4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Shockingly Incomplete, July 5, 2008
This review is from: ZAGAT Texas Restaurants 2008 (Zagatsurvey Texas Restaurants) (Paperback)
The Zagat's 2008 "Texas Restaurants" guide should be renamed the Austin/Dallas/Houston/San Antonio guide. The medium sized metropolitan areas (El Paso, Abilene, Waco, Amarillo, Killeen, etc) are completely excluded, as are destination towns like Salado or Fredericksburg. What is puzzling is that the information is on their webpage. Why not include a "best of the rest" section? Given the Zagat methodology, the exclusion must be intentional - they simply don't see fit to expand the survey beyond the I-35 corridor.
Space is a serious consideration. While smaller cities get their own guidebooks, four of the largest cities in the entire country are crammed into one volume. The culinary scene in Dallas has exploded over the past five years. How is it possible that Connecticut, St. Louis, and the New Jersey Shore have their own guidebooks, but Dallas has to share billing? The same could be said of the three other cities. The Texas Hill Country alone could be a guide much like some of the other regional ones Zagats publishes.
The result is that that guide tends to list newer openings rather than established local favorites. The list for Austin was shockingly incomplete. Likewise Houston and Dallas felt very light. There were well known places that didn't make the book, rendering it useless for someone who is looking for an authentic experience rather than the trendy latest openings.
Another serious flaw is that regional chains only get one review for all four cities. If you are looking for a review of the location in Austin, you might be redirected to the review of the Dallas location. This might work for small chains all operating in the same city, but to propose that there is no discernable difference in price, décor, quality and service between restaurants that are hundreds of miles apart is ridiculous.
I could only recommend this to someone on an extended business trip or vacation along the I-35 corridor who has never been here before. If you really want to get a flavor for Texas, look online at some of the great city scene websites or thumb through back issues of Texas Monthly.
Just like the old salsa commercial, don't be caught dead trying to explore the culinary landscape with a guide book published by folks from New York City.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No