From Publishers Weekly
Starring an excitingly large and fuzzy bear and a tricycle-riding cub, McCourt's (the Stinky Face books) latest celebrates a parent's love. I love your wild belly laugh—/ so delicious to my ears,/ I'd do my silly face a hundred times/ just to hear it again and again, writes McCourt; Bryant (
God Gave Us You) tamps down the notion of wild, showing a delighted cub rather politely applauding the parent's silly-face routine. More domestic humor follows (I love your never-ending surprises./ Like when you hate broccoli./ Then it's your favorite./ Then you hate it./ Then it's your favorite) and Bryant's well-dressed bears have a wonderful time sledding and splashing and celebrating. McCourt's sweet sentiments will reassure youngest readers, but expressions of love this fervent may make strike some older children as uncomfortably mushy: I love... the warmth of your small body/ and the beautiful beating/ of your perfect little heart. If a book could be a piece of Valentine's Day candy, this would be it. Ages 3–5.
(Jan.) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From School Library Journal
PreSchool-K—A treacly treatise on love. It includes such sentiments as, "It seems impossible that I could love you more each day/but that is what happens./You keep changing and growing and that will never stop./All I can do is hang on for the ride." Despite its moments of humor—"I love your never-ending surprises./Like when you hate broccoli./Then it's your favorite…"—the text bows under the weight of its sentimentality and, in the end, comes off as a laundry list. Bryant's cuddly personified bears, who wear clothes and read books, are appealingly sweet, and are a good match for the text. They often overfill the pages, giving readers a sense of the all-encompassing love they embody. Different seasons are represented, portraying the constancy of the parent's love. Leave this for grandparents to buy as gifts and pick up a copy of Todd Parr's
The I Love You Book (Little, Brown, 2009), which has the humor and universality that this title lacks.—
Amy Lilien-Harper, The Ferguson Library, Stamford, CT Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.