66 of 73 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
How Could I Be Such A Fool, November 22, 2004
Too much of this book, especially the first two thirds, is simply a history of events, i.e., Frank did this and then he did that. Sometimes the facts are jumbled: he and his first wife are separated, then a few pages later Frank's parents move in with them. The biggest let down is the discovery that nothing in this book is the result of primary research. No one--no one!!!!--was interviewed by the author in this endeavor. So this reads kind of like a competent college research paper based on other research. Miles provides us with notes of his many sources, including some of his own interviews from 30 years ago, but its mostly all stuff that's been out there in other books and magazines and websites. When he finally gets around to drawing some actual conclusions of his own, its mostly to tell us Zappa's Catholic upbringing made him a pervert or Zappa was a fairly heartless capitalist without feelings for his bandmates or Zappa was a misogynist recluse or Zappa sabotaged his serious work with titles too pornagraphic for ears. Crimeny, you'll wonder why anybody would care about the guy. By the end of the book, however, Miles seems to be contradicting himself by reciting all of the accolades Zappa received throughout his career from everyone from the Chieftains to Eastern European statesmen. Let's see, he's a soulless capitalist taskmaster pervert but meanwhile he's courted by band directors, musicians, and statesmen. I'd like to have read more about the upside. I'd recommend that you skip this book, save your money and go buy another Zappa album instead.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Could my hero actually have any flaws? Say it aint so, Joe!, April 20, 2005
I enjoyed the book, and felt that it was successful in what it attempted to do, describing and analyzing Frank's life with its ups and downs. I'm a Zappa fan, and I learned a lot of new info.
Zappa's biggest fans, like fans of any highly-talented unique person, have fervent devotion. As such, it's completely predictable that even the smallest criticism will be categorically rejected by these fans. Just look at the Online Devotion Forums for any artist - as soon as anyone gets off the track of total adulation, others will swoop in and even start flaming until the worship gets back on track.
I like Frank's music very much. I've played some of his tunes in bands. He's hilarious, too. But having heard him interviewed on the radio, seen his bands several times, and having read his comments in print, I'm not shocked that he may be just a wee bit controlling, possibly a little self-centered, and may have preferred machines to humans. I have read and enjoyed Frank's autobiography a couple times and enjoyed it too. But could Frank be just a little low on introspection? Maybe. Do many autobiographers write in a self-serving manner? Just possibly.
I also noticed the oft-quoted time sequence problem in the book. Does this, in and of itself, nullify all the contents? No, it just means that the author and editor messed up. Nearly all the new books I read have loads of typos and other problems. It's clear that editors don't get the time they need to do the job all that well anymore. But that's a universal problem that's not specific to this book.
This is a biography. If we have nothing but praise, it would be a puff piece, or press release. Miles does attempt to analyze Zappa's motives, and takes a stab at finding clues to them in his background. Does he speculate? Yes, that's what biographers do. Short of analyzing the person's brain and seeing a word-for-word copy of everything that ever happened, nobody really knows anyone's motives. You can't even take the person's word for it in many cases. So you have to take a chance and speculate based on observation.
Miles lavishes praise on many things Zappa did. I guess a lot of people just didn't notice. Those who want their biographies to have blind adulation without questioning anything, and without any critical analysis - this is just the type of person that Frank strafed with his lyrics.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A cut and paste job, December 7, 2004
The other reviewers have already said this in so many words, but the fault of this book is that there is nothing new in it. IT is a cut and paste job pure and simple. Even his opinions, such as that liberal comedians don't so much talk truth to power as they do mock their own liberal mores come from otherbooks. If you've read the other Zappa books and are well read generally you don't need to read this book -- you could have written it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No