3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
My heart rejoices!, April 7, 2008
This review is from: You Rejoice My Heart (Hardcover)
This book is written by a Turk who lives and teaches in Germany. It is a story of his search to find Turkish Armenians who masked their Armenian identity. His friendship with a fellow German naturalized citizen, Melanie, is what triggered his curiosity after he discovered she was an Armenian born in Turkey. He made a promise to Melanie, a colleague whom he deeply admired, that he would learn about Armenian history and why Armenians, especially those living in Turkey, felt a need to hide their Armenian heritage.
As an American born to immigrant Armenian parents, I never considered being Armenian as an impediment. I knew opportunities were around every corner, but apparently that is not the case for Armenians living in Turkey. Yalcin's story is a reminder how painful it is for those who are told they don't fit into the everyday mold and feel safer by hiding their heritage. My heart also goes out to American Moslems who abhor the destructive activities of some of their extremist brethren and to light- skinned blacks who, in our recent past, felt opportunities were greater if they passed as whites.
I am grateful to Kemel Yalcin, a Turk who understands the Armenian question and is open to creating dialogue, especially in Turkey. He understands we all belong to this planet earth, whether male or female, old or young, Turk or Armenian or Kurd, Israeli or Palestinian....and whenever there is an exclusion of certain groups from the circle of friendship, there are far sighted ones like Kemel Yalcin who understand that the circle needs to be expanded to enclose everyone.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A critical contribution to the Armenian-Turkish dialogue, November 8, 2008
This review is from: You Rejoice My Heart (Hardcover)
Armenians and Turks have been torn apart by the Armenian genocide of 1915. Since that time, they have been a people completely apart... or so it often seems. The Armenians who were left behind finally get a chance to tell their story - to a Turk who finally thinks to ask, at great risk to himself.
The author exposes so much, educating both Armenians on the outside what it was like for those Armenians who remained in Turkey, who have their own perspective on how to approach Armenian-Turkish reconciliation, and exposes Turks to the real inescapable harm their government policies have caused, often without a great deal of public resistance.
The stories of Armenians being saved among all the destruction, by individual or groups of Turks and Kurds is the ray of hope that shines throughout. People risking their own lives for the "infidel". The many Armenians interviewed who bear no hard feelings are the flip side of the hope for the future. Their stories can be unbearably hard to read - as you learn in excruciatingly personal detail that the genocide that ended for most upon their expulsion into the Syrian desert in 1915, continues to this day for some. Decades of attacks, discrimination and second class legal status took their toll.
I look forward to the day this book becomes required reading for high school students in Turkey and Armenia. The book has been published in both languages already and I cannot tell you how strongly I recommend this book.
Kemal has produced a masterpiece that has been printed in very small numbers so far. It shouldn't be that way, his journey through living history needs to be read by many, because the story that unfolds has to affect anyone that reads it, and will no doubt help heal the rift that it explores.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
