From School Library Journal
Grade 6 Up–What does it take to be a warrior? Fifteen different fantasy writers offer answers to this question in this well-written and carefully arranged collection of new short stories by experienced writers. Their examples include both males and females fighting physically, mentally, and spiritually; in times ranging from prehistory to World War II; and in distinct settings including Central America, a Russian shtetl, the Near East, Australia, the Sudan, India, the African savannah, and an Irish convent, as well as fantasy worlds. The protagonists are mostly teenagers, some driven by the nature of their world to rise to heroism, others seeking out adventure and potential glory. It is the nature of short-story collections to be uneven, but these selections are almost all strong, with quickly sketched but memorable characters and well-drawn settings. Readers will particularly welcome Pierce's own contribution featuring Kylaia from
Lioness Rampant (S & S, 2003) in her familiar Tortall universe. The other contributors include Bruce Rogers, S. M. and Jan Stirling, Janis Ian, Holly Black, Pamela Service, Esther Friesner, India Edghill, Mike Resnick, Laura Anne Gilman, Margaret Mahy, Doranna Durgin, Rosemary Edghill, Lesley McBain, and Brett Hartinger. This timely and appealing anthology will surely help swell the ranks of teenage fantasy readers.
–Kathleen Isaacs, Towson University, MD Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 7-10. "In this anthology are those who have trained to be warriors and have chosen to turn aside from that path, as well as those who have never trained for it, yet picked up weapons to defend those they loved from some looming threat." Fantasy author Pierce introduces this eclectic mix of 15 stories depicting young people fighting for what they believe--among them, Helen of Troy, who tells an alternate version of her rescue, and Maire, a teenager in an Irish Catholic convent school who invokes great magic to help a Jewish girl escape death during World War II. The contributors will be familiar to fantasy readers: Esther Friesner, Pamela Service, Holly Black, and Pierce herself, to name a few. Grammy winner Janis Ian, who "began writing prose two years ago," also supplies a tale. Story quality is mixed, but genre readers will enjoy the selections, and they'll get some information about their favorite writer in the author profile that rounds out each selection.
Cindy WelchCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved