18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very Historical yet interesting all the same..., July 7, 2001
This review is from: A Year and a Day (Mass Market Paperback)
This book is my "FIRST BOOK" in three ways... One, it's my first book of Virginia Henley (and certainly not the last). Two, it's my first book that the heroine is a very typical commoner who doesn't even know how to read. I actually thought I'd be turn off by this but as I read through, I learn to understand her situation and sigh for her. Then eventually, I wanted much, much more for Jane. Three, this is my first book that is perhaps about 70% filled with historical facts and events reigned during England's King Edward Plantagenet, The Longshanks, with Scotland's Robert Bruce and William Wallace, the famous BRAVEHEART epic. If you are the type of person who prefers more romance/love story and less historical facts on your books then this one is probably not for you. Because I saw and love the movie BRAVEHEART, I was and still AM particularly interested in Robert the Bruce & William Wallace's historical (con)quest for rights and freedom, that is why I wasn't bothered with the factual events that seems to overflowed more than the romance of the hero/heroine. I guess u can say that IF I was NOT already 'drawned' to such topic, I'd probably find this book very tedious.
Since the Editorial Reviews pretty much sum up the book synopsis, I'd just give my opinion without summarizing the content any longer...
Jane and Lynx love story was a bit ordinary for me. Aside for Lynx obsession to have an heir and Jane's adjustments to her new life, their love story didn't have any impact on me, however, it wasn't boring at all either. There are funny times and heart warming occurances as well but I find Jory's and Robert's love story much more heart wretching. Mind you, theirs wasn't even detailed bec. they are only the secondary characters yet for some reason, their relationship and Jory's love for Robert seems more fetching. I wanted to read more of them... I also enjoyed Jory's character more than Janes. Jory is uppity, manipulative and a big flirt yet she is also unselfish, charming and full of heart. I guess you can say that in my opinion, Jory's character overshadowed Jane's. I did have an admiration for Jane though but she should have been more develop. Jane was timid and too naive. Except for her herbal/healing talents, she was a bit ignorant which is fitting for her role and station in life of that time, i guess. She did improve a bit towards the end but I was left unconvinced, perhaps I just wanted more... What i specially like about Jane is her willingness to try and her willingness to learn. She doesn't pretend and she wasn't ashamed to accept her flaws... then ask for help to improve. "I will and I shall", she always said.... That is what I admire most about her.
I want to clarify a comment given by a reviewer about beastiality... For me, there was NO beastiality in this book at all. I'd say read this book for yourself and decide if it is indeed beastiality in your opinion. However,In my own comprehension, it wasn't. That part with the lynx in the forrest pool was simply a METAMORPHICAL description. A metaphormic vision. There is also another occurance where readers might find disgusting or wierd... I won't mentioned it here for those who have not read the book yet but i know readers will know what i mean once they have read the book. This is where i admire Virginia Henley most. She has the guts to create new ideas and implemented it. I do believe that when people read, see or even feel new things or ideas, we tend to shun upon it. I am always open minded for new things, new ideas and however strange it might be at first, I often times accept it and move on... Afterall, If it was thought of, it most certainly can happend.
I have to agree with few reviewers here that some of the dialogue doesn't sound right. The expressions Virginia Henley used such as "Dream on", "Hellavu Woman" and few more didn't fit in to the time period. Those inconsistencies wasn't a lot to get me annoyed however, so I manage to overlook that matter, especially because I did enjoy most part of this book. I do prefer consistencies in all the books I read but sometimes, it doesn't hurt to let small matters go and simply enjoy the story as it is. I will pick up more of Ms. Henley's work and that is for sure.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great book with a very originalstory line!, August 13, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: A Year and a Day (Mass Market Paperback)
When I bought "A Year and A Day" I thought that it would be a mindless distraction for a few hours, but I really didn't want to stop reading for anything.After I finished reading this book I went out and bought all the others by Virgina Henley that I could find. Lynx de Warenne is a prized warrior to the English. The one thing he wants more than anything is an heir. Jane Leslie is half celtic, half morman, who lives in a Scottish castle of Dumfries that was invaded by Lynx. When Lynx finds out that his steward Jock Leslie has ten children he thinks that the chance of having children with one of Jocks daughters would be a good chance. He proposes to Jane a handfasting for a year and a day. Jane never wants to marry or be handfasted to anyone but he is her lord so she must surrender... I have read this book more than five times i just the year I've had it. I highly recomend this book!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantasy Land, November 27, 1999
This review is from: A Year and a Day (Mass Market Paperback)
I thought this book was very charming. It is the tale of a young girl who unwillingly falls in love with a Fabio type warrior. The part that made me teary-eyed was when he was fatally injured, but this maiden suckled him back to life with her own breast milk. Come on folks that is love. This book is a good read for all us innocent and devoted to love.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No