Customer Reviews

Pandemic

5 star:		(110)
4 star:		(31)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(4)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Pandemic is the sort of rare game that appeals both to geeks and to people who like party games. It's relatively lightweight as boardgames go--each player has four moves, and the rules for them are relatively simple. Yet there is a lot of probabilistic strategizing to be done by the folks of that nature.

The game itself is relatively tough. The diseases -- the board -- wins about half the time in my group, and often in very mean and surprising ways. This makes it all the more fun when we win.

Fun game with that unique cooperative element. Teen aged girls loved it as did I, the 40 year old dad. It is a tough game to win, but the level of tension created by the game is quite excellent. Of the half dozen or so games we have played, only one ended where we were just so overwhelmed and lost without even feeling like we had a chance to win. All the other games, the whole table felt like we had a shot at winning and things kept flipping momentum. In a nutshell, good fun.

Every few years a game comes up with an original theme and an original mechanism, rather than just rehashing old ideas. Sometimes however the range at which this game plays well is less than the range that it states it can handle. This game does not have that problem.

This game manages to incorporate and original and interesting theme and mechanism, while playing well (if a little differently) with the entire range of number of players (1-5). While the originality gives this game some extra appeal with the more experienced gamer, the co-operative nature of this game makes it more appealing to the casual player too, who might be less interested in the standard, confrontational game, or a parent looking for a game to play with an older child that would hold their interest.

I purchased this game based on the excellent reviews it has garnered on amazon, and was unfortunately somewhat let down. Don't get me wrong, it's somewhat fun to play, and very unique in that everyone is working together on the same team, but once you realize that its more of a puzzle than a game, everything feels extremely limiting. What I mean by this is that you have to take into account that when you've set up the game, depending on how the deck is shuffled, you may or may not be able to finish ("win") the game, even if you make all the right moves. Let me rephrase this:


****** like Solitaire, skill alone is not enough win this game, the deck HAS to be shuffled such that the game is finishable, and you'll have no way of knowing this til the game is over ******


I found this aspect of Pandemic to be extremely frustrating, and any game affcionado would probably do well to take this into account when considering a purchase. That being said, it is still a fun concept, and with a little tweaking of the rules, could probably be made to be a lot of fun to play. As for me, I put my copy of this on ebay and haven't looked back.

Length:: 3:08 Mins

Pandemic is fantastic family fun!
It's a cooperative board game that has everyone trying to beat the game - you either all win or all lose. With only 1 way to win and multiple ways to lose - it sure keep you on your toes.

And as you can see from our video review - our 6 yr old can understand and play right along with the rest of the family.

But be careful, because it's addicting too. When you lose, you'll just want to start all over again. And when you win, you'll want to increase the difficulty level and try again. Of course, we have yet to win on the highest difficulty level.

Pandemic immediately earned a spot as one of our top 10 family games.

You can also read more about our impressions on our family game review site TheBoardGameFamily.

With those words, we knew we were in for an interesting night. I had done plenty of personal research before taking a bite out of boardgaming. As a confessed die-hard video gamer, and a vicious competitor, board games never did it for me. The heads-up multiplayer cutthroat style always left me a little wanting for something either more fun or at the very least, "less competitive." Pandemic, billed as a fully cooperative game, seemed to fit the bill.

The rules came neatly printed on an 8 page full color pamphlet. Setting up the game required some careful reading, but was relatively painless. With a couple of well shuffled decks, the original "disease cubes" in place, our intrepid two man team set out to save the world.

Like most turn based games, there's a lot of cross-talk and strategy that goes into each move. Once the general concepts were grasped, however, board movement and action selection were very swift. The mechanics of the game do a wonderful job of creating tension. Epidemics -- the critical event that drives the threat and tension of Pandemic -- come at fairly pre-set times. Once an Epidemic hits, all of the disease cards that were played to that point get reshuffled and go back on top of the deck. This immediately creates rising tension, as you know what's going to happen, and do your best, as a team, to stop it.

Even with only two players, not enough can be said about the cooperative element. Every character can, in some way, feel essential to the core game and makes each player feel special -- that they have a direct ability to contribute. While my friend was handling strategy and deployment, I was hustling around the world curing cities to stop future outbreaks. You're always keeping one step ahead of the next outbreak -- when a disease hits critical mass in a city and then spreads the infection to surrounding cities.

After an hour (given that the first fifteen minutes were spent making sure we knew what was going on, the target time for experienced gamers is dead on) we had everything under control. We had eradicated both the 'blue' and 'yellow' strains, and noticed immediately the in-game reward -- once you eradicate a disease, no new cubes of that type may be played, which limits the threat you face, and those cards remain in the deck. It gives you a little breathing room. That left us with the Black and Red strains, and we had found the cure for the black strain.

Then, we reshuffled the player deck, but didn't redistribute the Epidemic cards in the correct order. Drawing two epidemics back to back, all of India immediately succumbed to the strain, and collapsed under a pile of black cubes. Despite having lost out first attempt, probably to a rules bit that we couldn't find -- no where did we see how to 'reshuffle' the player deck -- the game was remarkably fun and engaging.

It is easy to learn, there are no heavy nuances to master, but little intracies that will make you more successful as you go on. Please review the rules carefully, to avoid common pitfalls, and know that you may not win, but you will have a pretty great time. If I were to give one piece of advice:

* Remember to populate the board fully with disease counters,
* That you only draw AFTER your turn, and
* Remember to always take an Infection Phase

Well worth the purchase.

This is a good American made Co-operative board game. 2-4 players work together to rid the world of 4 infections that have started taking over the world. Players move around the world, exchanging information, cleaning up cities and ultimately curing diseases. An interesting game mechanic is used where each game will have a different set of cities that the infection is constantly going after.

One issue this game has which many co-operative ones can have is that an experienced player can easily start to just tell less experienced players what to do instead of letting them play on their own. In my game group we actually don't allow for talking, but you can show your hand of cards to others in the same city as you.

Rather than simply review the game from my perspective, I'm going to try to address some of the negative reviews I read, since I think it's important to understand how cooperative gameplay works and a lot of people (at least in my part of the US) don't have a really clear gasp of that which ruins their enjoyment of games like Pandemic.

- The game is "cooperative". This doesn't mean that one player dictates what everyone does and it definitely doesn't mean that the players ARGUE over what to do next which multiple reviewers said were major issues with the game. You will spend a fair amount of time discussing what to do next but, if you're doing this right, it's more than half the fun. Cooperative games can only be fun if you have the right group of players. If you have one or two players trying to dominate everyone else, or if no one can agree with others no matter what, it won't be fun for anyone else.

- A bad shuffle can absolutely RUIN your chances of winning the game. anyone who's played it is probably painfully aware of this fact :D In fact, even when the cards manage to end up in an order that makes things easier on the players, it can still feel unwinnable at times. But, if you can win a game every time, what's the fun in playing? The truth is that losing doesn't even make the evening less fun, unless you take your gaming a little more seriously than I do. I've played and laughed with the other players over getting the human race wiped out more than once in the same evening ("Oh, man, the jedis are going to feel that."/"Yeah, well, humanity had it coming...").

Okay, now that those are out of the way, have some actual specifics.

In Pandemic, you and the other players try to prevent the spread of a series of infectious outbreaks that will eventually wipe out humanity if you do not both:
- contain outbreaks as they occur
- find a cure for all four strains of disease
Your attention is constantly being drawn away from finding a cure by the fact that new infections just KEEP OCCURRING. And heaven help you if multiple infections occur in adjoining locations or you draw an outbreak card.

Pandemic is fast-paced, nail-biting, maddeningly frustrating (in a good way!), and will probably have you kicking yourself in hindsight more than once. If these are things you like, why haven't you played Pandemic yet? If they're turn offs, then you definitely want to give this game a miss.

My husband and I are avid board gamers and this game has fit nicely into our weekly game line-ups. It's so nice to be on the same side and play cooperatively.

This game is particularly suited for couples who are just starting to play games together because it mitigates one of the sometimes un-fun aspect of playing a game versus your spouse: resentment, feeling like your spouse is attacking you, feeling like your spouse is way better than you, etc.... Since you're working together, the potential for hurt feelings is significantly lessened!

Also, we've played this with our monthly board game group and they have loved it as well. Plays well as two-player on up!

Pandemic is a cooperative game, where all the players are attempting to wipe out four world epidemics at once. It was a successful Christmas present to a 13 year old, and we have has a player as young as 8 playing with more experienced players successfully.

That said, we haven't won a game yet, but it is still fun to play. It is played with real cities representing areas of the world, and has a pretty good model of disease spread.

For kids of all ages who are ready to move up from the more widely played board games, this is a great next step, on a par with the classics Risk or Diplomacy.