Customer Reviews

Zen in the Martial Arts

5 star:		(94)
4 star:		(18)
3 star:		(5)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(6)

 

 

First I'd like to address a couple of criticisms that I read here that this book is rather superficial and doesn't get into Zen concepts in depth. That's true, this book is really only an intro to Zen--if you're already knowledgeable then this book will probably be too basic. However, for the beginner there is no better place to start, and as someone else here observed, the quotes from Bruce Lee are almost worth the price of the book by themselves.

Joe Hyams started his karate training back in 1952 with Ed Parker--a full ten years or more before the craze got started in America. He had the opportunity to train with such greats as Bruce Lee, Bong Soo Han, Ed Parker, and Jim Lau from the very beginning. Joe encountered many trials and tribulations, frustrations, and disappointments during his training, but he never gave up. One reason is he often had the opportunity to discuss his problems with the many great teachers he trained under, and they often offered their wisdom and insights to help him through the difficult times. He took that wealth of personal experience and knowledge and put it all into this little book.

Hyams gives a very clear, concise, and easy to understand introduction to Zen in the martial arts. The discussions are often illustrated and liberally peppered with fun anecdotes from his personal experiences with different masters, making this almost a personal journey through the dojos and minds of some of the most famous martial artists of our time. Hyams writes very well (he was a famous Hollywood screenwriter) and so rather than another dry, obscure, Zen philosophy tome, the book sounds more like an intimate conversation with a friend over a glass of wine and dinner. It sounds like he's personally talking right to you.

Hyams touches on so many concepts that I won't try to discuss them much here. But I will mention probably the most important one--which is persistence. Hyams points out that it often isn't the most talented and gifted student that achieves the most in the martial arts--since they often quit the first time they encounter a serious difficulty--since they're so used to everything coming so easy. Rather, it's the person who often has very little going for him physically, and has the patience and perseverance to stick it through to the end.

I'll mention just one other important principle. This relates to the Zen idea of living in the moment, especially when training, but also in everything else one does in life. Don't allow other concerns, however pressing or important, to weigh on your mind and distract you when you're training. Concentrate on living in the present moment and you'll make the most of your training--and of all the other activities in your life. Someone who's always worried about their other concerns can't truly live in the present, and therefore will never truly enjoy or make the most of whatever activity they're engaged in. Part of their mind is always somewhere else. Strive to always live in the now, in the present moment.

Interestingly enough, this idea has been confirmed by modern psychological research. If you have concerns that worry you, don't allow them to bother you to the point where you're thinking about them all the time. The best way to deal with this, it's been found, is to set aside some time each day--they recommend 10, 15, or 20 minutes at most--where, if you need to--go ahead and worry yourself sick about it. Then put it out of your mind and enjoy the rest of your day. Another important thing you can do during this time is to not just worry about everything but to put some constructive thought into how to better deal with your problems. Sometimes you won't have a good idea about how to do that for a while, for days, maybe weeks, but don't let that get you down. Remember the other principle of persistence I mentioned earlier. Stick it through to the end.

Realistically, life is never as bad as it seems to us during our darkest and most depressed moments--nor as wonderful as it seems during our happiest, most ecstatic moments. It's somewhere in between. The point here is that one should also cultivate the proper attitude--since that's often the only thing one has total control over in one's life. If you're the sort of person for whom even little things get you down--which is more of us than we would like to admit--then strive to be more objective. The little things can't really hurt you. They're just annoying psychologically because they bruise our egos a little bit. Save your emotional energy for the really big problems in your life, instead--because there will be more than enough of those. Cultivate a positive, upbeat attitude so that the little things are practically beneath your notice. Let them slide off you like water off a duck's back. This is also another important Zen principle--that too much ego impedes our progress in the martial arts--and our path through life as well.

Well, I've gone on longer than I intended, but this book is so chock full of useful little tidbits of advice that I got a little carried away. So I'll just conclude by reiterating that Hyams has written a great little introduction to Zen concepts as applied to the martial arts. But perhaps even more important is that they can be applied beneficially to every other area of your life.

I bought this book as a kid at 16 just being introduced to martial arts. 20 years later, I can still say, after college and an adult life filled to overflow that this book, among the hundreds I have read that touch on similar subjects, is STILL the best book of it's class. It is modern, unlike Sun Tzu or Samurai literature, and that is the book's strength. Samurais did not have the tedium of modern life to contend with: boardroom meetings, petty office jobs that lend life no meaning, mindless commercialized, propagandized media buzzing all around us. Samurai did not live in our world of wasting time and energy on nothing. They had time to get dressed and take their time, breathe clean air, and be human, and that is what Zen in the Martial Arts attempts to do, restore that balence to a martial artist's lifestyle...in a Modern world, however, not in some remote past. And that is why this book is in a class of it's own. Many try to approach this focal point without success, but none in my opinion succeed in so few pages or in such inspiring, heart-to-mind immediacy as Hyams manages. It may not seem important to a souless, bloodless academic, but to many a martial artist for several generations it simply is without peer.

There is nothing New Age or ridiculous about this book. I feel sorry for the people who don't understand how to appreciate it. This is written by a man who was deeply affected by Bruce Lee, most likely the greatest modern kung fu exponent of our age, because Lee was a kung fu warrior who lived in the world of hype and electrified delusion and he could see through it, even while using what it had to offer. Hollywood nothing. The only thing even remotely Hollywood about this book is the fact that Bruce Lee had been in Hong Kong Films and starred on a TV pilot that immediately replaced him before airing the actual show because Lee, as an actual Chinese, was "too Chinese" (meaning a white guy needed to interpret a Chinese for us whites). Wow. That's so Hollywood of you, Bruce.

On the reality side, Hyams transmits the inspirational genius that was everything in Bruce Lee. How to be fluid, like water, like the yin and yang of the Tao. How to dare to will to control one's own life. Yes, ignoring dental pain is possible... So what? Pain can be ignored. This is not the point of this book.

There is, however, an abundance of stories about people who overcame their fears and anxieties and their lacking to go on to open up the horizon in their world. This is a book about taking control and navigating one's life, as a martial artist, as a warrior in the modern world, toward freedom of the spirit. It reminds us that we are alive and that we can do pretty much anything that we really WANT or need to do, not really about something so trivial and pointless as "going to the dentist without anesthetic". The emphasis is on freedom to get what we need and want out of life, not on merely testing ourselves through performing superhuman feats. Maybe for the Moderns in Hyams time and place, knee deep in the modernity of the late 60's and early 70's, it really did take such feats to convert a following, to shake off the certain medical materialism of the times. Today I think everyone has seen the guru walk on hot coals. Everyone has suspicions about authority. Everybody wonders what they could do and fantasizes about the nature of true experiential freedom, yet they do not usually follow through with it toward their own potential in the same manner Lee was fully advocating.

What's truly remarkable is that someone showed Moderns of his time that they could walk red hot coals of modernity delusion completely unscathed, turn toward the world, wink, and then disappear from it's grasp into their own freedom, their own use of their own time, space and lives.

In this book, Joe Hyams sheds light on obscure facets of our personality, many of which we are not even aware of. Why are we so anxious, why do we fear pain, why are we so eager to show our force to others, why do we have to go through daily confrontations with our family, spouse, colleages ? Through a short but clear description of the issues that make our lives sometimes difficult and a thorough analysis of the mental process involved in overcoming them, Joe Hyams explains all the internal revolutions that a sound mentality can create in human beings. Non martial artists will find in this book some answers to those questions they have always been asking themselves about their behavior and how to make the most out of their lives. Martial artists will be exposed to the Zen aspects of martial arts, which is probably essential to a mastery of these disciplines. As a beginner in Shotokan-Karate, I found this book enlightening on some issues that take a life-long to master and even understand. The simple examples given in this work allows the reader to have a general understanding of the Zen principles behind martial arts and behind everyday life.

I strongly recommend this book, both to martial artists and to others, it will land you on the ground and make you understand that your way to happiness is still long and wanderous but may be stated in simple words understandable by all. The Zen principles and adages punctuating the book also constituate a good volume of meat for the mind.

Thank you for reading through. Stephane

As an avid student of the Martial Arts (Taekwondo), I read this book before every test, every tounament, and any other chance I got. This book is good reading for all, even if your not a student of the Martial Arts.

In Zen in the Martial Arts, Joe Hyam's uses the backdrop of the martial arts and his many unique experiences to show us all the way to a better, more rewarding life. By sharing his experiences with such martial art legends as Bruce Lee, Ed Parker and Bong Soo Han as well as many of Hollywood's biggest stars Hyam's presents in an engaging way the principles of Zen that lead to greater control and inner peace. Even those who are not fans of the martial arts will appreciate the unique and interesting stories that captivate and teach. Each chapter focuses on a life lesson learned in such an engaging way that I find myself reading this book again and again -- each time gleaning a little more of the wisdom in it. I am amazed at the number of times I thumb back through for a favorite passage or thought. A worthy addition to the library of anyone who seeks for greater direction and understanding in their life -- I would recommend Zen in the Martial Arts highly

I was amazed to see the negative reviews listed here. So many people seem to have missed the point and to have fixated on the people Joe trained with rather than what the book is about. It sounds as if their own egos are in their way. This book was definitely NOT about name-dropping, but some people have such a narrow view of the world that this was all they saw.

Anyway, this has been a favorite book of mine since it first came out. It is one of the most down to earth books on oriental philosophy available in the English language. I highly recommend it to anyone with an interest in the subject (except, perhaps, those who are already advanced Zen adepts with no need for simple books *wink*).

The real beauty of Mr. Hyams' book is that--unlike his often ad hominem and jingoistic contemporaries--he has sought out and shared the wisdom and insight one can obtain through martial arts training without putting the techniques of one person, style, or country above others.

When Hyams' asserts that the principal goal of martial arts training is to defeat the antagonist that resides within yourself, he turns his back on the ubiquitous 'do unto others before they do unto you' martial arts curriculum and gently leads the reader toward introspection, reflection, and insight.

Over the past 17 years, I have returned to this book again and again. Each time, I come away with something new and useful. There are only a handful of books in my ever growing library that I can say that about.

Many have criticized Mr. Hyams' book because it is not an exhaustive thesis on the subject. To these persons I would ask, could anyone possibly write an exhaustive treatment of this subject?

This was an interesting read. However, I consider the title somewhat misleading given the author's stated purpose for the book as disclosed in chapter one: "...this is a book from which readers may learn to apply the principles of Zen, as reflected in the martial arts, to their lives and thus open up a potential source of inner strength they may never have dreamt they possessed" (pg. 3). It appears that he learned about Zen through his experience with the martial arts and, through this book, is attempting to give Zen a broader application so that one can reap some general metaphysical benefits from Zen without ever becoming a martial artist or even a Zen Buddhist. The author notifies the reader in chapter one that this book isn't for those who wish to master either Zen or the amazing physical feats of more advanced martial artists. The book is for those (martial artists or not) who want a simple, general introduction to the spiritual/mental side of the martial arts for broader applications. This approach has its critics since some may think that he superficially covers Zen's application to the martial arts in his attempt to give it a broader application. This book does not expound in detail the philosophy and/or religion of Zen Buddhism although it does contain some practical concepts related to Zen and life in general. One doesn't have to be a Buddhist or martial artist to appreciate the practical wisdom he shares, but if one wants more details regarding either Zen Buddhism or the martial arts, one is better served looking elsewhere.

A very easy read I finished it in one night and plan to read it again. In todays world of Ultimate Fighting Championships, and a greater emphsis on the street fighting aspects of martial arts, it was a great reminder of what the true meaning and purpose of martial arts are. I have been invloved in the street fighting aspect of the arts for the last couple of years and I think it has hurt my character more than helped it. After reading this inspirational book I plan to seek out a school that has a strong mental and spiritual side. It is amazing that often the solutions to today's problems are often better solved with a thousand year old philosophy than by some pill. Very highly reccomended for anyone not just martial artists!

Excellent book!!! I have read this book many times over the three years I have been in Taekwondo. I learn something new each time I read it. In fact I would say I have learned more from it as a black belt than I did as a white belt. This book gives insights to enhance your daily living as well as in your martial arts training. This book is required reading for all 1st Degree Black Belt-Recommended at my Dojang. I think it should be required reading for ALL martial artists!