5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Luscious pictures, January 15, 2005
This review is from: The Yellow Balloon (Hardcover)
This is to rebut the previous review. Based on that review, I scanned our library copy carefully before checking it out. I found the book delightful and immediately shared it with my children. Some of the "objectionable" pictures are subjectively interepreted--for instance, where the previous reviewer saw an insane man dressed as batman, I merely saw as Batman himself (supported by the fact that if one looks carefully at the pictures, you can also find Little Red Riding Hood and Mary Poppins). I found the nude beach (less than one inch square) but completely missed the "children spying on naked people." The ghosts are teeny and cute. And so on. My children loved looking for the common elements in each beautiful picture. As in any book, look it over yourself and decide if you want your kids to see it. There ARE three or four impaled men in one scene, though, like every other element they are very small. I felt that these tiny images did not detract from a beautiful book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
we LOVE this book, April 10, 2005
This review is from: The Yellow Balloon (Hardcover)
I don't think I have ever written a review but I had to write to offer an opposing opinion to the earlier review. My 4 year old loves this book. We have looked at it more times than I can count and he has never noticed the "impaled people" frankly, neither had I (and I am accused of many of being way over-protective of what my child is exposed to) There are so many things to see and I find it charming overall. Batman is Batman. The lost children are Hansel and Gretel. The skater just has a red design on his shirt and has poor balance. Fire trucks are on the way yo help the people in the fire and there is a life boat helping those from the sinking ship(Titanic?) The witches are having a bonfire. Maybe roasting marshmallows? PLEASE do not write off this book based on one review. Check it out for yourself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Outstanding book to read with your child!, January 19, 2010
This review is from: The Yellow Balloon (Hardcover)
After reading this book, I too felt compelled to post a positive review to counter the ridiculous reviews below. Yes, there are some images, tiny as they may be, that have the potential to mildly trouble an already extremely sheltered child. As a preschool teacher, when I sit down with a child to read a book like this I try to use the much needed unsugar-coated imagery to initiate meaningful conversations with my students. If a child notices the boy who's fallen off his bike on the second page, then perhaps we could talk about the importance of bike safety, wearing your helmet, or better still, mustering the courage to get back up and try again. As for the nudity on a minute portion of the beach page, I for one think it's okay for children to know that naked bodies are good and appropriate in some circumstances, and I don't think an innocent conversation about how mommies and daddies sometimes have pubic hair will forever corrupt a child.
What saddens me most about the previous comments is the reviewers' failure to acknowledge the incredible potential in a book like this. This book is an invitation to sit down with your child and explore the world, answer important questions, acknowledge differences across cultures, and wonder, together, about the beautiful global community in which we all live.
If this book troubles you then I'll spare you the horror and advise you to never read The Busy World of Richard Scary, Where's Waldo, Where the Wild Things Are, The Giving Tree, The Gruffalo, anything by Shel Silverstein, The Three Little Pigs, Little Red Riding Hood, Curious George, and well, just about anything that will hold your child's attention and foster a love for reading.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No