Most Helpful Customer Reviews
37 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Good application of the lexical method., November 19, 2006
This review is from: A Year In the Life of an ESL (English Second Language) Student: Idioms and Vocabulary You Can't Live Without (Paperback)
Michael Lewis caused quite a stir in the world of ESL when he published his "The Lexical Approach" in 1993. Lewis's point was basically thus: ESL students are force feed too much English grammar. The idea that grammar can be mastered and then students fill in the blanks with vocabulary is naïve, according to Lewis, and makes it difficult for students to understand natural English phrases such as "Let's have a coffee," because students have only studied "Shall we drink coffee?" Having taught English to Japanese students, who are taught grammar and only grammar in high school, I found this to be a huge obstacle. Lewis's book caused a huge sensation on the ESL teaching community, and many teachers thought they didn't have to teach grammar anymore, it was fine just to teach idiom after idiom. Lewis followed up a few years later with a book on how to apply the lexical approach, saying that it is idioms, expressions and grammar are not so far removed from grammar. In other words, idioms and expressions should be taught as a part of grammar.
Since Lewis shook up the ESL world, there have been attempts to bring out commercial textbooks that implement the Lexical Approach. However, most of them are not so different than previous textbooks, with traditional grammar the focus of the lesson, and idioms kind of tacked on as an afterthought. "A Year in the Life of an ESL Student" does a good job of introducing idioms as an integral part of communication, not just as an added bonus. Colorful idioms such as "Drink like a fish" or "toss one's cookies", as well as expressions that are not idioms, but present difficulties to ESL students, such as "mope around" are presented in natural conversations, and than reinforced through various exercises, such as crossword puzzles, word find exercises, and so on. Many ESL students have the goal of being able to watch Hollywood movies with no subtitles. Just studying grammar and straight vocabulary will never allow this to happen. However, this book will equip students with hundreds of natural and useful expressions that will help them understand and by able to speak more natural English.
The book focuses on a Swiss student, Andre, as he studies for a year at a private language school in North America. All of the conversations in the book involve Andre and his friends at the language school. Students will like this because it makes the stories easy to follow and understand. Teachers will like this book because there are lots of good exercises in each of the 16 chapters, making it easy to teach good lessons with no or very little preparation. Then there is the theme of this book, studying language abroad for a year. This should be the goal of many of your students, and if it is not, studying with this text will hopefully get them interested in the possibility. For classes with more advanced students, this can be a good springboard for a discussion on the topic.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
57 of 60 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A little disappointed, May 28, 2009
This review is from: A Year In the Life of an ESL (English Second Language) Student: Idioms and Vocabulary You Can't Live Without (Paperback)
I purchased this book based on the product information and all the good reviews, so I was surprised to find it disappointing in a couple ways. But first the positive.
The author chose some excellent real-life situations for framing the idioms and language. He also includes plenty of repetition and reinforcement through follow up worksheets based on the introductory dialogue for each unit. This is sometimes a weakness in other idiom presentations.
The disappointment lies in the over abundance of idioms in each dialogue and the sense that too many of them are consequently forced into non-natural usages. Those of us who teach English have all experienced the over zealous language learner who wants to sound natural and tries to do so by throwing idioms into every other sentence. That is how some dialogues in this book sound. By doing so, it feeds the non-native speaker's belief that idioms are used constantly in speech rather than aiding them in sounding more like a native speaker by using them only in true context and sparingly. Take the first dialogue for example; there are 25 idioms / slang words used in a 2-minute dialogue. Unless I'm just a really boring person or I've been working too long with low level speakers, my natural conversations are not filled with half that many unusual expressions. And a couple examples of 'forced usage'. Chapter 3 in a student to student discussion about a teacher: "Actually, the course materials are pretty good, but the teacher certainly isn't the cream of the crop. I'm sure his days are numbered." Chaper 6 in a conversation at a shopping mall: "What about this pair of pants? They're right up your alley, don't you think?" (I don't remember ever talking about clothing with this idiom??)
All in all, there's some great language in the book for the basis of creating a lesson, and I would still recommend buying it. But I will be taking the dialogues and re-writing each one to eliminate at least half the idioms / slang words. Not only is the over usage a little annoying, it's also poor pedagogy to introduce so many pieces of social language that are so context-dependent.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
29 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An ESL text you really "can't live without", December 1, 2006
This review is from: A Year In the Life of an ESL (English Second Language) Student: Idioms and Vocabulary You Can't Live Without (Paperback)
Research in second language vocabulary acquisition demonstrates that learning idioms is one of the most important aspects of acquiring a second language. ESL students who do not understand idioms will not be able to understand a large portion of the English language. Consider that an ESL student can understand the grammar of the phrase "kick the bucket" without having any clue as to its actual meaning. Furthermore, ESL students who do not understand idioms will have a much harder time fitting into the culture of native English speakers. This struggle can be severely detrimental to a learner's intrinsic motivation, which is one of the most important factors influencing language learning success. A Year in the Life of an ESL Student: Idioms and Vocabulary You Can't Live Without is an outstanding resource that addresses this important issue of idioms by teaching ESL students an expansive number of them in an engaging and enjoyable manner.
As to the expansiveness of the text, it provides idioms that address a wide variety of situations from attending a TOEFL class to suntanning on the beach. The following examples give a glimpse of the range of idiomatic expressions that students will learn: "better late than never," "cover for someone (to)," "hangover," and "work one's butt off (to)." The presentation of each idiom is clear with each of them first appearing in bold letters in a stimulating dialogue. This feature of the book is beneficial since research has shown that lexical items are much better remembered when learned in authentic contexts. As the author states, "Context is the key to making the daunting task of understanding and using idiomatic English not only possible, but enjoyable too." The dialogues are followed by pages where each idiom is placed in glossary format. After that, there are a significant number of exercises for students to learn the idioms interactively.
Beyond meeting a need in the ESL community, the other aspect of this text that makes it so successful is its engaging style. Many language learning materials present grammatical and cultural information with pictures and other helpful graphics; however, when it comes to vocabulary and idioms these items are often still presented in lists. On the other hand, A Year in the Life places idioms in interesting dialogues that often contain humor and are related to the actual experiences that an ESL student may have. In addition to the dialogues, learners also have the opportunity to learn idioms by playing games. Two common exercises found throughout the book are crosswords and word searches. The realistic dialogues and the exercises make learning the idioms interesting and fun.
Considering the need for a text of this kind in the ESL community and its engaging style, I would recommend it without reservation to both ESL teachers and students. A Year in the Life will lead learners into a much more native-like competence.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
