Customer Reviews

Young Gods and Friends

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

Barry Windsor-Smith is my favorite "comic book artist," but his style is such that you have to put those words in quotations because we are talking about somebody who's artistic inspirations are as much Rossetti and the Pre-Raphaelites as Jack Kirby. To reduce this story to a single cute sentence, "Young GODS and Friends" is about deities who owe as much to the stories of Olympians and Germanic god as they do Kirby's "New Gods," placed in a rather Shakespearean situation, and confronted with a female member, Adastra, who has been spending way too much time on Earth. As he announces near the end of Chapter 1, she is back among the gods because "My sister's getting hitched to some schmuck named Prince Hero." Actually, it is Prince Heros, and there begins the tale.

What you have collected in "Young GODS and Friends" are all of the chapters of the early stages of the saga that were published in "BWS: Storyteller," up to the point where BWS suddenly stopped working when the title was cancelled by Dark Horse Comics: the second to last page is almost completely inked, but not colored, and the final page is still mostly rough pencils. Also included are: "The Pizza Story," which serves as prelude introducing Adastra on Earth dealing with one of her worshippers while trying to deliver pizzas; a series of aborted attempts at reviving the Destiny story line; "The Party," a collection of vignettes; and assorted fragments, one of which would constitute an alternative version of a key scene in "The Pizza Story." The result is the complete uncompleted "Young GODS" (The "Adastra in Africa" story published separated was originally intended for Storm of the X-Men, so I count it separately).

I had the first six episodes of "BWS: Storyteller," so it was nice to see what I had missed in being unable to track down the rest of the published issues. Original fans of the series might be disappointed in that this collection does not complete the Young GODS saga, but this was the beginning of a much longer story and BWS was laying down the initial threads of the story (for example, look at the first dozen issues of "Cerebus" and see how you could ever have anticipated the "High Society" storyline). What we have here is the beginning of something and while it is getting interesting it is not yet to the point where we are clearly on to something great.

The idea of "BWS: Storyteller" is the most important one here, because Barry Windsor-Smith's emphasis is clearly on the writing. "BWS: Storyteller" featured "The Freebooters" and "The Paradoxman" in addition to the "Young GODS," and coming up with 32-pages each month was a bit of a strain at times. For those of us who remember being disappointed when the new issue of "Conan the Barbarian" was a reprint or drawn by Gil Kane because young Barry Smith had missed another deadline, there are some pages here that show us what things would have looked like if he had rushed. Of course, "rushed" BWS is still better than what most mere mortals can do, and there are some stunning panels, usually full-page or full-spread, that serve as reminders of what this guy can do as an artist. "Young GODS and Friends" gives us an idea of what he can do as a writer.

Of course, after reading this you have to wonder if companion volumes for "The Freebooters" and "The Paradoxman." Be aware that "Young GODS and Friends" is oversized, so the reproduced pages are the same size as "BWS: Storyteller," the difference being that this is a hardcover collection. So if they come up with companion volumes we can use them to sandwich our original "BWS: Storyteller" comics between.

A few years ago, when I was still collecting comics, I was lucky enough to purchase most of the run of Barry Windsor-Smith: STORYTELLER. BWS: STORYTELLER presented The Young Gods, The Paradoxman, and The Freebooters, three original series written and drawn by Windsor-Smith. I had been a Windsor-Smith since his days as Barry Smith at Marvel comics. I once even owned his infamous debut in the Uncanny X-Men (let's just say his art has come a long, long way from those days).

BSW:STORYTELLER collected several ongoing series by Windsor-Smith, including one known as the "Young Gods." On it's surface it seemed highly derivative of Jack Kirby's "Thor" for Marvel, as well as his "New Gods" and "The Forever People of Supertown" for DC. But that was part of the trick to it all, at least I think it was. You were suppose to think Kirby and then watch as Windsor-Smith put his own little twists on the whole concept of beings who were considered gods.

These were gods who were, as one editorial put it: "sexy, ribald, politically incorrect, and outrageously funny."

The story begins on the eve of the wedding of Prince Heros, a somewhat reluctant groom, who decides he needs to go off carousing one more time before he is forced to settle down. He and his cousin, Strangehands, set out for a little adventure engaging in "dragon chasing." Also along for the ride is the lovely but foul-mouthed Princess Adastra, sister of the bride-to-be. Things don't go quite as planned, of course.

Unfortunately, the series was never completed in its original run. But, this volume collects issues one through 9 plus the previously unpublished issues 10 and 11. It also adds new material created for this edition. Windsor-Smith is not for everyone's tastes, but if you are a fan, this is a must have for your collection.

I remember this book when it was a monthly comic and it looked interesting. I snatched it up when the collection was printed but was sorely disappointed.

The story is unfinished. Worse than that, the book is padded with pages and pages of the author complaining about the publisher.

The story itself, about a race of gods interacting with humans is not even that interesting, certainly not as good as the creator seems to think it is in his pages and pages of complaints.

I have been a fan of Barry Windsor-Smith like most since his talent graced the pages of Conan The Barbarian. I followed him through his Gorblimey Press years, his on and off Marvel years, and Valiant, Image, and Malibu stints. I own and cherish most every print and portfolio Barry Windsor-Smith has ever produced and enjoy studying the art and meaning of them often. But I can honestly and sincerely say that there has been no better piece of art and storytelling to come from the mind and through the Esterbrook Falcon #048 of Barry Windsor-Smith than his Storyteller series. The YoungGods and Friends collection is one third of the proof to that statement. This book not only gives the reader great entertainment, humor, story, and art of the YoungGods series. It gives the reader a glimpse of how much the artist, the storyteller poured into it. It is truly heart and soul. Barry Windsor-Smith has again opened himself up a little bit further as he did in his Opus books to let his fans and his critics see what he goes through to bring fine stories to print. some will have a field day and some like me will enjoy. I believe that most will enjoy and learn from it. Those participating in the field day are stuck in the "KILLBANGBOOM" world of the Images and Marvels of the industry. This is truly an enjoyable book and I for one appreciate its publication. Thus the 5 stars. Oh! The other two thirds of the proof? Pick up the Freebooters collection in August of this year and the Paradoxman collection next year! Then the pudding will be complete.

I had heard good things about Mr. Windsor-Smith's work when I read this, but I was extremely disappointed.

Most of the editorials, instead of being funny or particularly interesting, are pages upon pages of the creator angsting about how horrible his publishers are.

The comics themselves, are difficult to understand until you've read it at least twice, and the humor, supposedly 'adult', instead of being more mature is just a lot of perverted sex jokes that don't get into the more mainstream comics very often.