbox®.

1. Remove one battery.
2. Hold the Left Trigger and Start buttons while re-inserting the battery. (NOTE: Do not touch or move the mini-joysticks at all during this time. It is very important that the mini joysticks are allowed to center themselves during this step or the calibration procedure will not be successful.)

The mini-joysticks should now be re-calibrated. Please note that in some cases you may need to resynchronize the gamepad and receiver after this procedure. For more information on resynchronizing this device please see Knowledge Base Article 457.

I've had this controller for over a month now and generally I have to admit this is a very well made controller. I am a big fan of the Microsoft S Controller so that is what I will compare this product with. The games that I tested this controller with are: Halo, Ninja Gaiden, Marvel v. Capcom 2, Dead or Alive 3, and Guilty Gear X2 #Reloaded

FPS: (Halo)
Everything played generally well. The face buttons were more comfortable (flatter) than the S controller (which hurt your thumb if you press too hard b/c of rounded tops) and the shallower triggers did not affect my gameplay at all. However, although my hands are not that small, I had trouble using the left analog stick. The stick was placed a little too high for my liking and my hands cramped after a bit of playing.

Action: (Ninja Gaiden)
Everything responded beautifully and I could land my intercept moves (Hurricane Pack) perfectly. I had no problems performing combos. Again, the left analog stick still bugged me because of its placement.

Fighting: (DOA3, MvC2, GGX2 #Reloaded)
This controller is amazing for fighting games. I'm not really a fan of using joysticks and prefer d-pads. The d-pad on this controller is not only very comfortable, but also is very precise. I replayed all the fighting games that I owned and I could pull off moves that I never could on the Microsoft S-controller. Also, the white and black buttons are much easier to press.
I do have two issues with the controller though. Due to the pad's unusual groove in the middle, you have to press the x (blue) button a little more than you would think. Took some getting used to, but eventually I didn't have any more problems. Also, if you play Xbox Live you cannot attach a communicator to the actual controller. Luckily I play close to my Xbox so that wasn't too much of an issue, but if you usually play 10-15 ft away from your TV this could be a problem.

Pros:
- Wireless
- Good battery life
- Great d-pad
- Comfortable face buttons
- Accessible white and black buttons

Cons:
- Can't attach headset to controller
- x (blue) button takes getting used to
- left analog stick a little uncomfortable

Wireless is the way to go!
When I put any of my wireless controllers down on the table they look like they belong there and not out of place...

Singular and clean looking this Sweet little controller is, IMO, another triumph by Logitech!

Though a little smaller than the S-type, it feels good in the hand and it does not slack at all in performance. I got mine used and, once again, put old batteries in it(takes 2)...even four months later, I am just now getting the low battery light flashing...

Still Vibrates
Still Responds Acurately
And the analog sensitivity is better than the wired.

Get it, get it... GET IT!!!

Logitech's Xbox Cordless Precision Controller is a must get for anyone tired of all the cords. I have all three consoles and after a while I got tired of having to wrap all the cords up, tripping on them, etc. I also eventually picked up the Logitech Controller for the PS2 and the WaveBird for the GameCube, fully getting rid of all the cords. In my opinion, the Logitech Xbox Precision Cordless is not as good as either the Logitech PS2 or the WaveBird, but it is also not bad by any means.

To begin with, the controllers design is nice and fits well and is comfortable in both hands. The feel is a mix between a PS2 controller and an Xbox controller. All the buttons work properly and are pretty much in the same vicinity as the other Xbox controllers, but it does take a short time to adapt to. As for the batteries, I have yet to have any problems with them. In fact, I am impressed by how long the batteries have last. I have played through Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic II twice and my brother has also played through it twice (Approximately. 100 hours of game play between us both). I have also played Madden and Halo 2 for quite sometime on it and I have yet to change the batteries once and I have had the controller since December! I was suspect at first with how long the batteries were going to last, but their longevity surpassed my expectations.

Even with great battery life and a good feel it does have a few flaws, minor, but flaws. The first thing I don't like about the controller is the little box that comes with it. The PS2 and GameCube equivalents have nice little boxes; the Xbox one is a bit bigger. I mean it is not a major concern, but it just takes up some space in an area where I don't have much to give. Secondly, I have noticed that it has a few problems in several games. They are not major problems and it only seems to be in the menus of a game. For example, I have to hit buttons twice or push the axis twice when I am cycling through the menus in Madden. I also had the same problem in ESPN College Hoops 2k5. But I didn't have any problems with the controller in KOTOR II, which has more menus and choices then any game ever. So perhaps it is just those games. Finally, my last thing is not really a flaw. The price of this controller is roughly $10 dollars more then both the WaveBird and Logitech PS2 Controller.

Overall, this is a great product by a company that I personally have never had a bad product from. This is my third wireless Logitech controller (Xbox, PS2 & PC) and I have had no major problems with any of them. If you are looking to go wireless with your Xbox, I really wouldn't hesitate. And if you are like me and have destroyed controllers in the past, do not fear too much. It can take a decent beating, but it does lose its signal if you shake it enough, so do play with caution and remember to throw a pillow rather than your $50 dollar wireless controller. Without the wires it can go rather far, so play safe.

The controller worked great during gameplay, but the construction of it leaves a little to be desired. First off, Im not sure why they call it a 'precision' controller since the L and R trigger throws are actually shorter than those of the Xbox Controller S, in fact making it less precise. Theyre higher up on the backside of the controller, making the grip on the controller a little awkward but tolerable. Secondly, the directional pad (the old-school left, right, up, down pad) is very loose and not very solid at all. I think I've been spoiled a little bit by the Nintendo Gamecube Wavebird controllers after having those for about 2 years though, fyi. It might sound like Im bashing the controller a bit, but Id much rather have it than the corded controller. Plus, it includes a rumble feature which the Wavebird does not.

I love this controller. I have small hands for an adult, and the pad fits me well. I like the shape better than even the now-standard Controller S shape. I have no problems with delay or drift. I haven't used the D-pad, but the thumbsticks and buttons work great, though I'm not a terribly heavy user. This pad works better than either the Pelican Eclipse or Soul that I own. My Madcatz Lynx is better, but way too big for my hands. I like the feel of the plastic. The only thing I would change would be making the thumbsticks a bit shorter and concave on top, though I've never had a problem with grip.

I have two of these and found they stop responding sometimes in the middle of a game (usually makes you stay in one place and twirl like a ballerina until you unplug the controllers, wait 10 seconds, plug them in, then hit the sync button).

I love the feel of the contoller and the responsiveness. As a 30+ rank in Halo, I depend upon the controller. I hate that you can't plug a headset into the controller since it is necessary for team play. Logitech sells a wireless controller, which doesn't work well, so use this controller if you don't need to communicate with others (don't use XBOX Live). Also don't get fooled by Logitech's advertising that you can plug your headset into it since it has a port...since the port is at the game console so you would have to be less than 3 feet from the TV unless you buy their $50 wireless headset.

Logitech, you need to enhance the product by putting the headset port in the controller and stop the ploy to make more money. Besides, the wireless headset uses the same frequency as the controller and telephones which just addes more things to interfere with each other. Provide a means for us to set the frequency (channel) to improve the reliability.