1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not Fish's best work, February 9, 2003
I don't get it! I bought this CD when my interest in prog music resssurfaced in 2002. I thought it would be good to start with a copilation disc to get to know Fish's solo work since he left Marillion. Up til then I only knew his first solo album, Vigil In A Wil;derness Of Mirrors (and I loved it). I was so disappointed with what I heard I almost did not bother to hear his other solo works. Thank God I changed my mind! I found out Fish had released great albuns (even the very underated and much maligned Suits CD).
But Yin is really a mistaken collection. Some of Fish's weakest tracks of all his career are included here (Pipeline, Tongues, Favourite Stranger, Raw Meat are the most obvious), while some of his strongest stuff are completely forgotten. And I still don't understand why he bothered to re-record some of his old Marillion songs. They are fantastic tunes, but they were already perfect recorded with his former band. Besides, most of his fans already have bought all Marillion albums of the 80's.
To be totally honest it would not be fair to say all the tracks are worthless. Just Good Friends is much better here than it appears on the Internal Exile album because it includes Sam Brown's fantastic vocals (the original song cried out to be sung in a duet). The album also includes a interesting re-recording of Boston Tea party with the Sensational Alex Harvey Band backing Fish, which is very nice. And, for the hardcore Marillion fans only, he even recorded a rejected old Marillion song, Institution Waltz. You only have to listen to it one time to understand why it should have been kept in the can.
If you are looking for a good Fish Best of collection I recommed the very well done Kettle Of Fish. This one's not, bar the exceptions I mentioned above. Besides, even his weakest songs are still listenable and not really bad(and that's why I give it a 3 star rating. It should be only 2 really. But, really, I'm a BIG fan...)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fish Yin, May 8, 2011
Prog music is so widespread and within it ranks every now and again an artist comes on sceane. What got my attiontion was that he coverd an old Yes track entilted "Time & The Word." Just a few short weeks ago I was exsploring Youtube and I discovered this song. I thought it was a mispelling of the band Phish who did the cover. After a relentless search I gave up on finding it. Last week on the eons social network in one of my groups it was posted. To be honest this is my first exsperiance with Fish and not my last I think this complation is nothing short of awesome. If you like that dreamie style of Pink Floyd, The Moody Blues or Yes then this is one cd you might want to look into...
- Rick "Uncle Prog" Glenn
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Suprisingly Refreshing !, December 30, 2000
This is a surprisingly refreshing album featuring some of Fish's finest solo tracks. "Family Business" and "Just Good Friends" are truly refreshing and the album flows smoothly from the upbeat "Incommunicado", "Boston Tea Party" and "Tongues" to the touching "Favourite Stranger", "Solo" and the other tracks. Overall a very refreshing album highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No