Customer Reviews

The Year of the Rat

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Think of the great themes found in children's literature. The new kid in class/on the block/in the family. One's relationship with one's parents. And, of course, friendship. Friendship binds children's literature together. Series books thrive on it. Think of The Baby-Sitters Club, Sweet Valley High, or any of their modern incarnations. Classic children's literature used friendship as a focus as well. The Betsy-Tacy books by Maud Hart Lovelace are one of the finest examples of this, and it's hard to find a modern day equivalent to Lovelace's throne. Think hard now... how many chapter books can you think of that have that same balance of sweetness, family, love, and friends in a perfect little package with a classic kind of feel? "Classic", in the sense that it's a book that will age well and be beloved for generations. Few books or series fit the bill, but one definitely sticks out in my mind. Grace Lin's semi-autobiographical stories of Pacy and her life in New Hartford contain just the right balance of sweetness and story. Without ever becoming trite or saccharine, Lin hits gold yet again with "The Year of the Rat", the sequel to her justly applauded (and popular) The Year of the Dog.

The start of the New Year is supposed to be a time of happiness and anticipation. But the fact that this Chinese New Year is The Year of the Rat means that there are also changes afoot. For Pacy, that means learning that her best friend Melody is going to be moving away soon. Unhappy but unable to do anything about it, Pacy and Melody vow to keep in touch. Still, it's hard knowing that Melody will never finish her square on the class quilt. It's even harder to see a new Chinese family move into her best friend's old home, particularly when their boy (her age) doesn't understand English. Still, there's nothing to say that change is all bad. This is the year that Pacy gets to participate in a wedding and show off her artistic talents. It's also a time when she learns to confront her friends about their prejudices and strengthen her own determination to become a writer. Not every good year is an easy one.

The test of any sequel is in its necessity. Did the previous book really need more stories? In her Author's Note at the end, Lin explains her reasoning for continuing Pacy's story. "Would I have loved Anne of Anne of Green Gables as much if I had only gotten to know her through only one book?" Some stories are meant to continue and some characters have to given the chance to grow. Pacy is not the same girl in this book as she was in "The Year of the Dog". She has had to grow up a little. This book isn't a recap of her old dreams and plans, but is instead a slightly older tale of dealing with change, both pleasant and unpleasant. If she continues at this rate, readers may be lucky enough to watch Pacy as she grows up through the years. It might take some doing, but I have confidence that Grace Lin is up to the job.

Lots of little details ring true throughout this tale too. When Pacy first sees the new boy Dun-Wei she decides that there's something a little off about him. "His pants were a little too short and his socks just seemed too white. His jacket matched brand-new sneakers and he carried a lunch box instead of a brown paper bag like everyone else did. These were just little things, but somehow, all these little wrong things made him stick out like a big mistake." No kid can read this without understanding what the author means. At the same time, she's clever enough to make you sympathize with Dun-Wei even while her heroine attempts to treat him like everyone else does.

Now when I read the first Pacy story "The Year of the Dog" I was sitting on an airplane tarmac for about five hours, waiting to get off the ground. I was desperately hungry, reading children's books to get my mind off of my growling stomach. Unfortunately, "The Year of the Dog" was precisely the wrong book to read for this purpose due to the fact that Grace Lin has the ability to conjure up tastes and odors out of thin air. If I was hungry when I picked up the book I was ravenous when I finished it. The real test with "The Year of the Rat" then was to see whether or not the food in this book seemed quite as yummy on a full stomach. I am happy to report then that "Dog" was no fluke. Right from the start Lin opens up with a full table of delicious delicacies ranging from delicate silver fish and "platters of pork stained the color of red wine" to noodles, duck, steamed buns, and dumplings. You could finish a ten course meal and still find yourself drooling when Lin brings her talents to the table.

I was also happy to see that the author decided to keep breaking up her book with lots of Pacy's family's stories. These are always interesting and some of them stayed with me long after I read the book. Her mother tells a tale of accidentally buying a can of cat food in the store thinking it was for people. Her cousin tells one of rescuing Pacy from her sister when she was just a baby. They're little things, but they really make the rest of the narrative pop, highlighting moments and lessons without ever sounding intentional or preachy.

Lin's books fall into the vanishing early chapter book category. With lots of small spot illustrations (created by Lin) and short chapters with relatively easy words, it's the perfect gateway book into older reading. Kids reading them will get a kick out of Lin's stories with "The Year of the Rat" a worthy follow-up to a great book. A must read for anyone inclined to discover the next great classic children's book author.

Pacy and Melody are best friends. The year of the rat means changes. Some of these changes Pacy isn't ready for. Her friend might move clear across the country to California and Pacy struggles to find the courage to keep the dream of being an artist and author even when others in her family tell her it's a 'closed door'. Later a new boy from China arrives. Others make fun of him. They call him Dumb Wit and say he's weird. Pacy knows this is wrong but doesn't want to be associated with him. What should she do? Pacy encounters prejudice and struggles to find the courage to make her own change.

This is a great tale about being proud of your heritage and who you are. I'm a big fan of multicultural tales. Tales that makes children proud of who they are. Pacy's tale is one I know other children face. I loved the stories within that tell of what her own Taiwanese parents went through when first coming to our country. Also Pacy's story reminds me of similar tales of Central American students I had and how others made fun of their differences.

The story also goes over Chinese holidays, a wedding, and a few folk tales. This story would be a great addition to a classroom library.

The Year of the Rat is as wonderful as its predecessor, The Year of the Dog. My eleven-year-old and I loved reading this aloud together, learning more about Pacy and her challenges during a year of changes as she loses her best friend, struggles with school friendships, and faces conflicting feelings towards a new classmate from China. As in the first book, we especially loved the stories of Pacy's mom as she uses her eye-opening experiences of life in Taiwan and immigration to America to gently teach her daughter some life lessons. Again we enjoyed the weaving in of Taiwanese food and culture. The adorable black&white line drawings top off this highly-recommended book.

I read the book that preceded "Year of the Rat", "Year of the Dog", toward the end of Aught 7 and was nothing but pleased. The book was not so much a story as a collection of events in the life of a grade school kid. At that age, school, family, and friends is about all there is. The characters were undeniably real. The semi-autobiographical protagonist made for some great examinations of Asian/American cultural differences that youngsters could understand. Well, Grace Lin continues the theme in "Year of the Rat" with similarly successful results. A book that doesn't wow as much as it satisfies. Or maybe I should put it this way: "Year of the Rat" just walks the walk, no talk necessary.

Pacy is a couple years older than last time and the Year of the Rat is about to begin. This particular year is destined to bring change, and it certainly comes through. Pacy's best friend Melody is moving, and our heroine is crushed. Her life plan, to be an author and illustrator, is also brought into question when Pacy learns that it is considered a "cold door" profession (see: bound to leave you broke as a joke). She begins to second guess herself. Pshhhhhhhheeeeeewwwwwww - Crash! That's the sound of change, my friends. These worries make for an unexpectedly stressful year. But there are some other changes in store for Pacy. The internal kind that allow her to see her year in a new light.

I've got to say, the book is a pleasure to read. Simple black and white illustrations scattered about to shed light on the text. Girls from a variety of cultural backgrounds will identify with the struggles of making friends and fitting in. An easy one to recommend.

My 8 year old daughter and I read this book aloud. We enjoyed every minute of it. There is much to learn about the Taiwanese American cultural that is revealed in this book. We just started reading Year of the Rat and can't wait to see what happens this year!!!

I read this book and simply fell in love with the story as well as each of the characters. I'm not a parent but I am an Aunt. Since I try to encourage children to read, I'm highly selective about the things children read but this is excellent.

In The Year of the Rat, one of the changes that Pacy faces is saying good-bye to Melody, whose family moves from New York to California. Yes, I know this can be a cliché. By removing a friend from the picture, an author is left with the ability to introduce new friends and hence new adventures. Remember, though, Grace Lin's books are semi-autobiographical; Melody's family is based on a real situation, which Lin weaves into her sweet and charming tale of family and friendship. In drawing upon her Asian heritage, she also ensures that her tales are unique. For example, one day the family heads off to Albany to visit Pacy's cousin Max who is turning one. Presents are opened, platters of food are served, and then Uncle Clifford brings out the destiny plate. Each item placed on the plate symbolizes a different job. Whichever one Max picks is thought represent the job he will one day hold. True to what you might expect from a toddler, Max just wants to eat his cake. Maybe he'll be a baker? One of my favorite and bittersweet moments in the book occurs when Pacy helps Melody pack. Melody is told she can't take all her books with her and so must give half to Pacy. The girls struggle to pick who will get which books, until they hit upon a compromise. After Pacy is done with with a book, she'll mail it back to Melody. In the aftermath of this plan, a funny incident happens that I'll leave to you to find. As with The Year of the Dog, not everything is perky and light. Pacy continues to struggle to find balance in her mixed identity as American and Chinese, especially when her peers try to match her with a new Asian boy at school solely based on their common ethnic background. After being cautioned that writers and artists are typically poor, she also begins to explore the wisdom of her career choice.

This is a wonderful book to read with, or to, a child. A delightful style to the writing. Children, and adults, can learn Chinese customs and life lessons. The illustrations are a pleasant addition to the story.